List Changes

[Dale Didak #134]

These are my wishes
IN: P. Medhurst - Fre Small Foward
H. O'Brien - Elavated Rookie HBF
D. Nicholls - Elavated Rookie - Mid
Pick 8 - Joel Selwood - Midfielder
Pick 10 - Nathan Brown - KPP CHB
Pick 28 - Kurt Tippett - Ruck
Pick 44 - Todd Goldstein Ruck
Pick 63 - Dean Kelly - Mid/Foward
PSD 10 - Luke Brennan

OUT Blake Caracella - Retired
Chad Morrison - Retired
Brent Hall
David Fanning
Adam Iacobucci
Julian Rowe
Chris Tarrant
Cameron Cloke
Jason Cloke


Thoughts?

 

[daics35]

i agree with most though i'd keep cam cloke and get rid of tristan walker
sorry just noticed another thread saying that malthouse has thrown walkker a lifeline. i still think he should get the flick. cam cloke still has something to offer in my opinion, he's a big bloke who seems to like to play it physical i think you can afford to give blokes like that a bit of extra time.

 

[Dale Didak #134]

i agree with most though i'd keep cam cloke and get rid of tristan walker
sorry just noticed another thread saying that malthouse has thrown walkker a lifeline. i still think he should get the flick. cam cloke still has something to offer in my opinion, he's a big bloke who seems to like to play it physical i think you can afford to give blokes like that a bit of extra time.

I would like to keep C2 because he has a bit of grunt which is something we don't have. Plus, we need a bit of a hitman

 

[Rohan25]

These are my wishes
IN: P. Medhurst - Fre Small Foward
H. O'Brien - Elavated Rookie HBF
D. Nicholls - Elavated Rookie - Mid
Pick 8 - Joel Selwood - Midfielder
Pick 10 - Nathan Brown - KPP CHB
Pick 28 - Kurt Tippett - Ruck
Pick 44 - Todd Goldstein Ruck
Pick 63 - Dean Kelly - Mid/Foward
PSD 10 - Luke Brennan

OUT Blake Caracella - Retired
Chad Morrison - Retired
Brent Hall
David Fanning
Adam Iacobucci
Julian Rowe
Chris Tarrant
Cameron Cloke
Jason Cloke


Thoughts?

What is it about Brennan that took your eye?

 

[Dale Didak #134]

What is it about Brennan that took your eye?

Despite the fact that he will probably be available at pick 10 in the PSD, I like his versatility, being able to play foward and back. His height is also a little akward and being picked at pick 8 shows his potential

 

[daics cousin]

Don't mind your choices,however i would prefer to pick up up Selwood and proud at picks 8 and 10 if possible.Tippet or kennendy would be a good pick up and Kelly or hislop would be good pick ups .I still think we should pick up Keating if we don't have to give up much.He would be very good as a boom crash ruckman to help Josh in the short term till anyone (Who's a ruckman) we pick up from the draft can develp.Richards i have no faith in he will sidelined again next year.This bloke always gets injured.We should have delisted him and kept cam cloke.

 

[altonapiefan]

Don't mind your choices,however i would prefer to pick up up Selwood and proud at picks 8 and 10 if possible.Tippet or kennendy would be a good pick up and Kelly or hislop would be good pick ups .I still think we should pick up Keating if we don't have to give up much.He would be very good as a boom crash ruckman to help Josh in the short term till anyone (Who's a ruckman) we pick up from the draft can develp.Richards i have no faith in he will sidelined again next year.This bloke always gets injured.We should have delisted him and kept cam cloke.

Agree 100 %. We are all speculating on who has been delisted due to Age article, but truth is, some serious talks must be going on, we may be surprised with outcome. I would prefer Cam to others but must have other issues.

But agree, Richards has used injury as excuse for non-progress, he should go BUT won't. Tex has been no good. But our BIG problem is exactly that, all the BIG men outside our best 22, are basically useless. We cannot get rid of them all. We need back up. If we got Keating at least he is a quality player can have for possibly 2 years until some tall of promise comes up. Poor Josh Fraser, needs his S.O.S. for help rescued soon, otherwise will burnout too son.

 

[Jabso]

Someone who talked to Adrian Fletcher not that long ago (he went to Tassie for some legends match) said that while Fletcher said "you'd know more than me" about the delistings he did admit that Hall was definately gone.