Mackenzie needs to go.

[Audacious]

Is a turnover machine, and some of his decisions are pathetic. Walking the ball over the boundary line and getting deliberate free kick against summed up his footy smarts. Doesnt have what it takes to be up to AFL standard. I actually defended him earlier in the year when he cost us the game against the Sydney Swans, but he just doesnt learn. Reminds me of Phil Read and all the goals he would cost us from turnovers in defense.

Stop persisting with him please Woosha, its embarrassing.

 

[weagles_fan]

For his age and experience he's a pretty good stopper however every other part of his game is absolutely abysmal. Give him a few weeks in the WAFL and tell him to work on his skills and decision making. Next year is make or break. If he doesn't improve in any of skills or decision making he will be delisted next year hopefully.

 

[Lynch takes a mark]

Last week the coaches gave him votes for being one of the BOG and this week he needs to go ?

 

[Biggie]

Clueless.

Simply put.

Eric is a required player, who can hold his head up high in 2009.

Stupid knee jerk thread, quite possibly the worst knee jerk thread this season....and that is saying something.

 

[Byron_Clanger]

more like wirrpanda needs to go, looks 10 times slower than all the opponents hes played on today

 

[BadSeed]

more like wirrpanda needs to go, looks 10 times slower than all the opponents hes played on today

Judging by your alot of your comments I can understand why you have a yellow card....

 

[gx122]

more like Glass needs to go.. kicked 0 goals even though he was playing in the 50 all game

 

[tcwaters]

Should delist Cox, Kerr, Glass, Naita, Masten & Lecca while we're at it.

 

[TOA.]

Had the highest disposal efficiency in the side for the year to date, a couple of weeks back (not sure about now). But yeh ... turn over merchant FFS.

 

[mitchzz]

He just has a very lazy kick.

He should be giving it off on every occasion.

Good defender.

 

[beatlesmith]

Clueless.

Simply put.

Eric is a required player, who can hold his head up high in 2009.

Stupid knee jerk thread, quite possibly the worst knee jerk thread this season....and that is saying something.

+1
Was brilliant for the first half of the season. His disposal has dropped off, but he is still playing solid footy.
Wow, a young KP defender who is a proven stopper has problems with his disposal. Glass anyone?

 

[Embers]

Was brilliant defensively. Nearly put him in the votes.

Kept Tredrea fairly quiet given the amount of ball that went his way

 

[Play by Numbers]

Terrible OP.

Excellent young key defender who started the season very well.

Guess what he will make mistakes and personally I thought his defensive efforts were alright.

I know people get frustrated after a loss but this is just plain stupid.

Someone needs to give themselves a swift uppercut to the face.....

 

[CoastersFlag No.5]

I say persist in making audaciously dimwitted comments cause it's pretty audacious you considering dropping the guy who is a lock in for our best 6 in defence I suggest you take a look at Sphanger before having a go at Emac.

 

[CursoryMercenary]

agreedis!

 

[Tyberious Funk]

Was also one of the top players in the competition for 1%ers at one stage. Yeah, he's such a dud

 

[Crimson King]

He needs to get as much game time as he can get so that his development is accelerated. He has done commendable jobs on some of the best forwards in his career and there is no way he should be dropped unless he gets bags of goals kicked on him. Glassy and E-Mac are doing well for us.

 

[Eagle87]

He started the year like a train and has tailed off in my view. Still a kid with a developing body playing on guys like Riewoldt, Tredrea and Kosi ....

No way would we drop him but I reckon he might be looking forward to a rest - just looks worn down.

 

[larrikin]

Good point.

Some of his errors seem to be fatigue related. He's probably carrying a pretty sore body by this stage of the season, especially at that end of the ground the way we've played.

Been a great find for us this year though

 

[Spange]

Quite simply........ You are an idiot

Beat me to it. Why the hell would we drop a star defender of the future. Let him live and learn the hard way.

 

[billyboy 21]

I'd be interested to know how many people on this board have actually ever played a competitive game of footy. The pressure of running full pace to get a loose ball and then make the right decision once you get it, with an opponent bearing down on you.

It's easy to be critical when you in your heated house in your nice comfy chair with a beer in hand.

 

[bighit006]

Yep, get rid of this hanger on. He's getting in the way of our chance at a home final and premiership glory this year.

 

[Eagle Number1000]

I find this question annoying when we've got senior players like Hansen, Seaby, Staker, even Embley.
They would be first that needs to go.

And you shouldn't be so harsh on a young player thats had one off game.
Your just like those kn*bs who were having a go at Masten for making a couple of errors- Young players need time to develop-they make a errors. Give him 3-4 years before being critical.

 

[Cockie what a cracker!]

Is it just me or was thet deliberate out of bounds free kick an absolute joke? The exact same thing happens multiple time a game and is never called. The only thing that evened things up today was the other deliberate called against the power later in the game. Both were terrible decisions!

 

[Monkey Worshipper]

Geez I hate the 'down' cycles we have, only because of all the flogs that want to have their voices heard.