Oppo Camp Dangerfield's Gone (Zero tolerance to trolling) - READ THREAD LINKED IN OP BEFORE POSTING

[Footy Smarts]

maybe i should have said the geelong posters that i respect rate gore > murdoch

Perhaps you should reconsider your respect for them because rating him above Murdoch is madness. Murdoch's played some very good AFL footy but is still developing. Gore's played a few good VFL games and that's it.

 

[hippyhippy]

****... pies got way more for beams... shit deal if it's true

 

[6BTS]

Would you guys be happy with Dean Gore?

No

 

[Golumless]

****... pies got way more for beams... shit deal if it's true

They didn't. (Got 5, 25 and Crisp who had played 18 games in 3 years for one of the worst sides in the league).

It only seems like more because the young player they got ended up having a break out year and they drafted fantastically.

 

[Brentmeister]

If it's Pick 9, 28 and Gore, that's about the most we can hope for.

The fact that Geelong fans are melting over there at the prospect of that deal is a decent sign.

 

[WhiskeyTangoFoxtrot]

I'd take the compensation over that bullshit.

If you are getting 3 players in for the one, I reckon a draft pick is coming out too.

Ummm, one of the picks is Pick 9 which, by itself, is better than the compo pick.

 

[hippyhippy]

5 and 25 is much better than 9 and 28 for starters.

 

[PAFC_1870]

They didn't. (Got 5, 25 and Crisp who had played 18 games in 3 years for one of the worst sides in the league).

It only seems like more because the young player they got ended up having a break out year and they drafted fantastically.

How is that not more?

5 > 9
25 > 28
Crisp with 18 Games >>>>>>> Gore

Than you add the minor detail that Beams isn't as good as Danger... and Beams wasn't the best player in his team.

 

[NikkiNoo]

5 and 25 is much better than 9 and 28 for starters.

We can't help that the destination club finished higher on the ladder than Brisbane did the previous year.

 

[hippyhippy]

It should be 2 firsts or nothing.

 

[PAFC_1870]

Ummm, one of the picks is Pick 9 which, by itself, is better than the compo pick.

Sure, if you wanna keep up the pushover tag.

No prize to get a deal done in the first morning.

 

[baldandbroke]

If it's Pick 9, 28 and Gore, that's about the most we can hope for.

The fact that Geelong fans are melting over there at the prospect of that deal is a decent sign.

Absolutely - was always a going to be a good way to test the deal. Both fans screaming that their clubs go soft at the trade table !!

 

[Elite Crow]

We can't help that the destination club finished higher on the ladder than Brisbane did the previous year.

This is it, where was Geelong going to get pick 5 from? Pick 9 is a top 10 pick.

 

[RedvestMan]

Don't think that trade is as bad as it looks. The kid will be on bugger all money so we will have a war chest and picks 9 & 13 to try and land a bigger fish.

 

[Adz2332]

hold out!

 

[baldandbroke]

Sure, if you wanna keep up the pushover tag. No prize to get a deal done in the first morning.

I'm not sure why you see us as the push-over tag - or who sees it that way? There is a reason to get the deal done early - it will give both clubs a real chance with other trades in the period.

 

[jenny61_99]

I wish people wouldn't ****ing compare who got what for whom.

Hawthorn got next to nothing for Buddy and Geelong got little for Ablett. Treloar may well go for two first rounders. Collingwood definitely got overs for Beams. You have to take into account that we would have received compo pick 14 if they'd gone the free agency route and we didn't match. It appears they haven't gone the free agency route, and a trade is being fleshed out. If we can get pick 9, pick 28 and Gore (for example), we'll have two first round picks, and two second round picks to further trade or use in the draft. We are infinitely better off than if we'd picked up 14 alone (ie. no top 10 pick), or made him enter the draft for nothing.

 

[Stiffy_18]

If it's 9, 28 and Gore, I might be able to live with it with the emphasis on might.

However if it's only pick 9 and 28 or pick 9 and Gore, I would be livid!

 

[hippyhippy]

Don't think that trade is as bad as it looks. The kid will be on bugger all money so we will have a war chest and picks 9 & 13 to try and land a bigger fish.

Bigger fish.. lol.. we cant even sell our biggest fish for the market value.

 

[jenny61_99]

It should be 2 firsts or nothing.

So you cut off your nose to spite your face.

 

[NikkiNoo]

I wish people wouldn't ******* compare who got what for whom.

Hawthorn got next to nothing for Buddy and Geelong got little for Ablett. Treloar may well go for two first rounders. Collingwood definitely got overs for Beams. You have to take into account that we would have received compo pick 14 if they'd gone the free agency route and we didn't match. It appears they haven't gone the free agency route, and a trade is being fleshed out. If we can get pick 9, pick 28 and Gore (for example), we'll have two first round picks, and two second round picks to further trade or use in the draft. We are infinitely better off than if we'd picked up 14 alone (ie. no top 10 pick), or made him enter the draft for nothing.

I will wait and see the complete end result from the whole trading period and what we are doing with those picks before I throw my toys out of the pram, if that is the deal.

I would prefer two firsts and a Gore, but as you said that is better than just pick 14 or nothing.

 

[NikkiNoo]

Bigger fish.. lol.. we cant even sell our biggest fish for the market value.

Of course we can't - he is a RFA and there are caveats on it to make sure he gets where he wants to.

 

[PAFC_1870]

Don't think that trade is as bad as it looks. The kid will be on bugger all money so we will have a war chest and picks 9 & 13 to try and land a bigger fish.

You don't find bigger fish suddenly out of nowhere during the trade period....

 

[Golumless]

How is that not more?

5 > 9
25 > 28
Crisp with 18 Games >>>>>>> Gore

Than you add the minor detail that Beams isn't as good as Danger... and Beams wasn't the best player in his team.

It's a minor improvement but as it's still a 1st, 2nd and promising youngster it's not heaps more as stated, it's more it's the market value for a star player who wants to go home.

 

[jenny61_99]

Bigger fish.. lol.. we cant even sell our biggest fish for the market value.

Because he's not actually for sale. Why don't people get that?