Daniel Cross v James McDonald

[closie4]

Both great tacklers, courageous and possesion winners.

 

[Blacky]

More upside to Cross I reckon...
Massive engine and slightly better skills.

 

[Neutral_observer]

McDonald easily


The most underrated player in the AFL

 

[Top Dog]

Cross!

Absolute machine. I love this man.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

McDonald by the proverbial country mile.

He should be All-Australian this year.

 

[swjmfc]

Cross can't kick over a jam tin.

Junior getting the job done every week. No longer the AFL's "most underrated player".

 

[Benny_]

The only reason i picked Cross cause he has played only 60 odd games and i think there is still a fair bit of improvement in him. At this stage McDonald easily and will win Melbourne's B&F quite easily i believe.

 

[Hard Ball Get]

Cross for me.
Hardest worker at the club by a mile and the results show.
Racks up the touches, tackles and clearances.

 

[tomthetiger]

Cross can't kick over a jam tin.

Junior getting the job done every week. No longer the AFL's "most underrated player".

Nah, hes definately still the most underrated imo.

 

[HeLMie]

McDonald easily


The most underrated player in the AFL

Still observing nuetrally i see.

 

[TizzaBlues]

100% cross. The next Scott West.

 

[demonfire]

Cross for me.
Hardest worker at the club by a mile and the results show.
Racks up the touches, tackles and clearances.

nothing different to mcdonald. infact i'd say mcdonald is equally as good if not better in all those areas.

average disposals
cross 25.6
mcdonald 23.9

tackles
cross 6.6
mcdonald 7.1

clearances
cross 2.9
mcdonald 4.4

1%ers
cross 3.9
mcdonald 5.7

plus mcdonald is accountable for the oppositions best midfielder week in and week out.

 

[Neutral_observer]

nothing different to mcdonald. infact i'd say mcdonald is equally as good if not better in all those areas.

average disposals
cross 25.6
mcdonald 23.9

tackles
cross 6.6
mcdonald 7.1

clearances
cross 2.9
mcdonald 4.4

1%ers
cross 3.9
mcdonald 5.7

plus mcdonald is accountable for the oppositions best midfielder week in and week out.

Cant believe the thread starter compared Cross to the mighty Junior McDonald


A more valid comparison would have been Cross vs Simon Godfrey

 

[cezzz]

Crossy's kicking has improved immensley this year. He's probably kicked 10 goals this year.

 

[closie4]

Cant believe the thread starter compared Cross to the mighty Junior McDonald


A more valid comparison would have been Cross vs Simon Godfrey

Then why is he winning the votes

 

[demondude]

most ppl will obviously pick cross because hes younger & has area to improve, though mcdonald would be leading our b&f by ****loads & yes definetely the most underated in the afl. hoping he gets AA definetely deserves it

 

[jimmy_c8]

McDonald for me

 

[demonfire]

Then why is he winning the votes

because mcdonald is underrated. if he was winning he wouldn't be underrated now, would he?

 

[Major Colvin]

Cant believe the thread starter compared Cross to the mighty Junior McDonald


A more valid comparison would have been Cross vs Simon Godfrey

Godfrey would win that.

 

[Woodstock..]

Cross

 

[X_box_X]

Cross is a real workhorse. Strong mark. Incredibly courageous. Definitely Cross the Boss for mine.

 

[Neutral_observer]

Then why is he winning the votes

because this is BigFooty

 

[Belly]

because this is BigFooty

Great point, we need more members of your stagering intellect and completely unbiased comments.

 

[Neutral_observer]

Great point, we need more members of your stagering intellect and completely unbiased comments.

Agree 100%

 

[The Dustbin]

Cross.