Essendon OR Richmond OR Carlton (under 23 team)

[jetta2davey]

Carlton

B: Joe Anderson Michael Jamison Paul Bower

HB: Dennis Armfield Mark Austin Andrew Walker

C: Kade Simpson Adam Bentick Shaun Grigg

HF: Brad Fisher Matthew Kreuzer Jordan Russell

F: Eddie Betts Adam Hartlett Jake Edwards

R: Shaun Hampson Bryce Gibbs Marc Murphy

I/C: Luke Blackwell Ryan Jackson Steven Browne Cameron Cloke

Couldn't fit in: Sam Jacobs, Aisake O'Hailpin, Clint Benjamin.


Richmond

B: Alex Rance Will Thursfield Andrew Raines

HB: Daniel Connors Graham Polak Jake King

C: Dean Polo Brett Deledio Richard Tambling

HF: Shane Edwards Cleve Hughes Mitch Morton

F: Adam Pattison Jack Riewoldt Danny Meyer

R: Angus Graham Nathan Foley Trent Cotchin

I/C: Jay Schulz Travis Casserly Luke McGuane Daniel Jackson

Couldn't fit in: David Gourdis, Andrew Collins, Dean Putt, Jarrod Oakley-Nicholls, Kelvin Moore.


Essendon

B: Tom Hislop Tayte Pears Henry Slattery

HB: David Myers Patrick Ryder Jay Nash

C: Jason Winderlich Jobe Watson Courtenay Dempsey

HF: Angus Monfries Scott Gumbleton Ricky Dyson

F: Alwyn Davey Jay Neagle Leroy Jetta

R: Jason Laycock Brent Stanton Bachar Houli

I/C: Heath Hocking John Williams Tom Bellchambers Kyle Reimers

Couldn't fit in: Courtney Johns, Darcy Daniher, Cale Hooker, Sam Lonergan, Andrew Lee.



All exciting young teams, but which one do you think is the best?

 

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

Essendon is much much better and clearly better.

 

[Merv]

Alwyn Davey doesn't qualify, unless it is 23 and under?

 

[jetta2davey]

yeah sorry merv didn't really explain it properly it's 23 and under.

 

[KING-JAMES]

Clearly its stupid, as some players that are 24/25 will still be around while this group develops and draft picks can impact a side a ton. Essendon's 2005 list is so much different to now from draft picks. Its impossible to tell what is going to happen.

 

[jetta2davey]

this thread is based on potential KING-JAMES, it's not to see which club will win a premiership first with this exact team, i'm just trying to find out how people rate essendon's younger players compared to the continually talked up youngsters down at Richmond and Carlton

 

[samthemanlonergan]

What does the bold mean?

 

[jonesy86]

Backline - Richmond
Midfield - Carlton
Forwardline - Essendon

 

[jetta2davey]

What does the bold mean?

It's just to distinguish the names

 

[Silvagnis]

Hard to understand why John Williams would be named ahead of Lonergan.

Add Pfeiffer to the backline and move Hartlett to CHF, Walker to the wing and Hampson to FF.

B: Anderson Jamison Bower
HB: Armfield Austin Pfeiffer
C: Simpson Bentick Walker
HF: Fisher Hartlett Russell
F: Betts Hampson Edwards
R: Kreuzer Gibbs Murphy

I/C: Jackson Browne Aisake Grigg

 

[boms]

For essendon id have -

B: Slattery Pears Reimers
HB: Dempsey Ryder Nash
C: Myers Watson Winderlich
HF: Jetta Gumbleton Monfries
F: Davey Neagle Lonergan
R: Laycock Stanton Hislop

I/C: Hocking Houli Dyson Bellchambers
EMG: Williams Daniher Hooker

Backline - Richmond
Midfield - Carlton owns it
Forward - Essendon

 

[jetta2davey]

For essendon id have -

B: Slattery Pears Reimers
HB: Dempsey Ryder Nash
C: Myers Watson Winderlich
HF: Jetta Gumbleton Monfries
F: Davey Neagle Lonergan
R: Laycock Stanton Hislop

I/C: Hocking Houli Dyson Bellchambers
EMG: Williams Daniher Hooker

Backline - Richmond
Midfield - Carlton owns it
Forward - Essendon

Dempsey is a winger mate, ands myers will definitely start his carrer at half back and move into the midfield

 

[boms]

Dempsey is a winger mate, ands myers will definitely start his carrer at half back and move into the midfield

His not only a winger, As Matthew Knights has said he can also play in the half back giving us alot of pace. Indeed Myers will start in the half back, but this is a 'future' team and i think his best position will be on the Wing

 

[doggiesin08]

CAN I VOTE FOR HAWTHORN?
B R.Ladson S.Gilham G.Birchall
HB X.Ellis M.Thorp T.Tuck
C C.Young L.Hodge B.McGlynn
HF T.Boyle L.Franklin B.Muston
F C.Rioli J.Roughead B.Dowler
R M.Bailey B.Sewell J.Lewis
OTHERS: T.Murphy, Z.Dawson, J.Morton J.Kennedy B.Renouf G.Moss

 

[Monkeyboy]

Carlton midfield is just awesome.

 

[im rick james dog]

Carlton midfield is just awesome.

Do u have any thing positive to say about your own team though?

 

[Jono B]

Do u have any thing positive to say about your own team though?

He just did.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Carlton would own in the midfield, the backline is all Richmond's and the forwardline Essendon.

So I'd take... Collingwood.

 

[LuKe2428]

foley>murphy
deledio>bentick
cotchin=gibbs

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Murphy > Foley

Deledio >>> Bentick

Gibbs > Cotchin.

People would argue Collingwood's midfielders aren't as good as these guys talent wise, with the exception of Pendlebury. And I agree. But it's how the team moulds as a unit, and I'd rather have a well moulded team than a midfield with selfish players.

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

pfffffft Carlton midfield is no good folks.

I'd take Essendons and Richmonds any day of the week.

It's the paper midfield. Makes good reading but in reality is no good.

Murphy and Gibbs will only be good average and Bentick will be delisted in a year or two.

 

[beaver fever]

Jake King doesn't qualify.

Thursfield Schulz Polo
Casserly Rance Morton
Edwards Connors Jackson
Deledio Polak Cotchin
Riewoldt Gourdis Collard
Graham Foley Tambling

Pattison Raines Oakley-Nicholls Meyer

 

[Heisenberg_]

Their isn't really that much between Richmond and Carlton, it could go either way pretty easily.
Essendon a long way back though

 

[CrazyQ]

Murphy > Foley

Deledio >>> Bentick

Gibbs > Cotchin.

People would argue Collingwood's midfielders aren't as good as these guys talent wise, with the exception of Pendlebury. And I agree. But it's how the team moulds as a unit, and I'd rather have a well moulded team than a midfield with selfish players.

How on earth is Murphy better than Foley?

Please explain.

 

[CrazyQ]

How on earth is Murphy better than Foley?

Please explain.

Foley Deledio Cotchin Tambling

Or

Murphy Walker Simpson and Gibbs

I'd take Richmonds over Carltons.