Could've at least said...show some respect....champ!
Luke Shuey - Where Does He Rank?
- Thread starter Mop
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Jul 14, 2022
- 1,538
- 2,540
- AFL Club
- West Coast
When compared to one of the greatest games in modern times then no, he doesnāt.
Judd plays 18 GF instead of shuey and we lose 9/10 times.
Carbine Chaos
The Gaff-er
- Apr 1, 2009
- 63,949
- 94,296
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Perth FC, Everton, Delhi
Have to agree with this.
Mainly because Judd would have been 35 and 3 years into retirement.
Matera92
Brownlow Medallist
Why do we lose 9/10 times? How are you calculating these random percentages?
Is it not more likely that the player that has consistently been significantly better over their career have a greater impact on a game than not?
VicBased
Club Legend
- May 3, 2019
- 2,968
- 3,245
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Yeah but can Jesus football?
Last edited:
- Jul 28, 2018
- 784
- 3,078
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Judd in the conversation for best player in the modern game. Also at his peak he was ridiculous, and a more noted big game performer. Shueyās GF was amazing granted but the 9/10 thing is such a long bow. Not too many win Normās in losing GFās either
- Jul 14, 2022
- 1,538
- 2,540
- AFL Club
- West Coast
THE A5
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 26, 2020
- 9,364
- 16,643
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Apparently moves on grass as if heās on water
Judd's peak and as a player particularly for West Coast is at a significantly higher level than Shuey's ability is.
However Shuey does have the highest impact rating for any grand final since recording stats. Literally 30% higher than Martin's best norm smith performance.
You can argue about any great player being a better player than Shuey and you are almost always right, but in that grand final he put in a performance that was above and beyond what anyone has done in modern times. As he's actually done it, you can make up all the hypotheticals you like but if anyone other than Shuey plays instead of him we likely lose. Shuey played half the match with a tag and was the only reason we were still in the game at half time. The only player who has a realistic claim to rivalling Shuey for that 2018 norm smith is Schofield as once he was moved onto degoey he won 11 consecutive one on ones against the player that had destroyed us up until that point. Hutchings and Sheed a distant third with Sheed kicking the winning goal in a great all round performance and Hutchings shutting down sidebottom stopping his amazing movement into the forward 50. You can probably list 6 players for our side who played their greatest ever game for us in that match and a lot of them were the unheralded players.
Matera won us our first premiership (along with Sumich, hugely underrated game) however tagging wasn't a thing and he played in a different era. He will always be remembered for that and along with Shuey in 2018 and Ablett in 1989 they are up there as the greatest norm smith winning performances.
The 2018 Grand final doesn't however change Shuey's ranking career wise in relation to our other mids and the truth is he is a good step behind the first tier and im probably being slightly harsh on Kemp here in only having Matera, Judd and Cousins in that group.
However Shuey does have the highest impact rating for any grand final since recording stats. Literally 30% higher than Martin's best norm smith performance.
You can argue about any great player being a better player than Shuey and you are almost always right, but in that grand final he put in a performance that was above and beyond what anyone has done in modern times. As he's actually done it, you can make up all the hypotheticals you like but if anyone other than Shuey plays instead of him we likely lose. Shuey played half the match with a tag and was the only reason we were still in the game at half time. The only player who has a realistic claim to rivalling Shuey for that 2018 norm smith is Schofield as once he was moved onto degoey he won 11 consecutive one on ones against the player that had destroyed us up until that point. Hutchings and Sheed a distant third with Sheed kicking the winning goal in a great all round performance and Hutchings shutting down sidebottom stopping his amazing movement into the forward 50. You can probably list 6 players for our side who played their greatest ever game for us in that match and a lot of them were the unheralded players.
Matera won us our first premiership (along with Sumich, hugely underrated game) however tagging wasn't a thing and he played in a different era. He will always be remembered for that and along with Shuey in 2018 and Ablett in 1989 they are up there as the greatest norm smith winning performances.
The 2018 Grand final doesn't however change Shuey's ranking career wise in relation to our other mids and the truth is he is a good step behind the first tier and im probably being slightly harsh on Kemp here in only having Matera, Judd and Cousins in that group.
- Sep 8, 2011
- 11,014
- 11,021
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Taking out the match committee and injuryās in ā05 the only reason we lost that game was because Daniel Kerr came off with a broken/fractured leg (he did come back on).
He was by far our best and most influential player when he was on the ground and when he was off was when Sydney did their damage.
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
- Chris Judd
- Ben Cousins
- Peter Matera
- Dean Kemp
- Daniel Kerr
- Matt Priddis
- Andrew Embley
- Luke Shuey
- Chris Mainwaring
- Chad Fletcher
HHM: the 2006-era WCE was stacked for midfielders, 7 are in contention for a top 20 of all time for WC and the top two are in discussion for top 20 in the AFL, period, really was a wasted period of midfield dominance being fed and supported by Dean Cox
1. Chris Judd
2. Ben Cousins
3. Peter Matera
4. Josh kennedy
5. Dean Kemp
6. Mainwaring
7. Matt Priddis
8 Daniel kerr
9. Andrew Embley
10 Luke Shuey
11. Dean cox
On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
2. Ben Cousins
3. Peter Matera
4. Josh kennedy
5. Dean Kemp
6. Mainwaring
7. Matt Priddis
8 Daniel kerr
9. Andrew Embley
10 Luke Shuey
11. Dean cox
On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Sep 21, 2004
- 37,182
- 26,029
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Norwood & Liverpool.
1. Cousins
2. JK
3. Peter Matera
4. Judd
5. Cox
6. Kerr
7. Shuey
8. Jakovich
9. McKenna
10. Embley
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
2. JK
3. Peter Matera
4. Judd
5. Cox
6. Kerr
7. Shuey
8. Jakovich
9. McKenna
10. Embley
On SM-S908E using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Aug 15, 2009
- 2,975
- 5,101
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Big Shuey fan here, but still think Schoey was the rightful norm smith winner.
One of the things I loved about Shuey was since day 1, he bought a winners mentality to the club, and even now you can still see him it in him, he has given this club his all.
One of the things I loved about Shuey was since day 1, he bought a winners mentality to the club, and even now you can still see him it in him, he has given this club his all.
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
Top 5 forwards in the AFL era:
1. Tom Boyd
2. Tom Lynch (Richmond)
3. Quinten Lynch
4. James Podsiadly
5. Shane Ellen
HM: Nick Riewoldt, Matthew Pavlich, Matthew Richardson, Tony Lockett, Gary Ablett Sr
- Jul 14, 2022
- 1,538
- 2,540
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Embley and Priddis above Shuey must be taking the piss.
it was literally the best GF performance of all time based off CD.
Forward Press
Hall of Famer
More due to Shuey's peak being shorter (not his fault entirely) - if he sustained 2018 for more than a couple of seasons he'd be a lock for top 5 - but he didn't so he isn't.
1. Judd
2. Cousins
3. Cox
4. Shuey
I havent included anyone before 2000 as i never watched footy back then
2. Cousins
3. Cox
4. Shuey
I havent included anyone before 2000 as i never watched footy back then
- Jul 14, 2022
- 1,538
- 2,540
- AFL Club
- West Coast
JK above shuey but yep, canāt have him lower than that since 2000.
Similar threads
- Locked
