- Joined
- Sep 26, 2003
- Posts
- 4,913
- Reaction score
- 721
- Location
- TJBC
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- TDot, LFC
Alas trade week has passed us and the 2004 National Draft beckons. We currently hold pick 32, pick 48, pick 64, and pick 80. I only expect to see the first 3 being used to satisfy draft rules.
Any thoughts as to who we should pick?
To start things off, what do fellow Geelong BF posters think of the following youngsters?
Thomas Redden
Details:
Club: Sacred Heart/Glenelg
DOB: 18 June 1987 Hgt: 190cm Wgt: 74kg
Position: Key Position/Onballer
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
National Draft Camp 2004
Strengths: Thomas could be one of the surprises of the draft, getting a draft camp invite despite not playing for SA in the carnival. He has spent most of the year playing school football for Sacred Heart where he has been a star.
Redden is a tall midfielder with the ability to play in a number of key positions, in a similar mould to former schoolmate Andrew Mackie. He was given an exemption into this year's draft so there is plenty of scope for improvement. He has good pace, good skills and his versatility will make him very attractive to most clubs.
Weaknesses: Almost unproven at the elite level, clubs are really taking a gamble on selecting Redden.
Footydraft.com comment: Every year Sacred Heart seem to produce a player from left-field, and Redden looks like it for 2004. Players of his versatility are gold for any AFL recruiter and this should see Thomas selected.
I say: The similarities between Redden and Mackie are quite amazing by the sounds of it. The prospect of drafting another Mackie-like player intrigues me. For all our abundance of flankers, which it appears Redden will become with his body size, I don't think Wells could do no worse than take a punt on a player with our first draft pick.
Chris Gooley
Details:
Club: Melbourne Grammar/Sandringham
DOB: 4 March 1986 Hgt: 193cm Wgt: 84kg
Position: Full Forward
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
National Draft Camp 2004
TAC Stats:
2004: 8 games, 17 goals, 13.8 PPG
Strengths: Chris Gooley is a tall forward who has spent most of the year playing school football for Melbourne Grammar with his twin Sam. Chris is a perfect size for a future key position player, has good balance and a touch of class about him.
He is a good set shot for goal and can take some fantastic grabs. He is usually pretty good with his attack on the footy and 2nd efforts.
Weaknesses: can struggle to read the flight of the ball as well as he should up forward, and he can two-grab a lot of marks. Also struggles with body on body marking contests. Had OP over the past 18 months.
Footydraft.com comment: Bit of a gamble given he didn't play much TAC Cup football or in the carnival. However Chris has had good form in the TAC Cup when he has played and has the right build to develop into a key forward.
I say: Would add to our list of project talls, but his strengths look to far outweigh his weaknesses. Our other young talls all have some sort of major issue about them; for example McCarthy has the size but not the kicking skills, Lonergan looks a good kick and a decent mark but his body isn't ready. Gooley looks to have a decent body size for a kid his age, and by the sounds of things his marking and kicking skills are also fairly good. The reading of play is a minor concern, whilst I'm confident his body on body work can be fixed after a couple of seasons hitting the weights.
Eddie Betts
Details:
Club: Templestowe/Calder
DOB: 26 November 1986 Hgt: 170cm Wgt: 72kg
Position: Forward Pocket/Back Pocket
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
Victoria Metro 2003, 2004
All Australian 2003
National Draft Camp 2004
TAC Stats:
2003: 17 games, 36 goals, 14.1 PPG
2004:
Strengths: Eddie is a livewire pocket rocket who was originally from Kalgoolie. He was recruited to the Calder Cannons on the advice of Phil Krakouer, and also played junior footy in SA at Malee Park, where his cousins Harry Miller, Graham Johncock and the Burgoynes came from.
Betts is super quick and elusive, and his front and square ability is just sensational. Is capable of kicking the freak goals every week, as well as dishing off with his exceptionally quick hands. Reads the play well and can kick on the left.
Weaknesses: Obviously his size. Betts is tiny and to get drafted when you are 5'6 you have to be exceptional - even then you can still get overlooked. Whether Eddie has the body to handle the rigours of AFL football is the big question. Specialst forward pockets also tend to get overlooked by most clubs. Injuries also affected him in 2004.
Footydraft.com comment: Eddie is one of the hardest players to classify in the entire draft pool. I love the way he plays and his ability mean it would be a travesty if he wasn't at least given an opportunity on an AFL list. However, I think clubs will be just too wary of his small stature, and a rookie list is a more likely option at this stage.
I say: I've watched Betts play a number of times now, and he genuinly excites me as a player. Size would be an issue, but I'd hate to see us pass up on him with one of our late picks in the draft after seeing Davey slip through our fingers last year.
Matthew Egan
Details:
Club: Oak Park/Geelopng (VFL)
DOB: 7 October 1983 Hgt: 194cm Wgt: 98kg
Position: Full Back
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
Full Back in VFL Team of the Year 2004
Strengths: Egan had an excellent season in defence for the Geelong VFL side, and was rewarded with Full Back in the VFL team of the year. Matthew has a background in tennis, but handled some of the best goalkickers in the VFL very well this year.
He is disciplined, very strong one-on-one and usually makes good decisions.
Weaknesses: Tends to be more of a negating player rather than creating a lot out of defence. Not much scope for improvement.
Footydraft.com comment: Clubs that are looking for a ready made defender late in the draft could do a lot worse than Egan. Geelong VFL coach Ron Watt is a big fan of his, and it wouldn't be a surprise to see the Cats take him with their final selection.
I say: Many here would be familiar with Egan already, as he has been discussed around before. Would add depth and cover for our defensive key position stocks, and IMO is deserving of a spot on our list after a good year in the VFL.
Any thoughts as to who we should pick?
To start things off, what do fellow Geelong BF posters think of the following youngsters?
Thomas Redden
Details:
Club: Sacred Heart/Glenelg
DOB: 18 June 1987 Hgt: 190cm Wgt: 74kg
Position: Key Position/Onballer
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
National Draft Camp 2004
Strengths: Thomas could be one of the surprises of the draft, getting a draft camp invite despite not playing for SA in the carnival. He has spent most of the year playing school football for Sacred Heart where he has been a star.
Redden is a tall midfielder with the ability to play in a number of key positions, in a similar mould to former schoolmate Andrew Mackie. He was given an exemption into this year's draft so there is plenty of scope for improvement. He has good pace, good skills and his versatility will make him very attractive to most clubs.
Weaknesses: Almost unproven at the elite level, clubs are really taking a gamble on selecting Redden.
Footydraft.com comment: Every year Sacred Heart seem to produce a player from left-field, and Redden looks like it for 2004. Players of his versatility are gold for any AFL recruiter and this should see Thomas selected.
I say: The similarities between Redden and Mackie are quite amazing by the sounds of it. The prospect of drafting another Mackie-like player intrigues me. For all our abundance of flankers, which it appears Redden will become with his body size, I don't think Wells could do no worse than take a punt on a player with our first draft pick.
Chris Gooley
Details:
Club: Melbourne Grammar/Sandringham
DOB: 4 March 1986 Hgt: 193cm Wgt: 84kg
Position: Full Forward
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
National Draft Camp 2004
TAC Stats:
2004: 8 games, 17 goals, 13.8 PPG
Strengths: Chris Gooley is a tall forward who has spent most of the year playing school football for Melbourne Grammar with his twin Sam. Chris is a perfect size for a future key position player, has good balance and a touch of class about him.
He is a good set shot for goal and can take some fantastic grabs. He is usually pretty good with his attack on the footy and 2nd efforts.
Weaknesses: can struggle to read the flight of the ball as well as he should up forward, and he can two-grab a lot of marks. Also struggles with body on body marking contests. Had OP over the past 18 months.
Footydraft.com comment: Bit of a gamble given he didn't play much TAC Cup football or in the carnival. However Chris has had good form in the TAC Cup when he has played and has the right build to develop into a key forward.
I say: Would add to our list of project talls, but his strengths look to far outweigh his weaknesses. Our other young talls all have some sort of major issue about them; for example McCarthy has the size but not the kicking skills, Lonergan looks a good kick and a decent mark but his body isn't ready. Gooley looks to have a decent body size for a kid his age, and by the sounds of things his marking and kicking skills are also fairly good. The reading of play is a minor concern, whilst I'm confident his body on body work can be fixed after a couple of seasons hitting the weights.
Eddie Betts
Details:
Club: Templestowe/Calder
DOB: 26 November 1986 Hgt: 170cm Wgt: 72kg
Position: Forward Pocket/Back Pocket
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
Victoria Metro 2003, 2004
All Australian 2003
National Draft Camp 2004
TAC Stats:
2003: 17 games, 36 goals, 14.1 PPG
2004:
Strengths: Eddie is a livewire pocket rocket who was originally from Kalgoolie. He was recruited to the Calder Cannons on the advice of Phil Krakouer, and also played junior footy in SA at Malee Park, where his cousins Harry Miller, Graham Johncock and the Burgoynes came from.
Betts is super quick and elusive, and his front and square ability is just sensational. Is capable of kicking the freak goals every week, as well as dishing off with his exceptionally quick hands. Reads the play well and can kick on the left.
Weaknesses: Obviously his size. Betts is tiny and to get drafted when you are 5'6 you have to be exceptional - even then you can still get overlooked. Whether Eddie has the body to handle the rigours of AFL football is the big question. Specialst forward pockets also tend to get overlooked by most clubs. Injuries also affected him in 2004.
Footydraft.com comment: Eddie is one of the hardest players to classify in the entire draft pool. I love the way he plays and his ability mean it would be a travesty if he wasn't at least given an opportunity on an AFL list. However, I think clubs will be just too wary of his small stature, and a rookie list is a more likely option at this stage.
I say: I've watched Betts play a number of times now, and he genuinly excites me as a player. Size would be an issue, but I'd hate to see us pass up on him with one of our late picks in the draft after seeing Davey slip through our fingers last year.
Matthew Egan
Details:
Club: Oak Park/Geelopng (VFL)
DOB: 7 October 1983 Hgt: 194cm Wgt: 98kg
Position: Full Back
Natural Foot: Right
Honours:
Full Back in VFL Team of the Year 2004
Strengths: Egan had an excellent season in defence for the Geelong VFL side, and was rewarded with Full Back in the VFL team of the year. Matthew has a background in tennis, but handled some of the best goalkickers in the VFL very well this year.
He is disciplined, very strong one-on-one and usually makes good decisions.
Weaknesses: Tends to be more of a negating player rather than creating a lot out of defence. Not much scope for improvement.
Footydraft.com comment: Clubs that are looking for a ready made defender late in the draft could do a lot worse than Egan. Geelong VFL coach Ron Watt is a big fan of his, and it wouldn't be a surprise to see the Cats take him with their final selection.
I say: Many here would be familiar with Egan already, as he has been discussed around before. Would add depth and cover for our defensive key position stocks, and IMO is deserving of a spot on our list after a good year in the VFL.










