Remove this Banner Ad

Jesse Hogan Contract Negotiations (Titus O'Reilly)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

There's an element of truth here. Dangerfield was a free agent, Buddy was a free agent, Hogan isn't a free agent. It's a huge difference.

Unless Hogan says to Melbourne 'Freo or I walk and you get nothing' our chances of landing him are slim. Melbourne would (rightfully) demand 2 mid to early first rounders plus a player like Neale. And there's nothing in our recent trading history that suggests we would entertain that.

the only scenario i can see Hogan going to freo, is that if Hogan really really wants to leave and go home (which i respect, but i think is unlikely) we would ask for Fyfe (very unlikely considering i reckon he will never leave WA) and then a swap of picks like our 3rd rounder for your 2nd... how do you all feel about that?
 
the only scenario i can see Hogan going to freo, is that if Hogan really really wants to leave and go home (which i respect, but i think is unlikely) we would ask for Fyfe (very unlikely considering i reckon he will never leave WA) and then a swap of picks like our 3rd rounder for your 2nd... how do you all feel about that?
I dont think any hogan deal will be happening until 2017.
 
the only scenario i can see Hogan going to freo, is that if Hogan really really wants to leave and go home (which i respect, but i think is unlikely) we would ask for Fyfe (very unlikely considering i reckon he will never leave WA) and then a swap of picks like our 3rd rounder for your 2nd... how do you all feel about that?

So you end up with a Brownlow medallist and the best player in the game and we give you our second round?

Hogan is currently potential
 
the only scenario i can see Hogan going to freo, is that if Hogan really really wants to leave and go home (which i respect, but i think is unlikely) we would ask for Fyfe (very unlikely considering i reckon he will never leave WA) and then a swap of picks like our 3rd rounder for your 2nd... how do you all feel about that?

Wait, so you are saying that Hogan is worth more than Fyfe?
 
yeah but i think that will be the deal

Lot's of hypotheticals in this. Firstly, if Hogan demands out and back to WA and at the end of 2017 you're in no real position of power. We'd still try to offer equitable trade and somewhere along the lines of a couple of firsts would likely see it done (all depends on where we finish next year).

IF Fyfe comes out and says he wishes to openly explore free agency, then yes a trade for a Hogan becomes possible, BUT in no way is it only a player exchange. We'd be demanding your first which if you improve next year would be a pick around 10-14, which would still probably not be enough BUT if Fyfe wants out we'd be hard pressed to find a better offer and to a club Fyfe sees a future at.

So much unknown, but we won't be putting Fyfe up for trade at the end of next year unless we spiral out of control and the rumours prove fact. He is naturally going to be our captain after Mundy, although I wouldn't be against Walters being thrown into the mix here and for Fremantle to become a destination club for young aboriginal players.

Genuine question and excuse my ignorance, but how many aboriginal captain's of a club has there been? who was the latest? McLeod? was he even captain? Wanganeen??
 

Remove this Banner Ad

yeah but i think that will be the deal
I am looking more for a balance deal like chris judd - kennedy deal.

Chris judd Brownlow - kennedy potential plus pick 3

Fyfe brownlow- hogan potential , plus your next year 2017 first rd and the 2018 2nd rd . Knowing you will at least made top 8 this two year. Going to freo.
 
the only scenario i can see Hogan going to freo, is that if Hogan really really wants to leave and go home (which i respect, but i think is unlikely) we would ask for Fyfe (very unlikely considering i reckon he will never leave WA) and then a swap of picks like our 3rd rounder for your 2nd... how do you all feel about that?
I would expect at the very least your 1st rounder and Hogan.

Currently Fyfe >>>>>> Hogan.
 
I always struggle to believe that a family member would be so casual in leaking contractual information.
I'm not so sure. A night on the beers and a slip of the tongue. I ran into a guy on the plane who new Jessie's junior coach, who knew the family,and said he was looking to come home. Again, flimsy I know, but believable.
 
I'm not so sure. A night on the beers and a slip of the tongue. I ran into a guy on the plane who new Jessie's junior coach, who knew the family,and said he was looking to come home. Again, flimsy I know, but believable.

That's like the guy on demonland.com who claims to have inside sources at the club (Has called some stuff very early but also gotten some wrong) saying that Hogan has informed MFC he wishes to stay.

I've heard so many conflicting opinions on his future (Especially from journos both in WA and over here) I won't believe a thing until there is an official announcement one way or the other.
 
I'm not so sure. A night on the beers and a slip of the tongue. I ran into a guy on the plane who new Jessie's junior coach, who knew the family,and said he was looking to come home. Again, flimsy I know, but believable.

It's all chinese whispers and interpretation too.

Hoge's bro's friend - 'Hey, what's the latest with Jessie? He coming back to WA?'
Hoge's bro - 'Honestly, he's unsure. Loves WA and being home, but we'll see'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Hey you spoken to Jessie's bro? What's the deal?'
Hoge's bro's friend - 'Said he loves WA and can't wait to be home'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend 'BS you know Jessie Hogan'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Nah for real mate. Speak to Jessie's bro all the time and when Jessie is in town we don our purple scarves and get up to all sorts of shit'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend 'Nah you're full of it mate... like that time you said Luc Longley was going to play for the Wildcats'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Oi mate, whatever hey. All I know is Jessie hates Melbourne and thinks David Schwartz is a douche'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend - 'So, Fremantle?'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Mate, have I ever steered you wrong?'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend - 'What? like that time we spent 48 hours in lock up for that stash in your car... then said it wasn't yours, so we both got done'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Oi, don't bring that shit up again. That was only twice and we got a meal didn't we? Anyway, Hogan is coming to Fremantle. Straight from the horses mouth'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend posts on FaceBook - Hogan coming to Fremantle. From the horses mouth.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

That's like the guy on demonland.com who claims to have inside sources at the club (Has called some stuff very early but also gotten some wrong) saying that Hogan has informed MFC he wishes to stay.

I've heard so many conflicting opinions on his future (Especially from journos both in WA and over here) I won't believe a thing until there is an official announcement one way or the other.
Yeh definitely, as you say, all here say.
 
It's all chinese whispers and interpretation too.

Hoge's bro's friend - 'Hey, what's the latest with Jessie? He coming back to WA?'
Hoge's bro - 'Honestly, he's unsure. Loves WA and being home, but we'll see'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Hey you spoken to Jessie's bro? What's the deal?'
Hoge's bro's friend - 'Said he loves WA and can't wait to be home'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend 'BS you know Jessie Hogan'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Nah for real mate. Speak to Jessie's bro all the time and when Jessie is in town we don our purple scarves and get up to all sorts of shit'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend 'Nah you're full of it mate... like that time you said Luc Longley was going to play for the Wildcats'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Oi mate, whatever hey. All I know is Jessie hates Melbourne and thinks David Schwartz is a douche'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend - 'So, Fremantle?'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Mate, have I ever steered you wrong?'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend - 'What? like that time we spent 48 hours in lock up for that stash in your car... then said it wasn't yours, so we both got done'
Hoge's bro's friend's friend - 'Oi, don't bring that shit up again. That was only twice and we got a meal didn't we? Anyway, Hogan is coming to Fremantle. Straight from the horses mouth'

Hoge's bro's friend's friend-friend posts on FaceBook - Hogan coming to Fremantle. From the horses mouth.

Hoge's bro's friend's friend is probably on BF
 
I am looking more for a balance deal like chris judd - kennedy deal.

Chris judd Brownlow - kennedy potential plus pick 3

Fyfe brownlow- hogan potential , plus your next year 2017 first rd and the 2018 2nd rd . Knowing you will at least made top 8 this two year. Going to freo.
no chance we will give both those picks for fyfe
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Jesse Hogan Contract Negotiations (Titus O'Reilly)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top