Mark Murphy or Adam Cooney

[OEGB]

Mark Murphy or Adam Cooney

who would you want in you' team

 

[F/D]

Adam Cooney comfortably.

Although Marks a good player.

 

[Silvagnis]

Marc Murphy isn't a bad player.

 

[F/D]

Marc Murphy isn't a bad player.

I knew there was something wrong with the title

 

[DG-Man]

This is a tough one. Late last year when the Coon Dog tore a few games apart with some scintillating clearances, i would have had him over Hodge or Ball. But this year he seems to only rack up small numbers (some doggy supporter is probably about to make me look stupid and post his stats for the year and they will be really high)
Might take Murphy...just!

 

[loki04]

Cooney

 

[demondude]

a more accurate poll would be mclean or murphy

 

[Top Dog]

a more accurate poll would be mclean or murphy

Why?

Similar stature?

Cooney has more runs on the board than McLean my friend.

 

[The_Flying_Egg]

This is a tough one. Late last year when the Coon Dog tore a few games apart with some scintillating clearances, i would have had him over Hodge or Ball. But this year he seems to only rack up small numbers (some doggy supporter is probably about to make me look stupid and post his stats for the year and they will be really high)
Might take Murphy...just!

His stats ain't super high, but he's still getting 19.5 touches a game, last year he was 19.7. Not a lot of difference, and this year he has 17 goals, he finished last season with 21 so statistically he's ahead of last year

People have been harsh on the Coondog this year, he's had a couple of down games, particularly in the first few rounds, but for the most part he's been very good. 20 touches from a player who spends quite a bit of time away from the middle is quite good, and he runs with the ball and uses it well. He'll most likely be in our top 5 or 6 in the B and F again which is a great performance from someone his age.

He's undoubtedly one of the most exciting young players going around and we are very lucky to have him and Griff in the same team.

 

[demondude]

Why?

Similar stature?

Cooney has more runs on the board than McLean my friend.

and mclean has been carrying an injury and is still racking up 25+ posessions a game

 

[geelong_falcons22]

always take the developed and proven player over potential