Herald Sun Super Coach 2007

[nick_savo]

Exactly he had one good week, andi bought him round 2, he has given my nothing, he has one more week to prove himself

 

[T-I-G-E-R-M-A-N]

The reward has been and gone.

have to disagree mate...

 

[nick_savo]

Well, I am going to belive in him for one more week, I really hope he can pull out a big score to rub it into those who traded him, make that 16 more big scores in a row

 

[Lonie_from_50]

watch out for Robbos Rednecks, my 12 year old brothers team. Hadnt changed it first SIX weeks, but has scored 2200 pts last two weeks with 20 players, lmao.

Has 18 trades left, he traded K McGregor (lol) for Jesse Smith, then Nathan G. Brown for Scott Lucas (i told him Barry Hall was probably a better option, haha)

 

[Biggie]

Gibbs OUT

N.Lappin IN

$$$$ coming up

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Gibbs OUT

N.Lappin IN

$$$$ coming up

I hope you have good emergencies.

 

[Biggie]

I hope you have good emergencies.

You know I dont.

 

[inwhiterooms]

anyone know if X. Ellis or L. Jetta will be back this week? both would be my emergencies as i'm hiding two injuries on the bench already

 

[footyfan_25]

anyone know if X. Ellis or L. Jetta will be back this week? both would be my emergencies as i'm hiding two injuries on the bench already

Highly unlikely either would play this week.

 

[Don Cottagers]

anyone know if X. Ellis or L. Jetta will be back this week? both would be my emergencies as i'm hiding two injuries on the bench already

Especially Leroy. Read the article about Bachar Houli on the Herald Sun website, doesnt even seem he is in the calculations (if indeed he is over his injury at all)

 

[ffc1954]

Hughes has done well past 2 games mainly because he has been our only target up forward, especially last week.

With Schultz out this week and Richo having to ruck he should do alright down forward again.

However Jack Reiwolt and Kingsley may get a game this week, therefore giving us more options down forward and Hughes won't be the main target.

Wallace played Hughes as a CHB all pre-season trying to develop him down back, but with injuries he is currently required down forward.

Considering he is not a bottom price player, he is not going to be an ideal cash cow.

I guess would all depend what trade your looking at for Hughes and if you want to start him or have him on bench.

With our injuries and lack of talls I can see Hughes getting a regular game though.

Hope this helps, but hard to say yes or no without knowing your side and what trades you were looking at.

Thanks mate. That is very helpfull. He'll spend most of the time on the bench but I wanted a player who will pull 60 - 70 as an emerg. and go up in value for later sale.
Also the money from trading in embley, cause he doesn't score even if he plays, will alllow me to upgrade some other average players.
The only problem is that I will have to put Hawkins in as a regular for a while. But I feel he is improving.

Cheers

 

[rgauci]

Top 20?

Kidding yourself. Top 1000, maybe.

Crap side btw.

Thanks. Any chance you'll name your side? Or your current rank?

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Thanks. Any chance you'll name your side? Or your current rank?

For sure,

306th

Heath Shaw
Lindsay Gilbee
Adam McPhee
Jess Sinclair
Beau Waters
Nathan Bock
Grant Birchall

Chris Judd
Daniel Kerr
Scott West
Kane Cornes
David Rodan
Richard Hadley/ Joel Selwood / Ricky Petterd

Aaron Sandilands
Dean Cox

Chad Cornes
Garry Ablett
Matthew Pavlich
Barry Hall
Ryan O'Keefe
Alwyn Davey
Aaron Edwards/Campbell

 

[Deledio_Judd]

Which midfielder should i get i have $700,000 allready have Kane Cornes & Kerr is it worth getting Judd, Bartel or Dal Santo?

 

[Deledio_Judd]

Also who will play first Andrew Browne or Lindsay Thomas?

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Which midfielder should i get i have $700,000 allready have Kane Cornes & Kerr is it worth getting Judd, Bartel or Dal Santo?

Get Deledio or Lewis or even Goodes.

 

[inwhiterooms]

Which midfielder should i get i have $700,000 allready have Kane Cornes & Kerr is it worth getting Judd, Bartel or Dal Santo?

out of those three i'd take judd, bartel has been playing slightly above himself and like kerr may be due for a down game. Still a superstar so you really can't go wrong with any of those three.

Considered Goodwin? VALUE.

 

[davey_23]

Thinking of trading Sam Mitchell or Michael Rischitelli. I can afford anyone but would like to have some money left. Any suggestions? Judd is the popular choice.

 

[Ray Ball]

if both Bock and mcphee scored around 100 this week can anyone tell me what there price will be around next week?

 

[foxy_dal]

who would u choose? gilbee or goddard and who should i get rid of? x clarke or bock

 

[Philzsay]

anyone know if X. Ellis or L. Jetta will be back this week? both would be my emergencies as i'm hiding two injuries on the bench already

Jetta will probably be given a few weeks for Bendigo to find some form.

 

[inwhiterooms]

who would u choose? gilbee or goddard and who should i get rid of? x clarke or bock

gilbee. don't know bout clarke or bock

 

[warney7]

In S O'hAilpin for G polak a good trade.

Or with Richmond going to AAMI 2 weeks in a row, would you expect his scores to come down?

 

[Hairy Cat Mooney]

who would u choose? gilbee or goddard and who should i get rid of? x clarke or bock

Get rid of Bock for Gilbee.

 

[footyfan_25]

Would be nice if people stopped starting a new thread for every trade they are considering

Ill ask my question here rather than starting a thread saying "Help with my backline or similar"

Thinking of X.Clarke for Whitnall ... thoughts? Has Whitnall found his form again?