Kelly or Prismall?

[Scarlett30]

Who do you guys think will play this week out of these two?

I think the bench will be Rooke, Blake, Playfair, but i cant split these two.

Prismall has the form, Kelly has the experience

 

[Saint3r]

I would go for Kelly, genuine class..

If you are wondering what I'm doing here, the whole family follows Geelong.

By the way, any chance of PM'ing the email to me???

 

[LifeSpan-Void]

Prismall.

 

[Bronx Bomber]

I would go for Kelly, genuine class..

Prismall had 20 disposals, & 4 marks last week against Brisbane, you can't drop the kid after that!

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Prismall.

You can't keep calling up a kid, see him rack up 15-20 effective touches and dump him back to the reserves the next week.

With both Rooke and Ablett under a cloud it wouldn't be a surprise if there was a late change and both played.

 

[Jack-Packenham]

Bench should be Blake Kelly Prismall and Rooke

 

[Soupy]

WTF is playfair on the bench for?

Surley we wouldnt go in with King, Otto, Moons, Playfair and Blake

Playfair out

Kelly and Prissa both in.

 

[scottydeewah]

Interesting I had a discussion with patdman about this tonight. I said we should entertain offers for Kelly as Prismall is an ideal replacement. He tended to agree but the trade would have to be there.

Gotta leave Prismal in i think

 

[jess_555]

I pick PRIZZA by a mile!!!!

I have been sooooo angry with Kelly over this year. He looks so lazy... but not nearly as much as SJ looks. LOL I bet Kel will get picked over Priz because Thompson loves him and he has more experience.

 

[TheTimeCometh]

*If you are wondering what I'm doing here, the whole family follows Geelong.

By the way, any chance of PM'ing the email to me???*


this is like the popularity i never had at highschool!

 

[Unwritten_Law]

WTF is playfair on the bench for?

Surley we wouldnt go in with King, Otto, Moons, Playfair and Blake

Playfair out

Kelly and Prissa both in.

Prismall and Kingsley in.

Kingsley is more mobile than Playfair, so the balance will be ok, and will kick goals as the third tall in the forward line without a suitable opponent.

 

[Dasher39]

I thought this was going to be a 'Who would you prefer to keep on the list at seasons end?' (not that we should be trading Prismall).

The answer to that question and the question of the thread is Prismall.

Will be a star given the opportunity.

 

[darren forssman]

kelly's tether has been reached....

 

[Mooney_d'King]

I thought this was going to be a 'Who would you prefer to keep on the list at seasons end?' (not that we should be trading Prismall).

The answer to that question and the question of the thread is Prismall.

Will be a star given the opportunity.

Yes yes yes!

 

[JUBJUB]

Who do you guys think will play this week out of these two?

I think the bench will be Rooke, Blake, Playfair, but i cant split these two.

Prismall has the form, Kelly has the experience

H won't play
The Prismall/Kelly decision is an easy one after last weeks game [Prismall],but both will play
The bench will be Rooke,Blake,Prismall,Kelly [Byrnes in if Jr doesn't play]

 

[Lindenow Cat]

Prismall looks like turning into the player we all hoped and thought Tenace would be. Impressive so far.

 

[SJ]

I would go for Kelly, genuine class..

If you are wondering what I'm doing here, the whole family follows Geelong.

By the way, any chance of PM'ing the email to me???

Hahaha, you're using your own St Kilda tactic on us. Mate, forget the reputations, he's been pathetic. You want him? We'll take Rooey.

 

[winty]

I'd pick Prismall any day of the week. Like Jess, I too have been critical of Kelly's workrate this year, but not only that, some of his disposal this year has been very ordinary, especially early in games. Dropping Prismall after good efforts in the seniors wouldn't be too good for his development IMO. If his form warranted being dropped, then well and good, but he was one of our better players last week, and to the best of my recollection, Kelly didn't exactly set the world on fire.

 

[geelong32]

prismall must play, looks like he has a touch of class, kinglsey plays at the expense of henry. otto in the goal square with kingsley being the leading option. kingsley in form adds allot to our forward structure.

 

[jess_555]

kingsley in form adds a lot to our forward structure.

 

[eliiiiza]

Prismall any day. Works harder.

 

[Prismall]

ummm.....Prismall

 

[Scarlett30]

well.....

IN: Ablett, Mooney
OUT: Bartel, Kelly

Looks like Prismall wins.

 

[thegerman]

well.....

IN: Ablett, Mooney
OUT: Bartel, Kelly

Looks like Prismall wins.

Good picks, think we should keep H in the lineup, plus with Ablett we also get a hard ball nut along with Prismall. Moons starts at CHF, and can be changed quickly if the backline is struggling with Kosi. Shouldn't though as he hasn't played for ages, and should be a bit soft on plays and getting the hard ball.

We should put Mooney in the middle for a bit also, let him make some havoc like he did last year.

 

[gocats_17]

James Kelly.... no doubt.... when he's no longer carrying any injuries he will be back!