Ins & Outs vs Geelong

[BomberAce7]

In - Lovett
Out - Lucas

Im not sure if we need to replace a key Forward with another. IMO Lovett - Murray could play CHF. His speed & atheticism could cause alot of problems for any CHB. What do you guys think?

 

[Spikey]

Don't think we need Lovett TBH, Showed heaps of pace today so I don't see a place for him. Though if Winders is fit I would put him in.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Out- Slattery, Lucas
In- Monfries, Neagle

 

[BABYBOMBERS2007]

In - Lovett
Out - Lucas

 

[SOT4]

Keep Monfries out. Make him earn it. Anyways, Lonergan>>>>Monfries (at the moment)

 

[BomberAce7]

Keep Monfries out. Make him earn it. Anyways, Lonergan>>>>Monfries.

Agree.

 

[DonMania#5]

In - Lovett
Out - Lucas

Yep, agree with that.
Although if Winderlich is fit, i would have him ahead of Lovett.

 

[bomberstomake8]

ins: lovett/winderlick
outs: lucas

maybe dyson dropped for winderlick, what do you guys think? Dyson was back to how he played last year, nowhere to be seen.... 8 possies for the match and 1 tackle.....

should he be dropped or given another game to prove himself...

with players like lovett, winderlick. monfries, reimers on the sides watching you would think he could not afford to put in another poor effort next week

 

[Schmick]

Even know Slatts didn't have a very good game, i think we should keep him in because out of all our players, Slatts is probably our best option to play on Chapman.

IN: Winderlich/Lovett
OUT: Lucas

 

[BomberAce7]

ins: lovett/winderlick
outs: lucas

maybe dyson dropped for winderlick, what do you guys think? Dyson was back to how he played last year, nowhere to be seen.... 8 possies for the match and 1 tackle.....

should he be dropped or given another game to prove himself...

with players like lovett, winderlick. monfries, reimers on the sides watching you would think he could not afford to put in another poor effort next week

Agree. Ricky didnt have a good game. Lovett in just over Winderlich.

 

[Spikey]

ins: lovett/winderlick
outs: lucas

maybe dyson dropped for winderlick, what do you guys think? Dyson was back to how he played last year, nowhere to be seen.... 8 possies for the match and 1 tackle.....

Who was Dyson playing on? I think it was Wells but I'm not sure...

 

[Schmick]

I don't think we should drop Dyson just yet. I think we should give him at least 1 more game to redeem himself before dropping him after just 1 game.

 

[danzan22]

Even know Slatts didn't have a very good game, i think we should keep him in because out of all our players, Slatts is probably our best option to play on Chapman.

IN: Winderlich/Lovett
OUT: Lucas

I thought slatts had a pretty good game

I would b tempted to bring in Neagle if fit, just love the look of him.

 

[Burzum]

Out: Lucas
In: Lovett

 

[silk]

Out - Dyson, Lucas (Inj )

In - Welsh (If fit), Winders.

Can't afford a bad game in this bomber outfit!

 

[lemon chicken]

Out - Lucas, Dyson (hack and proved it again)

In - Welsh, Winderlich

 

[lamaros]

Is everyone just judging Dyson from hsi stats? Why not get stuck into Slattery then? Or Laycock? Or Nash? Or Stanton?

Dyson was much better than he has been in the past and I think deserves another game.

 

[sikmoe]

Round 2 Vs Geelong

What a game this is going to be. We should match up well against them and i feel confident about this game. go dons!

 

[efcboy]

Re: Round 2 Vs Geelong

the only kpp's fit enough to warrant selection are johns, hooker, pears. i don't think any of these should get a game. only guys up for selection should include monfries, winderlich, peverill, lovett, myers.

no way will slattery be dropped - obviously lucas is out and maybe one more change in dyson.

i think monfries will replace lucas and whether winderlich/lovett have enough miles in the legs to replace dyson is a query. geelong run very hard so we can't afford to take in guys half fit.

i'd keep it the same with monfries in for lucas personally and give dyson one more chance against the best in the business.

 

[dave_27]

Re: Round 2 Vs Geelong

IN: Welsh

OUT: Lucas

That is all atm.

Looking forward to seeing how Mcphee, Lovett-Murray and Welsh going in the same forward line.

 

[bomba4eva]

Lovett and Winderlich are both in our best 22. No doubt about that. Monfries should get a big wake up call knowing he has to earn his place in the side. We used a first round pick on him so I really hope he comes good. Welsh would be in consideration also. Reimers is a possibility especially as I didnt think that Lonergan did a whole lot today. Personally Id really like to see Neagle get a crack at Lucas' spare position.

In: Neagle, Lovett, Winderlich
Out: Lucas, Lonergan, Johnson

 

[efcboy]

none of neagle, gumby, welsh will be ready to play next week. they need to get over injuries first.

 

[lemon chicken]

Is everyone just judging Dyson from hsi stats? Why not get stuck into Slattery then? Or Laycock? Or Nash? Or Stanton?

Dyson was much better than he has been in the past and I think deserves another game.

I wasnt. I was judging his game. Was there a lack of opportunity as said in the past, NO started in the guts (what a joke). Did todays game not suit his style, NO. His kicking skills are crap, gets the ball on the wing and kicks it 10m short of a leading forward. He is meant to be professional footballer and he cant hit a simple target. Has no composure in a pressure situation, looks like a duck out of water.

All the highlighted players have runs on the board and have proven themselves in REAL matches. How many chances does this bloke need?

 

[SirJimi05]

I don't think we should drop Dyson just yet. I think we should give him at least 1 more game to redeem himself before dropping him after just 1 game.

Knights said that players like Dyson will get plenty of games to prove themselves before being dropped so i can't see him going back on his word.

It is all about the development of the football club NOT beating Geelong next week.

 

[kelvin_sheedy]

Knights said that players like Dyson will get plenty of games to prove themselves before being dropped so i can't see him going back on his word.

It is all about the development of the football club NOT beating Geelong next week.

Wow.

Fancy not winning being good for development.