lucas to west coast

[IceTemple]

Originally posted by slugger
Best swap ever was Cocky to Port for a pair of footy socks and a half-eaten hot dog.

 

[Bartholin Juice]

Originally posted by Tinker
I would disagree, I dont think he is captaincy material because when he is down and getting beaten he lacks ticker - no second effort. You never EVER see that in Hird.

But then I have never been a fan of Lucas, have always considered him over-rated. Sorry.

Lucas is one of the hardest working players in the team, always makes a contest.

 

[Bartholin Juice]

Re: Re: lucas to west coast

Originally posted by Broadbridge_20
Essendon would be raping West Coast with that deal.

If you could get Kerr, even better.

No. KPPs, especially those that can play both ends of the ground, are extremely valuable. Look at Rawlings, his price was inflated because he is a KPP, and he was the only one of note on the market. Lucas is a premiership player, a B&F winner, was unlucky to miss out on CHB in the 2003 AA squad, and has kicked 50 goals at CHF. If he was put up for trade, I can almost guarantee you that Essendon would get more than Fletcher.

 

[Tinker]

Originally posted by Bartholin Juice
Lucas is one of the hardest working players in the team, always makes a contest.

Sorry but I disagree. Just not a fan and have never been.

I'll grant that he has improved over the last couple of years....but I still think he is grossly over-rated.

 

[Yabba]

If we could get a quality midfielder i.e Kerr then it would need to be looked at. We will have enough KPP with Lay(ock, Richards, Hunt and Bradley all to make a senior impact.

I would hate to lose him but there are players there to try and fill his gap if he does go, which I really doubt