GAJ

[Judd_Magic]

As long as your happy.

And until you trade Dusty back in JM still has the wood on you with the Roughead-Zorko trade.

Yep, no-one is going to trump me quite just yet.

 

[Lums23]

Pendles could also fall away considering he hardly has a supporting cast around him and Collingwood has a habit of "resting" their guns in shit seasons when they don't have much to play for. The $50k odd difference could be significant, could be the difference between getting a Bontempelli or a spud like Taylor Adams in your forward line.

Agree to disagree on that. He's capable of carrying their rabble on his own IMO.

Lots of if, buts and coulds. I think it's pretty safe to say they're both really good picks though. I like Pendles just, I can't see much evidence of him dropping off yet and surely he won't get rested. Sloane is a lot cheaper though and definitely a good choice

 

[Jiska]

To generate that sort of cash in my forward line (by downgrading to Hogan), it was either Dusty, Bartel or Gray.

If you absolutely had to trade one of those three, which would you choose TheOz ??.

TheOz??

 

[TheOz]

TheOz??

I wouldn't have contemplated trading any of them.

 

[Jiska]

I wouldn't have contemplated trading any of them.

That wasn't the question posed.

If you absolutely had to trade one of those three, which would you choose

 

[leng jai]

Flip a coin between Bartel or Martin. Ridiculous to trade either though.

 

[GT619]

He'll pump out 100 to 130 plus as soon as you's all think trading him out dw he'll be back

 

[big bootaaaaah]

Traded Gazza>JPK.

It's been a great ride over the years gaz.

Cheer up You never know CD may find a way to give you 100 for his silhouette .

 

[ashley12]

That wasn't the question posed.

If you absolutely had to trade one of those three, which would you choose

If I was forced to murder either my mother or my brother, I would probably pick my brother.

If you want, you can take my statement out of context and think I am a psychopathic maniac, or you can understand that the decision when a third option, in not killing either of them, or trading away either of them, makes more sense.

 

[Kadog]

 

[Judd_Magic]

Ha! Ha!

Thucking gold mate!!

 

[Pocket Aces]

That wasn't the question posed.

If you absolutely had to trade one of those three, which would you choose

There are no absolutes with trading but why get rid of the one that was playing?

Three trades to to turn Martin into Swan, I for one am confused. Jury is still out on Dockertys keeper status.

 

[Jiska]

If I was forced to murder either my mother or my brother, I would probably pick my brother.

If you want, you can take my statement out of context and think I am a psychopathic maniac, or you can understand that the decision when a third option, in not killing either of them, or trading away either of them, makes more sense.

I look forward to you asking questions in the X vs Y vs Z thread. I will answer A

 

[TheOz]

That wasn't the question posed.

If you absolutely had to trade one of those three, which would you choose

I would only absolutely trade the one who had sustained a long term injury, not any other reason.

 

[Jiska]

There are no absolutes with trading but why get rid of the one that was playing?

Three trades to to turn Martin into Swan, I for one am confused. Jury is still out on Dockertys keeper status.

I'm guessing you didn't read my post.

The Docherty trade was due to take place this week, but will now become B Smith (if fit), otherwise Rance.

 

[Jiska]

I would only absolutely trade the one who had sustained a long term injury, not any other reason.

I look forward to you asking questions in the X vs Y vs Z thread. I will answer A

 

[KardiniaPark]

Jiska The fact is you didn't have to trade so I'm not sure why the TheOz doesn't get the same options you had. People admitting that Dusty would be the best of those three to go means absolutely nothing in the context of your trade.

 

[TheOz]

Jiska The fact is you didn't have to trade so I'm not sure why the TheOz doesn't get the same options you had. People admitting that Dusty would be the best of those three to go means absolutely nothing in the context of your trade.

I have read his sequence of trades and proposed trades and still don't understand the purpose of it.

 

[KardiniaPark]

I have read his sequence of trades and proposed trades and still don't understand the purpose of it.

It will be a glorious day when he brings in Dusty for $600k in R14

 

[Crawb]

GAJ set to be ruled out indefinitely apparently.

 

[MightyMark]

GAJ set to be ruled out indefinitely apparently.

Yeah saw that, probably wont matter too much, pretty much everyone was looking to offload him.

 

[Mullarkey]

2-3 weeks speculation, enough to move him on?

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

2-3 weeks speculation, enough to move him on?

Yep

Will get him back when he drops to 350k

 

[Pocket Aces]

I'm guessing you didn't read my post.

The Docherty trade was due to take place this week, but will now become B Smith (if fit), otherwise Rance.

I did I was basically summarising it, Smith makes it a little more appealing.

Why did you not ditch the injured premo? Why bounce 550K to the bench for a week(hopefully) when you didnt have to.

So if i did it i would have gone Bartel.

I think Martin historically did well against the doggies too. (I may be wrong but cant look it up ATM)

 

[NSWCROW]

Meanwhile all 4 GAJ non-owners be like......