Johnstone for Chapman

[chiliboy]

I can honestly say..

THAT IS THE BIGGEST LOAD OF BS IVE EVER EVER HEARD!!

The deal involves those players, but also a couple of others, and thats all if TJ rejects the dees newe offer, which, it seems he wont..

So p**s off pies supporters, u aint gettin him, at least not that easy..

Chaoman is good, TJ could be a champion.. too much time has been invested in him for thenm to let him got for that, especially when essendon are offer M.Johnson and a pick..

Calm down dee fans..

TJ should stay, but I CAN ASSSURE YOU OF THIS

THAT IS NOT THE DEAL!!!

 

[leonmagic]

I can honestly say..

THAT IS THE BIGGEST LOAD OF BS IVE EVER EVER HEARD!!

The deal involves those players, but also a couple of others, and thats all if TJ rejects the dees newe offer, which, it seems he wont..

So p**s off pies supporters, u aint gettin him, at least not that easy..

Chaoman is good, TJ could be a champion.. too much time has been invested in him for thenm to let him got for that, especially when essendon are offer M.Johnson and a pick..

Calm down dee fans..

TJ should stay, but I CAN ASSSURE YOU OF THIS

THAT IS NOT THE DEAL!!!

Who said Collingwood supporters are suggesting it??

Last I heard it was actually mentioned on 774..

 

[markc]

I can honestly say..

THAT IS THE BIGGEST LOAD OF BS IVE EVER EVER HEARD!!

The deal involves those players, but also a couple of others, and thats all if TJ rejects the dees newe offer, which, it seems he wont..

So p**s off pies supporters, u aint gettin him, at least not that easy..

Chaoman is good, TJ could be a champion.. too much time has been invested in him for thenm to let him got for that, especially when essendon are offer M.Johnson and a pick..

Calm down dee fans..

TJ should stay, but I CAN ASSSURE YOU OF THIS

THAT IS NOT THE DEAL!!!

thanks Chily anymore rumours ???

 

[chiliboy]

Who said Collingwood supporters are suggesting it??

Last I heard it was actually mentioned on 774..

Im not saying collingwood supporters said, im just saying dont get excited..

It was on the abc, but it wasnt specific, it just said a deal INVOLVING those players..

 

[leonmagic]

Im not saying collingwood supporters said, im just saying dont get excited..

It was on the abc, but it wasnt specific, it just said a deal INVOLVING those players..

Who's excited?

I sure as hell aren't..

 

[Seb]

TJ > Chapman?

Delusional.

 

[leonmagic]

TJ > Chapman?

Delusional.

Exactly.

It's amazing that TJ is the exact player that Melbourne fans love to bag (overrated, hasn't delivered after 5 years).

To hear some of them bag Ottens is simply laughable.

 

[morax]

Im not saying collingwood supporters said, im just saying dont get excited..

It was on the abc, but it wasnt specific, it just said a deal INVOLVING those players..

time for some yoghurt mr boy...no real interest here either and especially not for pick 7.

 

[smilingassassin]

Who's excited?

I sure as hell aren't..

Of course not - as far as trade deals go Collingwood fans never have anything to get excited about. When you do get excited Eddie and Mick let you down. Sad that.

 

[morax]

Of course not - as far as trade deals go Collingwood fans never have anything to get excited about. When you do get excited Eddie and Mick let you down. Sad that.

here comes the resident expert on all things collingwood

 

[leonmagic]

Of course not - as far as trade deals go Collingwood fans never have anything to get excited about. When you do get excited Eddie and Mick let you down. Sad that.

What, one deal?

 

[the-rover]

Exactly.

It's amazing that TJ is the exact player that Melbourne fans love to bag (overrated, hasn't delivered after 5 years).

To hear some of them bag Ottens is simply laughable.

hasn't delivered in 5 years you say do you?
would a top 5 finish in the brownlow be delivering. i think so. oh no your right he should have won a brownlow by now. u tool

 

[Bakes]

I can honestly say..

THAT IS THE BIGGEST LOAD OF BS IVE EVER EVER HEARD!!

You're tellin' me! TJ (even his name sounds gay) is not worth two peices of tofu and a half eaten bag of stale twisties.

 

[leonmagic]

hasn't delivered in 5 years you say do you?
would a top 5 finish in the brownlow be delivering. i think so. oh no your right he should have won a brownlow by now. u tool

WTF???

Do I care what you think??

 

[dees_best]

leonmagic, what would you think of pick7 for TJ?

 

[leonmagic]

leonmagic, what would you think of pick7 for TJ?

It's a tough one.

I remember having a discussion on another board about this very proposal, and I ended up thinking yes, just.

Malthouse would do it, I'd think.

 

[dees_best]

It's a tough one.

I remember having a discussion on another board about this very proposal, and I ended up thinking yes, just.

Malthouse would do it, I'd think.

IMO it's touch and go for both club but certainly looms as a fair trade.

Both clubs would appear to benefit from it.

 

[lamby29]

You're tellin' me! TJ (even his name sounds gay) is not worth two peices of tofu and a half eaten bag of stale twisties.

Well duh. He's obviously worth a first round pick - minimum.

 

[Navy Blue and Red]

WTF???

Do I care what you think??

Great comeback that

 

[Navy Blue and Red]

You're tellin' me! TJ (even his name sounds gay) is not worth two peices of tofu and a half eaten bag of stale twisties.

Homophobic, can't spell, and wouldn't know a decent footballer if he bit you on the arse.

 

[Fall Out Boy]

We have absolutely no need for Johnstone.

Got a stack of midfield depth already, and whilst he does have talent, he rarely produces.

Chapman is of far more value to the Geelong Football Club.

 

[Z_K]

Phat, your sig is disturbing.

Remove it.

Now.

 

[JUBJUB]

Homophobic, can't spell, and wouldn't know a decent footballer if he bit you on the arse.

So TJ is an arse biter.

 

[DBAH0]

It's a tough one.

I remember having a discussion on another board about this very proposal, and I ended up thinking yes, just.

Malthouse would do it, I'd think.

Considering the quality in the draft is in the top 6, it's a tough decision. But Johnstone is like Ottens, only had 1 really good year. Personally I wouldn't do it.

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Phat, your sig is disturbing.

Remove it.

Now.

Hope it works out well for you, but i was getting Mitch-vibes as soon as i heard the news about Thompson.

Very similar so far.........