Gibbs for Judd??

[kouta 4 president]

Im just wondering, would anyone trade Gibbs for Judd? I would say no, but Judd has already proved to be a brownlow worthy player, and by the sounds of things Gibbs has not improved much since last year and may stay at this skill level for his whole career

 

[sticks74]

Im just wondering, would anyone trade Gibbs for Judd? I would say no, but Judd has already proved to be a brownlow worthy player, and by the sounds of things Gibbs has not improved much since last year and may stay at this skill level for his whole career

In a heart beat...

Confirm that in a couple of years!

 

[lebron]

Are you serious?

 

[Kaitsey]

yeah f*ck judd hes sh1t get gibbs!

 

[kouta 4 president]

Are you serious?

If you read what I wrote it says that i wouldnt take it, but im wondering how many people would and wouldnt

 

[sticks74]

Are you serious?

Hes a premiership Captain and a star of the game... Bloody oath im serious!

 

[lebron]

I meant are you serious in that you wouldn't take Judd if possible? Unbelieveable if true.

If you read what I wrote it says that i wouldnt take it, but im wondering how many people would and wouldnt

Is this from the perspective that we have Gibbs and you wouldn't trade him for Judd, or the other way round?

 

[RoosterLad]

You would be mad not to take it! Gibbs is a good player and all but Judd is a gun. Its not like hes at the end of his career, like a Voss, Roo or Buckley, Judd is still young and has plenty more premierships and brownlows left in him.

Kouta are you simple? You say Gibbs hasnt improved at all? Have you even seen him play? SO many people are experts on Gibbs but have never seen him. TO say he will stay at this skill level for ever is ridiculous. He will improve a lot when he goes to an AFL club, he will gain a lot from their weight/fitness programs and just the experience of being around AFL stars and playing AFL footy.

 

[Barb4Prez!]

yeah f*ck judd hes sh1t get gibbs!

I think a closer poll would be who is a bigger w@nker on big footy Kaitesy or Jeff Dunne would be a more interesting poll!

 

[Silvagnis]

yeah f*ck judd hes sh1t get gibbs!

Why don't you stop posting on every other club's board?

 

[kouta 4 president]

Kouta are you simple? You say Gibbs hasnt improved at all? Have you even seen him play? SO many people are experts on Gibbs but have never seen him

Ill admit I have never seen Gibbs, but if you look at what I wrote it says, in my exact words, "by the sounds of things Gibbs has not improved much". Notice I said by the sounds of things and not IMO. Im just going off what I have heard from other people so how about you read what I say before you comment on it

 

[blues4flag]

Of course I'll take Judd - have seen very little of Gibbs, but Judd is a proven champion and gamebreaker with atleast probably another 10 years in the game.

 

[Kaitsey]

i still dont know why you guys are discussing this.

 

[Jeremias]

i still dont know why you guys are discussing this.

Because it's a Carlton forum?

If you don't like it you can **** off, we can discuss what we like.

 

[Kaitsey]

judd will never be traded for anyone.

if there is a god (which it may be judd)...

judd>god

 

[kouta 4 president]

Because it's a Carlton forum?

If you don't like it you can **** off, we can discuss what we like.

Well said. Truly inspirational words from Jeremias

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Kaitsey, stop coming in with one lined rebuttals, either be constructive in your discussions or have your access removed.

Thanks

 

[Wilburwild]

HAHAHAHAHA - you cant keep your own players, good luck getting Judd to come to you!! HAHAHAHA - you cant afford him anyway! maybe the AFL can pay for you!

- Sorry guys, i know thats low but have a look at the Adelaide board and there is heaps of Carlton supporters posting C*** there, and like they say...
Whats good for the goose (thats the carlton supporters) is good for the Gander (thats the Adel and WC supporters)

 

[crowsarethebest]

This is the worst thread i've seen. I meen.. Gibbs hasn't even played AFL. He could be a flop. Judd is a proven Chmapion. I severely doubt Gibbs will be as good as Judd. Judd is a player you only see once a decade.

 

[earlsta]

LOL @ Gibbs for Judd..
What a rip-off

It'd be more like Fevola, Walker, #1 2006 Pick = Judd

That'd be more fair, carlton you have got to be kiddin yourselves.

 

[kouta 4 president]

I get the feeling Adelaide supporters are jealous because they dont have a player thats as good as Judd OR Gibbs. Poor little people. Finished 1st and 2nd in the last 2 years and didnt make grand final either year

 

[Furn]

Giibs is not the next judd hes not even close hes not as good at his age as hodge ball or judd were and wont be as good as any of them

 

[TheBlueblood]

well see wont we

i reckon hodge went backwards this year

 

[Silvagnis]

I'd trade picks 1, 17 and 19 to have Judd wearing Navy Blue.

Twigley can come to Carlton as well if she wants but I'm only willing to give up Houlihan for her.

 

[Hu$$ey]

Giibs is not the next judd hes not even close hes not as good at his age as hodge ball or judd were and wont be as good as any of them

That's why Wayne Hughes said that Gibbs has done more at his age than any player he has seen since Buckley and Wanganeen, and if you can't work it out, that includes the Hodge/Ball/Judd draft.

This isn't in any way a knock on Judd but if you were comparing relative achievements of the players at similar ages then you would have Gibbs in front.

Having said that however, I would do it the trade in a heartbeat, heck I'd package pick 17 with it too to get Judd, that's how good he is.

P.S: Thanks Nostradamus for letting us know he won't be as good as any of Judd/Ball/Hodge, now we can concentrate on picking someone else with our first pick who has a better chance