Farmer would we take him back

[demon21]

Would we take Farmer back I know its a bit of a long shot but with the WA media always bagging him and he hasnt played that well since leaving melb and frem might trade him. Personally I would take him back as we lack small forwards with only Davey and Armstrong who isnt getting as game at the moment. also Vardy but injury prone Robbo but he is not an out an out crumber there is also Williams but he is a dud.

 

[BT]

I reckon Wiz is capable of playing some good footy but is he worth the risk & $$$? Maybe if he takes a paycut & a haircut .

Still luv the Wiz deep down.

 

[demon21]

Yes I agree BT he would have to take a pay cut and would love him back at the dees

 

[Supermercado]

Why bother, we've got the new wizard (Davey) now.

 

[demon21]

Why bother its nice to have at least 2 small forwards in our side and

 

[underthebridge]

Why bother its nice to have at least 2 small forwards in our side and

what would u give freo for him? they probs need a outside midfielder....johnstone?

 

[BT]

what would u give freo for him? they probs need a outside midfielder....johnstone?

Not TJ for Wizzy.

2nd rnd pick.

 

[Deestroy]

what would u give freo for him? they probs need a outside midfielder....johnstone?

Keep right on dreaming.

Wouldn't even give up a 2nd rounder.

3rd rounder at best, he may well have a more negetive influence on the club than positive.

 

[underthebridge]

Keep right on dreaming.

Wouldn't even give up a 2nd rounder.

3rd rounder at best, he may well have a more negetive influence on the club than positive.

im not dreaming...i dont rate either of them, and i done supporter freo...just thought id clarify that b4 taking any further in this conversation.

 

[Deestroy]

Let me just clarify Melbourne's position by saying there's the same chance of us trading TJ for Farmer as there is for West Coast trading Chris Judd for Luke Williams .

 

[BT]

im not dreaming...i dont rate either of them, and i done supporter freo...just thought id clarify that b4 taking any further in this conversation.

I for one fully understand why you are distancing yourself from the anchors.

 

[underthebridge]

I for one fully understand why you are distancing yourself from the anchors.

glad thats now cleared up

 

[Deestroy]

I for one fully understand why you are distancing yourself from the anchors.

Yeah but they have a good symbol... The anchor...

Err... They have good colors... Purple....

Nah, I've got nothing.

 

[BT]

Yeah but they have a good symbol... The anchor...

Err... They have good colors... Purple....

Nah, I've got nothing.

No they have nothing actually. They have Schlockerland & we have MFCFlame.

 

[underthebridge]

they have players who have won in premierships at other clubs

 

[BT]

they have players who have won in premierships at other clubs

They have Roger Hayden...yep still nuthin!

 

[Deestroy]

Anyone remember Peter Mann?

He has a pretty cool surname.

 

[rgauci]

Your not in top form at the moment either. Swap you Farmer and our 3rd round pick for Armstrong and your 2nd round pick.

Any takers?

 

[benrey_demons]

Ready AND Wizza in the same team??? The club would need to hire a psychologist for the weekly anger management sessions these 2 would need

 

[Deestroy]

Your not in top form at the moment either. Swap you Farmer and our 3rd round pick for Armstrong and your 2nd round pick.

Any takers?

No.

Wouldn't do Armstrong for Farmer straight, so sure as hell wouldn't upgrade a pick for you.

3rd round pick, take it or leave it. I wouldn't really care either way.

 

[Supermercado]

Why waste a third round pick on somebody who has very little more to offer in his career?

One of my favourite players of all time but if we're going to start recycling people I'd rather have Troy Simmonds back if it's all the same.

 

[BT]

Why waste a third round pick on somebody who has very little more to offer in his career?

One of my favourite players of all time but if we're going to start recycling people I'd rather have Troy Simmonds back if it's all the same.

Yep the return of the Snake for Armstrong is a deal I'd do in a second.

Farmer for Carroll, take it or leave it!

 

[Deestroy]

Why waste a third round pick on somebody who has very little more to offer in his career?

One of my favourite players of all time but if we're going to start recycling people I'd rather have Troy Simmonds back if it's all the same.

Basing it more on a very weak draft this year and our lack of crumbers.

I agree though, even a third rounder is a stretch.

Where would we use Simmonds?