Recommitted Josh Kelly [re-signed]

[Wild Bill]

Good, but Scully is much, much better atm.

9 mill for 9 years. Not sure Scully would take a pay cut to come to the Roos.

 

[Snake_Baker]

The entire clip (C/- giantroo on the North board)


If Stkilda have a body language expert, then they wouldn't be too confident.

 

[Donkey Chop]

"Come to the Saints mate"

View attachment 367038

Bit of look at me type stuff from Joey there. Unusual for him

 

[Sarcoidevo]

Josh knows he that he is going to the Saints however he is somewhat troubled at how he is goung to break the news to his Giants team mates

 

[Donkey Chop]

Josh knows he that he is going to the Saints however he is somewhat troubled at how he is goung to break the news to his Giants team mates

Kelly for McCartin & the Saints first?

GWS probably wouldn't want McCartin though. Probably the saints first & the first they got from the Hawks

 

[Roadto2018]

Kelly for McCartin & the Saints first?

GWS probably wouldn't want McCartin though. Probably the saints first & the first they got from the Hawks

Massive price, likely to be pick 3-5 and 10-12, treloar and 28 went for 7 and and a future first (the value of it was unknown at the time), is Kelly worth more than Treloar was? By season's end maybe. Feel like our 2017 and 2018 firsts would be fair with nothing coming back like Collingwood got, if it was our pick (this or next year) and the hawks pick I'd expect something coming back. All depending on whether or not he does actually want to leave of course, hard to see him turning down North's offer if he does though.

 

[JG22]

The decision is being made as we speak.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

Kelly for McCartin & the Saints first?

GWS probably wouldn't want McCartin though. Probably the saints first & the first they got from the Hawks

Yeah, no way McCartin Cameron and Patton all play in the same team.

 

[king rising]

The decision is being made as we speak.

yeah it is. choosing between North and GWS. Saints not even in the picture. in fact, i'd say after North have a resounding upset win over the crows this arvo his decision will be made.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Yeah, no way McCartin Cameron and Patton all play in the same team.

Massive price, likely to be pick 3-5 and 10-12, treloar and 28 went for 7 and and a future first (the value of it was unknown at the time), is Kelly worth more than Treloar was? By season's end maybe. Feel like our 2017 and 2018 firsts would be fair with nothing coming back like Collingwood got, if it was our pick (this or next year) and the hawks pick I'd expect something coming back. All depending on whether or not he does actually want to leave of course, hard to see him turning down North's offer if he does though.

He's worth the same as Treloar. Just as good at the same age.

GWS will want picks. Spose it just depends where North finish as to what picks they'll need to use

 

[JG22]

yeah it is. choosing between North and GWS. Saints not even in the picture. in fact, i'd say after North have a resounding upset win over the crows this arvo his decision will be made.

Started sensibly, then lost me.

I do think the same to be honest.

But last night was timely.

 

[king rising]

Started sensibly, then lost me.

I do think the same to be honest.

But last night was timely.

all in good faith. was a great win by st.kilda.

 

[Donkey Chop]

What are the odds that GWS approached the Saints to try to get a higher price from North?

 

[Colonial]

What are the odds that GWS approached the Saints to try to get a higher price from North?

Dont think we have given up on him yet so i doubt we are shopping around this early in the year.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[JG22]

What are the odds that GWS approached the Saints to try to get a higher price from North?

Bains may have an impact.

 

[Donkey Chop]

Dont think we have given up on him yet so i doubt we are shopping around this early in the year.

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

You're CEO sounded like they have been at the very least been discussing what the possibilities are.

Bains may have an impact.

How so? Does he know Josh?

 

[The Filth Wizard]

What are the odds that GWS approached the Saints to try to get a higher price from North?

Is it a higher price though? If come the end of the season Hawthorn finish above North (they should) and Saints are around 4th or 5th (they could) our first and second represents pretty good value compared to the Saints two firsts (and that's if St Kilda want to deal with both).

 

[Donkey Chop]

Is it a higher price though? If come the end of the season Hawthorn finish above North (they should) and Saints are around 4th or 5th (they could) our first and second represents pretty good value compared to the Saints two firsts (and that's if St Kilda want to deal with both).

I'm just trying to make sense of it. From what I've heard North have been in Kelly's ear for years and now the Saints are popping up at the last minute.

 

[Glen Buterol]

I'm just trying to make sense of it. From what I've heard North have been in Kelly's ear for years and now the Saints are popping up at the last minute.

Saints have been Kelly fans from when he played junior footy. We did everything we could to draft him in his draft year & if rumours are true were close to securing pick 2 from the Dees until GWS came in with a better offer.

You would have to be naive to think St Kilda as well as a number of other clubs weren't asking the question from Kelly's management. Saints, like North, & possibly another club or two, are in a great position to get him. Saints have the Money + draft picks. North obviously favourites with the much publicised 9mill / 9yr offer in front of Josh.

 

[GetDimmaBack]

Ward played a great game tonight. One of the most underrated players in the comp

Not by Dogs supporters...

 

[Donkey Chop]

Saints have been Kelly fans from when he played junior footy. We did everything we could to draft him in his draft year & if rumours are true were close to securing pick 2 from the Dees until GWS came in with a better offer.

You would have to be naive to think St Kilda as well as a number of other clubs weren't asking the question from Kelly's management. Saints, like North, & possibly another club or two, are in a great position to get him. Saints have the Money + draft picks. North obviously favourites with the much publicised 9mill / 9yr offer in front of Josh.

And the fact he comes from a North Melbourne family

 

[The Filth Wizard]

I'm just trying to make sense of it. From what I've heard North have been in Kelly's ear for years and now the Saints are popping up at the last minute.

They'd definitely signed Fyfe the other day.

 

[JG22]

You're CEO sounded like they have been at the very least been discussing what the possibilities are.



How so? Does he know Josh?

He's a smart man around trade discussions

 

[joop]

It's good money obviously, but why would he want to go to north? They're at the start of the rebuild and by taking 9m over 9 years it doesn't exactly leave much wiggle room to attack good free agents in the future.

 

[Snake_Baker]

It's good money obviously, but why would he want to go to north? They're at the start of the rebuild and by taking 9m over 9 years it doesn't exactly leave much wiggle room to attack good free agents in the future.

LOL

Are you watching North V Adelaide?