Remove this Banner Ad

Player Watch Josh Smith (Delisted 2018)

  • Thread starter Thread starter Spatfers
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Apex36 said:
WC making the same mistake that we did, being seduced by his endurance and work ethic without taking in to account he’s incapable of playing attacking football.
Click to expand...

So another Kyle Martin
 
Apex36 said:
WC making the same mistake that we did, being seduced by his endurance and work ethic without taking in to account he’s incapable of playing attacking football.
Click to expand...
He’s really just cheap depth; that’s all they probably doing, getting some cheap conveyance in case required.
I’m sure they know he’s limited; but at least disciplined.
 
TradeDraft said:
So another Kyle Martin
Click to expand...
Kyle wasn’t really keen enough to want to be a league footballer, Smith certainly is keen to be a league player.
 
Love his application, has a serious tank and knows how to get his hands on it. Played his best footy for us early on as a wingman who liked to get forward. Unfortunately, in a team chock full of midfielders we tried to turn him into a backman, which he just wasn't. Wish him all the very best.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I also wish him all the best, but he is depth only.
Does everything the coaches ask and more, but he does need something extra in his game
 
Saintly Viewed said:
Kyle wasn’t really keen enough to want to be a league footballer, Smith certainly is keen to be a league player.
Click to expand...

Different scenario in my opinion. Kyle would rack up possessions galore in the VFL & dominate in the midfield against everyone & anyone.
Then when he finally got his chance it was in a forward pocket in a side that really struggled to kick goals on a good day. He was a midfielder not a forward pocket.
In my opinion Martin was way better than Smith. Didn't have his tank though that's for sure.
 
si tacuisses said:
Kyle Martin just didn't have the drive IMO. Smith is the opposite, all drive but lacks the talent. Good luck to him though, always like seeing those kind of players make it.
Click to expand...
A cross between Kyle Martin and Josh Smith would be interesting...
 
Saintly Viewed said:
A cross between Kyle Martin and Josh Smith would be interesting...
Click to expand...

Wait, does the crossover get the good bits or the bad bits? Because the good bits together we've seen, they get drafted first round... and the bad bits together we've also seen (and sometimes they also get drafted first round, lol).
 
Apex36 said:
WC making the same mistake that we did, being seduced by his endurance and work ethic without taking in to account he’s incapable of playing attacking football.
Click to expand...

It's more than that. Smith suits the WC style of football which is possession based. He has more value to them than us because his playing qualities suit them.
 
si tacuisses said:
Wait, does the crossover get the good bits or the bad bits? Because the good bits together we've seen, they get drafted first round... and the bad bits together we've also seen (and sometimes they also get drafted first round, lol).
Click to expand...
The good bits.

:)


The bad bits... that’s more Carlton reserves level.
 
TradeDraft said:
So another Kyle Martin
Click to expand...
Uh, what? Kyle Martin was the polar opposite. Had talent to burn but didn’t want to put in the hard yards.
 
Quicky said:
It's more than that. Smith suits the WC style of football which is possession based. He has more value to them than us because his playing qualities suit them.
Click to expand...
And ours isn’t? We had the highest disposal numbers in the league last year, about 10% more than WC on average. If holding up play and being so afraid of turning the ball over that you’re incapable of kicking forwards suits WC game style I’ll eat my hat.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Apex36 said:
And ours isn’t? We had the highest disposal numbers in the league last year, about 10% more than WC on average. If holding up play and being so afraid of turning the ball over that you’re incapable of kicking forwards suits WC game style I’ll eat my hat.
Click to expand...

Very different for them. They actually have key forwards. They'd hold, hold, hold then go very direct. I think Josh Smith makes a lot of sense for West Coast and is more likely to have a role than with us.
 
Prior to the draft I was worried that giving up pick 57 for the Beams deal was going to affect our ability to match for Quaynor and Kelly without going into deficit.

Given Brisbane's list manager said they feel their list is at a point where they want players over draft picks, I wonder if we should have offered up Smith given he is a Queenslander, over pick 57? I'd say he's about worth a pick 57 anyway.

Obviously it doesn't matter because we ended up matching without going into deficit, but had we kept pick 57 we would have had a few extra points after matching that we could have considered someone a bit higher than Atu. But of course that's not to say Atu is necessarily a bad choice at all, just seems more speculative at that end of the draft.
 
Pragmatic Shill said:
Prior to the draft I was worried that giving up pick 57 for the Beams deal was going to affect our ability to match for Quaynor and Kelly without going into deficit.

Given Brisbane's list manager said they feel their list is at a point where they want players over draft picks, I wonder if we should have offered up Smith given he is a Queenslander, over pick 57? I'd say he's about worth a pick 57 anyway.

Obviously it doesn't matter because we ended up matching without going into deficit, but had we kept pick 57 we would have had a few extra points after matching that we could have considered someone a bit higher than Atu. But of course that's not to say Atu is necessarily a bad choice at all, just seems more speculative at that end of the draft.
Click to expand...
I assume he meant good players.
 
Pragmatic Shill said:
Sure, but I would have thought Smith would fit into the high pressure gameplan Brisbane is developing. But I don't really know how Noah Answerth played in draft footy.
Click to expand...
High pressure is the exact style Smith doesn’t fit in. He’s slow and has no defensive nouse or hardness. In saying that I don’t think they’re are any game styles that suit Smith anyways.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Pragmatic Shill said:
Prior to the draft I was worried that giving up pick 57 for the Beams deal was going to affect our ability to match for Quaynor and Kelly without going into deficit.

Given Brisbane's list manager said they feel their list is at a point where they want players over draft picks, I wonder if we should have offered up Smith given he is a Queenslander, over pick 57? I'd say he's about worth a pick 57 anyway.

Obviously it doesn't matter because we ended up matching without going into deficit, but had we kept pick 57 we would have had a few extra points after matching that we could have considered someone a bit higher than Atu. But of course that's not to say Atu is necessarily a bad choice at all, just seems more speculative at that end of the draft.
Click to expand...
I think by that point in the trade period, Brisbane pretty much conceeded it was too late to get a player considering they would have to consent and then go through medicals etc. In any case, Josh got to where he wanted, Brisbane got what they wanted, and so did we.
 
Jen2310 said:
I think by that point in the trade period, Brisbane pretty much conceeded it was too late to get a player considering they would have to consent and then go through medicals etc. In any case, Josh got to where he wanted, Brisbane got what they wanted, and so did we.
Click to expand...
True point Jen, although the only thing I would say is I don't think Josh really wanted to go the Eagles as such.
 
Pragmatic Shill said:
True point Jen, although the only thing I would say is I don't think Josh really wanted to go the Eagles as such.
Click to expand...
Where do you think he wanted to go? I actually thought he was going to sign with Gold Coast. He did fly over there and did a medical, so this WC did throw me a bit. He probably didn't care at that point. As a delisted footballer, you're looking for any opportunity no matter where it is.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

TradeDraft
    • Like
Player Watch Welcome to Collingwood Amy Smith
Replies
4
Views
244
Robroy22
Robroy22
BigVic
    • Like
2006-2013 vs 2018-2024
Replies
4
Views
481
PonsfordMagpie
PonsfordMagpie

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom