Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Scape Goat G&GF Coach

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Bond.ShaneBond

Bond.ShaneBond

Club Legend
Veteran
Joined
Mar 13, 2007
Posts
2,613
Reaction score
486
Location
Dorne
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Cards Suns City Vics
Chris "worst player in the AFL" Dawes for pick 20?

Gysberts for VFL player and pick downgrade?

1 win season?

Boring gameplan?

20 year old co-captains?

Sign in here if you are anti-Neeld.
 
On board. Dees supporters can say what they want about In Neeld we trust but this trading period has been an absolute disgrace. Getting bent over by every club we deal with after one of the poorest seasons in our history.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Yeah. Nah. Getting rid of Frail Morton is worth premiership points in itself.
 
This thread is a disgrace....you sir are an idiot. Supporters like you are an embarrassment. Have you ever even kicked a football?
 
Key forward that gives us structure, a second tall target (something we haven't had since Neitz/Schwarz/Lyon) and a backup should Mitch go down for the chance to select an unproven, untested 18 year old.

Small-bodied, injury-prone, played 1 game this year player for big-bodied, key-position utility

4 win season (Ask Richmond if games against GC count)

Accountable gameplan that encourages defensive effort, not just downhill skiing

20 & 23 year old co-captains with drive, motivation, a strong work ethic and a desire to improve and lead by example

An uncomprimising belief in performance over potential and instilling the right culture/work ethic.

Sign in here if you are pro-Neeld.
 
SuburbanMe said:
You know what can G&GF? Pea Heart Supporters that won't even give a new coach 2 yrs to see what he does with a pathetic list.
Click to expand...
THIS!
 
Perhaps we should bring back Bails and he can update Matthew Bate's development plan . . . . . .
 
Darksidepoints said:
Door is over there, feel free to leave.

Guy comes in with some balls and makes some big calls. Did we pay overs for some players? Maybe.

But you know what, we wont die wondering.

But lets persist with Morton, Bate etc. :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

This thread is clearly about Gysberts. **** Melbourne supporters are ****ing dumb.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Neeld's approach has been spot on tbh.

The Gys deal was awful in execution and we need to improve in our dealings but Morton heading west is quite a liberating feeling.
 
There's no doubt this trade period was always going to divide fans. But you can't deny that something needed to change. Neeld has come in and decided out with the skinny development type players, and in with the hardened body's with great work ethic. Out with the leaders who have been rubbish for our club for years and in with some fresh new kids with drive. He's trying to change a culture not just our list.

Yeah, we've been bent over with a few deals this week, but what have we really lost? Gysberts showed potential, but is injury prone and clearly doesn't work hard enough on the track. Moloney besides 1 good season was highly over rated. Morton we all wanted out of the club for many reasons. Martin is highly over rated, especially by some around here. Green's best years were well behind him. Cook has shown nothing since arriving. Rivers is a loss, but again, fans were divided as to his output, and Neeld didn't cut him loose, he left.

Have some faith mate. It's been bloody hard being a Melbourne supporter for a long time now, but Neeld is trying at least to change our culture. Dawes, Byrnes and Rodan will at least provide experience and add some energy. All quality blokes as well supposedly. Give them a chance. And don't forget Viney and potentially Wines will add some quality to our midfield. Have some faith and patience brother. We're all in this together...
 
deeman87 said:
This thread is clearly about Gysberts. **** Melbourne supporters are ******* dumb.
Click to expand...
No - the post is about Mark Neeld. The title says so.

Title: G&GF COACH

Post:
Chris "worst player in the AFL" Dawes for pick 20?

Gysberts for VFL player and pick downgrade?

1 win season?

Boring gameplan?

20 year old co-captains?

Sign in here if you are anti-Neeld.
Click to expand...

So, first point is regarding the recruitment of Dawes (That's not about Gysberts, it's about the deal Neeld & Co. have done to bring Dawes to the club - so it's about Neeld).

2nd point, Again talking about Neeld and him trading away Gysberts for a 'VFL' player and a Pick Downgrade.

3rd point is about winning one game (even though we won 4)

4th point is about the gameplan Neeld is bringing into the club (which you haven't seen, so I'm wondering if you have a time machine or are just talking out of your Ass)

5th point - 20yo captains - How this has anything to do with Gysberts, I have no idea.

So in summation, Thanks for clarifying that the OP was about Gysberts.

You're right, **** Melbourne supporters are ******* dumb.
 
Darksidepoints said:
You call me dumb, yet you cant even read.

Feel free to keep bitching and moaning, which is all you seem to do.
Click to expand...

How can i not read? Sorry that i don't condone every move the club makes and i only bitch and moan when the club makes the most ridiculous trade of the entire trade period.
 
deeman87 said:
How can i not read? Sorry that i don't condone every move the club makes and i only bitch and moan when the club makes the most ridiculous trade of the entire trade period.
Click to expand...

"This thread is clearly about Gysberts."...

Looks at topic.....

imuwFM0Ael6BZ.gif
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

deeman87 said:
How can i not read? Sorry that i don't condone every move the club makes and i only bitch and moan when the club makes the most ridiculous trade of the entire trade period.
Click to expand...

Its when you criticize EVERY thing the club does it may be time to G&GF
 
deeman87 said:
Let me rephrase. This thread is clearly in response to trading away Gysberts.
Click to expand...
I would say that the thread is the result of a baby having a tantrum.

Honestly - lets sack the coach after trade period because his first season was bad.
 
IF Neeld succeeds, I would expect all of you anti-Neeld posters to take your medicine

Pro-Neeld supporters have nothing to apologise for, no one has said what he's doing will work, but he's going about cutting the dead wood (twigs) and rotten culture that has plagued our club for decades

You should all be applauding him
 
No one can argue that we haven't gone backwards onfield under this guy. I just hope he knows what he's doing.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom