Essendon List , my views

[DaSawx]

I can't see Winderlich getting delisted, he was in our best 22 before his injury

 

[go_the_bombers]

I can't see Winderlich getting delisted, he was in our best 22 before his injury

I'd give Winderlich another year to prove himself

 

[Longy413]

Winderlich won't get delisted. He'll stay.

But at the very least, he'll have some trade value.

 

[Daytripper]

Good assessment except you were wrong on NLM. Started the season as our best defender and was excellent for the fisrt 10-12 weeks. His suspension cost him and he has lost form - but that was when we were getting smashed and most were playing ****ehouse.

He's only been back one week.

 

[go_the_bombers]

Winderlich won't get delisted. He'll stay.

But at the very least, he'll have some trade value.

Which teams do u think Longy would take Winderlich?

 

[DaSawx]

I can't see why we should trade him when we wouldn't get any higher than a 3rd round pick for him. He was beggining to come into his own before his injury, drafting someone new to take his place just takes us back to square one

 

[ant555]

Don't think he's lost his passion for the game, and he;ll be only 29 at the start of the year. Why would he retire?

The surgery he had to fix his toe wasnt as sucessful as they had hoped and it is still giving him some trouble. He probably wont retire but there has been some talk around suggesting it may happen.

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

I can't see Winderlich getting delisted, he was in our best 22 before his injury

I'm not quite sure if he was in our best 22. Didn't he get dropped or started in the vfl. If we had a good run with injuries would he be in our best 22?

He played a few good games before hisinjury and looked like he could be part of the best 22.

Not in there just yet but I was quite happy to see him string a few good games together.

Jury is still out though.

 

[ant555]

thank god some of the people who post here dont make any decisions down at essendon

LOL i have often thought the same about some of your comments

 

[nipst@r]

Botls or peveril?

Winderlich was previouly mentioned (rough i know) but he is the oldest out of the other possibilites. (solly, mj jj should not be considered in my opinion for trade or delist)

out of bolts or peveril i'd actually prefer bolts to stay, if its out of him and pev for the last spot and trades can not be worked out. Pev doesnt have much of a spot now with mcveigh,slattery and nash, he also doesn't give a lot to depth wheras bolton at least gives us another much needed option to play on the goodes, kouta types or as a decoy hard working forward. Altough i do think its best if bolts moves on from essendon, and i actually believe he would have more trade value than peveril. Thoughts?