Remove this Banner Ad

Josh or Jobe..?

  • Thread starter Thread starter JBSwan
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Both excellent players but at the mo if have to go to jobe. As others have pointed out jobe has 4 years on him and Kennedy has only played regular season footy for 3 and half years
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Great article, I think they're both very similar to Diesel Williams as players.
Josh will finish his career with a Brownlow, I had a $50 on him last year after 2 rounds haha.
 
I couldn't separate them last season. This season Jobes probably been marginally better.
 
It is sort of like the decision to have the chocolate cake with ice cream or whipped cream. Who cares? Both plates have cake.

Paying to watch either of these play is worth it. That's all that matters in the end. Truly elite players.
 
Pewdy said:
Wait..Jobe Watson won the Brownlow last year D:
They're both great players, no doubt about that. Although, in my opinion I'd rather have JPK simply due to the age difference.
Click to expand...

a temporary award (strong sources say it will be revoked)
 

Remove this Banner Ad

PluggersPig said:
hey Mr Uppercut, what are you doing in here?

We were just about to discuss our chances for back to back this year when you vanished all of a sudden
Click to expand...

There seems to be some obsession with Lance on here. He didn’t vanish.

He got attacked for starting a congratulations thread and now attacked for his absence, he’s getting shot at both ends. As Lance came on this board to discuss the game genuinely. He deserves better than the way we deal with Adelaide trolls.

The swans board has always welcomed all supporters for a genuine discussion even if it is to give opposing viewpoint.
 
CAS79 said:
There seems to be some obsession with Lance on here. He didn’t vanish.

He got attacked for starting a congratulations thread and now attacked for his absence, he’s getting shot at both ends. As Lance came on this board to discuss the game genuinely. He deserves better than the way we deal with Adelaide trolls.

The swans board has always welcomed all supporters for a genuine discussion even if it is to give opposing viewpoint.
Click to expand...

I agree everyone is welcome. Lance just seems to be spending a lot of time putting out spot fires all over this forum. I am not sure, but I think he has become very sensitive on certain issure pertaining to his beloved club. (if you understand Mr Uppercut, you will also understand what his "uh-huh" post really means - it could not lay there unanswered)
 
PluggersPig said:
I am not sure, but I think he has become very sensitive on certain issure pertaining to his beloved club.
Click to expand...


If that issue happened with our clubs I am pretty sure that each and every one of us would be feeling sensitive about it as well (And it would be best for all clubs if Essendon were somehow found innocent of the whole situation).

Anyways back onto the topic, Would love to have Watson in our team at the moment as he is probably the best midfielder in the game besides Gary Abblett Jr and that includes JPK although luckily for us JPK has an extra 4 years to catch up to him.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

bonzaburgers said:
If that issue happened with our clubs I am pretty sure that each and every one of us would be feeling sensitive about it as well (And it would be best for all clubs if Essendon were somehow found innocent of the whole situation).

Anyways back onto the topic, Would love to have Watson in our team at the moment as he is probably the best midfielder in the game besides Gary Abblett Jr and that includes JPK although luckily for us JPK has an extra 4 years to catch up to him.
Click to expand...

If they have done something wrong, it's best for all clubs, the game and sports for them to be punished so this sort of alleged substance abuse is stopped and shonky sports scientists have their influence drastically reduced.
 
S120 said:
If they have done something wrong, it's best for all clubs, the game and sports for them to be punished so this sort of alleged substance abuse is stopped and shonky sports scientists have their influence drastically reduced.
Click to expand...
Absolutely. If this had happened at our club I would want those responsible for it gone immediately, and I hope others would too. Nothing justifies cheating and jeopardising the health of our players.
 
S120 said:
If they have done something wrong, it's best for all clubs, the game and sports for them to be punished so this sort of alleged substance abuse is stopped and shonky sports scientists have their influence drastically reduced.
Click to expand...


That's true, I am just saying I hope they are found to have done nothing wrong (Although it is very very unlikely)
 
Pewdy said:
Wait..Jobe Watson won the Brownlow last year D:
They're both great players, no doubt about that. Although, in my opinion I'd rather have JPK simply due to the age difference.
Click to expand...
Essendon were a depleted unit last year. No doubting his ability, but he was one of their only stand out consistent performers. Had Jobe been playing at Sydney, Hawthorn or even the Pies I doubt he would have a medal.
 
CAS79 said:
There seems to be some obsession with Lance on here. He didn’t vanish.

He got attacked for starting a congratulations thread and now attacked for his absence, he’s getting shot at both ends. As Lance came on this board to discuss the game genuinely. He deserves better than the way we deal with Adelaide trolls.

The swans board has always welcomed all supporters for a genuine discussion even if it is to give opposing viewpoint.
Click to expand...

Geez you're selective in what you write...
 
Swandwagonner said:
Essendon were a depleted unit last year. No doubting his ability, but he was one of their only stand out consistent performers. Had Jobe been playing at Sydney, Hawthorn or even the Pies I doubt he would have a medal.
Click to expand...

One of the biggest myths is teammates stealing votes. What about Judd, Cousins, Black, Akermanis, Ablett, Bartel, Swan, etc etc?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom