- Joined
- Jul 29, 2018
- Posts
- 9,865
- Reaction score
- 28,776
- AFL Club
- Carlton
You like everyone are entitled to opinions. Some of them may be right and some wrong.I understand people desire not not sack another coach. There are very valid reasons why it's not an ideal proposition.
There have been numerous success stories over the last decade of clubs sticking fat with their coach and turning things around. But each of these success stories have followed a narrative of a head coach, loved by the playing group, admitting fault, changing their tactics and messaging to suit the playing group they have, accepting guidance and supported by a very strong back of house football program.
Where it gets difficult for us is.... we don't have any of these things.
Our club is and has been run woefully for the last 20 years. It's all very grand to preach stability.. but stability only makes sense if you have the fundamentals in place to start off with.
Our problems are so multifaceted and run so deep that at times it is very hard to see light at the end of the tunnel.
Our on field problems are plain for all to see. The communication between the playing group and the coaching staff isn't working, which has led to confusion. Confusion leads to perceived pressure which leads to mistakes. Confidence and trust is shot to bits, and the cycle continues.
Our off field problems are even worse. The club is always caught between two worlds. We have had football departments dating back to even before the Swann focussed on the business side of things. A lot of this started with the club needing to find ways of paying off its historic debt, and have continued all the way through the redevelopments of IKON park. But great football clubs are run by great football minds first, and great businessmen second.
Growing the brand so much and so quickly always results in the same thing, and especially for Carlton. A huge and passionate fan and membership base who judge the team by results and the club by their footballing decisions.
The business people, being the way they are, get concerned to quickly about damage to the brand and make uneducated decisions. The sacking of Ratten for example, even the sacking of Bolton. The noise that led to the hiring of Teague.... But the one that sticks in my mind the most was after Neil Craig retired we decided not to replace his role and left Bolton, a genuinely genius footballing mind, but someone who needed support to evolve as a coach, hung out to dry.
And then there is the Carlton Alumni or mafia for want of a better term, and there very rich, very noisy and very powerful backers. Who despite not holding official positions of power within the club (except for Diesel, don't get me started on him. Love the player... but seriously!) still pull the strings in ways that very few, if any other clubs (maybe Essendon until this year) have to deal with.
The greatest problem with all this is, its no secret within football circles. Its a joke to other clubs. It's at the point now that we can't attract the type of people we need to get to the club. There is no doubt at all that if Clarkson believed he could implement the program he wanted, he would not of taken his sabbatical last year. (I know things have changed in that space, but I'm using it as a pre 2023 example). It is why someone like Hardwick would much prefer to go to Gold Coast or North Melbourne in the coming years than consider us.
We can only attract the people who are in the twilight of their careers and are more than happy to accept a huge boost to their retirement fund.
With all this being said, it doesn't change my opinion of the fact that I do not think Voss is the man to lead us out of it. For all his strengths as a player and a person, he is not and has never been a good or smart coach. He was an incredible leader on field in his actions. But you cannot do this from the coaches box. It is becoming visible that he is losing the playing group, they are completely devoid of confidence in the game plan and its leading to them being completely devoid of confidence in their own footballing abilities.
If and when the change is made, it needs to be complete. We cannot go through another review, sack a couple of people along the way yet leave the core operators of the club to continue along their merry dance of using our Football club as a rich man's play toy.
The AFL has come on leaps and bounds in the last 30 years and is now right up there with one of the most professional sports in the world. Yet at Carlton we still behave like its 1970. It's time for us to wake up and actually fix this systemic rot.
But they are not facts and I am sure not based on knowledge of the inner workings of the club and the league and its personnel, yet you write as if that is the case.
I mean for example how would you know what Hardwick might want or do? Or Clarkson, or anyone.





"Goddess"

