Giansiracusa to collingwood???

[tarrant]

What do you think about Daniel Giansiracusa possibly coming to collingwood??

i think he would b very handy almost like another caracella.

 

[sinepari]

Psssst. You need to offer the dogs something.

 

[PiePower]

What do you think about Daniel Giansiracusa possibly coming to collingwood??

i think he would b very handy almost like another caracella.

Is this a wish or based on something?

 

[Murray]

We don't have anymore room left we have 139 new players coming already

 

[hotpie]

We don't have anymore room left we have 139 new players coming already

135 of them are Footscray midfielders. The rest come from Melbourne.

 

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Mark Maguire and Leo Barry would be handy down back, as would Dean Cox in the ruck.

 

[pieman1]

Giansiracusa? Instead of naming a player in a teams best 22 and tapping your ruby slippers together, think about fringe players or players who have had a poor year. Giansiracusa, no chance, Sam Power? maybe.

 

[Lockyer24]

Id be after Sam Power if anyone at the Dogs

To shake Giansiracusa we'd have to do a massive deal including a Tarrant etc

 

[hotpie]

Giansiracusa? Instead of naming a player in a teams best 22 and tapping your ruby slippers together, think about fringe players or players who have had a poor year. Giansiracusa, no chance, Sam Power? maybe.

Exactly. Power, Birss, etc. Players who cant get a game. To swap for our players who cant get a game like Cole, Lonie etc. Players who we would actually have a chance of doing a trade for.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Mark Maguire and Leo Barry would be handy down back, as would Dean Cox in the ruck.

His name is Matt Maguire

Gia would be good, but I don't think we could get him.

BTW - Don't trade Lonie, i want to keep my name

 

[bulldogtragic]

If i were Collingwood, i'd head hunt Brad Murphy and promise him some game time. He'd probably walk out on the club to get it. At worst you'd have to give up a Lonie or Cole for him.

This guy will be a very, very good player and is in front of Power i think. He just can't get past gia, coon, griff, smith, johnson, west, hahn, ray, boyd etc.

As much as it hurts me to say, he'd be better of in a black and white jumper next year, i expect him to be wearing it too.

 

[pieman1]

I reckon we could get an extra 3rd round pick from somewhere, a 3rd round pick for Brad Murphy work for you?

 

[jefffff34]

Nic Fosdike or Jarrad McVeigh from Sydney would be handy.

Armstrong from Melbourne for a low pick.

 

[bulldogtragic]

It might have to. He'll walk i honestly think if we can't find a suitable trade.

Might be a case of getting what we can for him. Hopefully i'm wrong and he'll stay, but a kid with as much potential as him wont like playing 2's forever.

I'd be stoked to get your 2nd round pick 21, for pick 27 & Murphy.

Would that work?

 

[jefffff34]

It might have to. He'll walk i honestly think if we can't find a suitable trade.

Might be a case of getting what we can for him. Hopefully i'm wrong and he'll stay, but a kid with as much potential as him wont like playing 2's forever.

I'd be stoked to get your 2nd round pick 21, for pick 27 & Murphy.

Would that work?

Sold.

 

[pocketrocket#24]

i dont know much about this brad murphy. what number was he drafted at and in what year??

 

[PiePower]

2002 Draft
Round 3 number 33 Western Bulldogs BRAD MURPHY CALDER CANNONS 27/10/1984 186cm 71kg

Medium forward who has pace, vision, awareness and quick hands. Had 41 possessions and kicked 6 goals in Round 18 highlighting his potential.

 

[bradrowe#32]

Nic Fosdike or Jarrad McVeigh from Sydney would be handy.

Armstrong from Melbourne for a low pick.

I've always liked the look of Armstrong who is a fringe player in their midfield. Would be very keen to get him as he is quick and has good skills.

 

[Swifty_446]

What do you think about Daniel Giansiracusa possibly coming to collingwood??

i think he would b very handy almost like another caracella.

What do you mean "almost another Caracella"?

Are you implying the Caracella is better than Giansuracusa?

 

[PiePower]

What do you mean "almost another Caracella"?

Are you implying the Caracella is better than Giansuracusa?

yeah I'm afraid Gia is a gun averaging over 20 possies, Caracella is not the player I would compare him to

 

[PIES BACK TO VP!!!]

His name is Matt Maguire

Gia would be good, but I don't think we could get him.

BTW - Don't trade Lonie, i want to keep my name

Thrade him (Lonie R) for his bro at Hawthorn. Name wont be an issue then

 

[magpies42]

yeah for sure, he woudl be an awesome pick up but we need a few more players above him! lets say a kerr, bartel , salopak, polak, griffen cooney, bradley and the maybe gainsiracussa not to mention the kids we draft

 

[Jabso]

Mark Maguire and Leo Barry would be handy down back, as would Dean Cox in the ruck.

Mark Maguire might be alright but I don't think the AFL allows baseball bats on the field.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

I would love Steve Armstrong at Collingwood. Plaer who keeps getting further and further away from getting a good chance at senior level.

 

[Jabso]

yeah for sure, he woudl be an awesome pick up but we need a few more players above him! lets say a kerr, bartel , salopak, polak, griffen cooney, bradley and the maybe gainsiracussa not to mention the kids we draft

If you think we are going to get any of those players mentioned let alone a few without giving up something VALUABLE you are kidding.