Remove this Banner Ad

Mid Year Report: Sydney

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Joined
Mar 20, 2007
Posts
31,806
Reaction score
31,363
AFL Club
West Coast
Win-loss: 6-5 (LWWLWLLWWLW)


AAMidseasonreports_b.jpg

The run home:
Round 12 - Collingwood (Telstra Stadium)
Round 13 - Geelong (Skilled Stadium)
Round 14 - Fremantle (SCG)
Round 15 - Carlton (SCG)
Round 16 - West Coast (Subiaco)
Round 17 - Richmond (SCG)
Round 18 - Melbourne (Manuka Oval)
Round 19 - St Kilda (Telstra Stadium)
Round 20 - Brisbane (Gabba)
Round 21 - Collingwood (MCG)
Round 22 - Hawthorn (SCG)
Ladder position: 7th


Leading possession winner: Brett Kirk (241)


Leading goalkicker: Barry Hall (22)


Season so far
The Swans might have been a little inconsistent but they aren’t in bad shape at all.
In fact, this season’s campaign is starting to look remarkably similar to those of recent years.
We’ve seen in the past couple of seasons how Paul Roos’ men haven’t looked a million dollars at the half-way stage, but they’ve powered towards the finish line.
While the form of a couple of big names in the early part of the season has been a concern, the fact the Swans are seventh and the likes of Barry Hall and Adam Goodes are yet to approach anywhere near top gear is an ominous sign for rival clubs.
Twin towers Darren Jolly and Spida Everitt appear to have formed a neat partnership in the ruck, and if they can continue their supremacy in the second half of the season the Swans might have that extra zip that left them just short in 2006.


Best win A toss-up between the Swans’ round-nine triumph over the Western Bulldogs and their most recent victory, the round-11 struggle against the Hawks.
To the neutral observer the win over the Doggies might have looked far prettier and more polished, but those who have watched the Swans longer and closer would know the result against Hawthorn might have meant more.
Not only was it achieved against a top-four side playing on its home turf and in red-hot form, but it was finals-type footy.
The Swans went in on the back of a one-point loss to Essendon and with a 5-5 record, so another defeat6 heading into the split round simply would have been unacceptable.
Returning to the MCG, Roos’ men lifted to record their seventh win from their past eight encounters at the ground, drawing on their experience in the tight clash to outlast the young Hawks and perhaps set up their own season.


Best goal so farWhen his side needs him to deliver, co-captain Leo Barry knows what’s required.
The Swans were peppering the goals in the final term in round three against Brisbane but with little success. Barry lifted all his teammates when he gathered on the wing, dodged two opponents, took a bounce and kicked truly from outside 50m.
His goal not only brought the home fans to their feet, but levelled the scores. The Swans would not be headed again as they bolted clear of the Lions to record a convincing win.
Best and fairest leaders With agroupsuch as the Swans where each player is so focused on the teamethos, it must sometimes be difficult for the coaching staff to give votes after matches.
While it has been an up-and-down ride so far this year, there have been some regularly consistent performers who, although perhaps not big ball-winners, would no doubt be polling well in the club awards.
Reliable defenders Craig Bolton and Leo Barry have had terrific years down back, Ben Mathews has performed some admirable run-with roles while the emergence of Nick Malceski has been a real highlight for the club in 2007.
Inspirational co-captain Brett Kirk continues to lead by example and do plenty of the tough stuff while winning his share of the footy.
Ryan O’Keefe’s enormous engine has allowed him to get to plenty of contests and, more often than not, win plenty of possessions for his side in another impressive season so far.


Surprise packet
Nick Malceski. Everyone knew he was a good player, but just how important he’s become to the Swans was impossible to predict.
He’s shown this year with his run and piercing, penetrating left boot just what a player he can be.
And now, with Tadhg Kennelly succumbing to a knee injury for the second time this season, he’ll become the centre of even more attention from opposition clubs. But, so far at least, Malceski has risen to every challenge.


Coaches' award (one-percenter player)
Jude Bolton continues to lead by example for his teammates, tackling, smothering and throwing himself into every contest with seemingly no regard for his own welfare.


Second-half story linesCan the Swans finally gather some momentum or will their up-and-down form continue? History suggests they will string some wins together at some stage, but the question is when?
Will big, bad Barry regain his bustle? Will Adam Goodes re-discover his Brownlow Medal-winning form? If the pair can hit their straps at the same time, their rivals had better look out.
Can Spida’s legs carry the Swans that extra step? Some have said the former Hawk ruckman arrived in Sydney a year too late. But if Peter Everitt helps the Swans to a Grand Final appearance – and a premiership – then the big man was surely worth the wait.
 
What's the source? Did you write this yourself or is it filched from somewhere?

FWIW

I reckon Kirk would be leading the B&F from Craig Bolton.

I think our best win was against the Hawks but our best performance was against the Power (I rate it slightly higher than the Dogs game).

Malceski is an interesting one. I don't know if I'm surprised with him or not. I saw him play two reserves games - one in 2005 and one at the very start of 2006 - that were so sublime that, even allowing for the lowish standard of the competition, I knew he could become absolutely anything. I am maybe a little taken aback by how quickly he's brought that confidence and aplomb to senior level football but it was only a matter of time. And I am ultra pleased that he's going in and tackling hard and putting his body on the line too. There was a chance he'd be prepared to rest on his superb "outside" ability and I am very very happy to see him trying to become a complete player.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Agree with most of that except for the B&F. I think Malceski should be quite a way in front of Kirk, C. Bolton, while Spida would be racking up a few in recent weeks. If Leo had not kicked the two goals on Saturday i think he would have been one of the worst.


How so? He kept Boyle almost touchless and provided a lot of rebound. He had a couple of brain freezes but we'd be disappointed if he didn't give us a couple of scares each week.

As for Malceski vs Kirk, we see most of what Malceski does and are less aware of some of Kirk's activities because they are not as obvious to the spectator. The coaches will know all about them though. Excellent as Malceski has been, my guess is that the coaches will place higher value on the defensive achievements of Kirk, not to mention his three BOGs.
 
If happy-eagle wrote that then I'm stunned not only at the balanced assessment, but that it came from an Eagles fan. :eek:

Happy with most of it. Thanks for posting it. Good read. :thumbsu:

Personally I reckon Kirk has been one of the few players that has seemed to show passion even in our direst games, and I noticed that he's been getting some votes in the Coaches award while Malceski hasn't. So I'd have him leading our B&F. Only just. But have to say that Leo Barry has been great this year - and Roos has described his form as career best. And C.Bolton really hasn't put a foot wrong either.
 
Best goal so farWhen his side needs him to deliver, co-captain Leo Barry knows what’s required.
The Swans were peppering the goals in the final term in round three against Brisbane but with little success. Barry lifted all his teammates when he gathered on the wing, dodged two opponents, took a bounce and kicked truly from outside 50m.
His goal not only brought the home fans to their feet, but levelled the scores. The Swans would not be headed again as they bolted clear of the Lions to record a convincing win.

Yay!
 
I'd say Malceski would be leading the b+f at the moment, but I expect teams to tag him or take him away from the contests for the rest of the season, especially with Kennelly out. Hasn't had as much time and space the past few weeks and as a result been down on efficiency and had to handball off a few, when usually he'd be the one delivering it in. I think guys like Fosdike, J. Bolton, Schneider and Buchanan will have to really start using the ball when we're going into the forward line now. We've got the best forward line in the league when we're not giving away free-kicks, so lets use 'em.

If they're going to rate the Hawthorn win equal best, I'd say most important goal was O'Loughlin's at three quarter time against them. Very important moment in the match/season and gave the team (and me)breathing space and confidence into the final term. Great to see him kicking straight this year too. (20 goals, 5 behinds). Davis too (13 goals, 3 points). Luv Humph.
 
They must all be on substances over in the wild west;) Was he trying to troll that we are only a "B" ?

My report

R1 WCE always gunna be a big ask as Swans slow to start.... first half attrocious but PROUD of their resolve didn't deserve a win but enhanced fighting respect
R2 Tuggers... well even when they hit the front in last qtr any fan knew Swans were only just idling!
R3 Lions ... home against always pwn3d side
R4 Crows... Oh KICK STRAIGHT!.... bad kicking for goal is bad footy lost a 8 pointer !!
R5 Dees.. lucky had inj
R6 Roos... took them too lightly .. I was always a Shagger Grant fan but now a prick!
R7 Aints... SHOCKER !!!... but mates rates given to Rossy Lyon
R8 Port... ENDED their delusion
R9 Dogs... put back in kennel
R10 Dons... $20,000 Sheedy magic.... BOOOOOOO!!!
R11 Hawks ....Upstarts taught them about how the "grown ups" play


Any Regrets? : Should have beaten Roos & Dons and maybe Crows but that would have us TOP and being hunted and talked up & stroked like the pussies

MUST beat Wobbles they are GOOD TEAM but pretenders and then will catch Cats after the break.. they might think it is good for them but if our boys are on track they need to kick their ass after a relapse... then the run home

IF the next 2 are WON well ....even if Hall or Goodes don't come good but DAVIS ( IMO 22nd) or others MUST!!! .... then HERE WE GO AGAIN:thumbsu: if not Swans can still win from 5th or 6th!!!;)

The BIG GUNS will fire in Sept we just have to be there!
 
I want to write my own report too! It's fun! :)

I can't believe the 2007 season is already half-way. It's wayy too fast and quick. And we are now sitting 6-5, but we could've easily been 8-3 given we lost to the WCE and Essendon by 1 point. I'd hate to thinking the what ifs, but we could've been equal first on the ladder, but we can't dwell on these things, cos it'll just make you feel disappointed and frustrated.

Overall, Swans played okay. Despite our key players never really stepping up to the plate, sitting on 6-5 is a good effort. I couldn't be more happier actually. I don't think the Swans have found consistency and our next games are going to be really tough. Collingwood are so far pretty good and the Cats sitting pretty on top of the ladder is very intimidating.

Our slow starts have been very frustrating, or maybe it's because the opposition restricts us from playing the way we want to play? I don't know, either way, our ball handling and use has been atrocious overall. We aren't consistent and every single week, it's almost impossible to know whether the Swans will turn up and play.

The games against Crows, Kangaroos and the Saints was probably the worst games I've had ever seen. It was a total different Swans outfit and our kicking accuracy is woeful. Ball handling, decisions and delivery to our forwards haven't been up to scratch.

Our forward line hasn't been too influential, I must say. Barry Hall dropping a few easy marks, but that also goes with the HITB rule and all. Will Hall and Goodes not playing their best, it's a good feeling knowing we are currently sitting 7th after 11 rounds.

The most dissappointing players would be Hall and Goodes. Although, in saying that, Goodes is starting to find some form. Played pretty well over the past few rounds. Hall? Well, what can we say? He is frustrated and angry. I read the SMH yesterday, and Hall wrote something about him feeling down and doesn't like the fact that everyone is expecting him to play so well week in and week out. I feel sorry for him, and its obvious he was screaming for a week off. I just hope the bye week does him more good.

The most impressive players have been Nick Malceski. Without a doubt. He is a deadly accurate kicker and plays for the team. However, the game against the Hawks was a little scrappy, seeing as he, almost everytime, kick to a Swans, but some of his kicks were a bit wobbly. In saying that, Malceski and along with the other defenders (Craig, Leo and Tadhg) have been the stars for the Swans. Not surprised that our defenders are on top of the POTY.

I really like Teddy and Dempster. Although Teddy aka the Barometer hasn't been playing well, I still think he's got lots of potential. I'll never forget how he played in the 2006 GF, simply inspirational. And as for Dempster, he has improved. He has more confidence and I love the fact that he has the confidence to kick a goal or two when outside the 50 metre arc. Glad he is using his long kick ability to his advantage.

Honorable mentions to Schneider, Kirk, MOL and Benny. Schneider has been playing more of a defensive role but I think he is playing quite okay at the moment. Pretty consistent. And Kirk, well averaging 20 posession per game (I think) just reflects that you don't need to be a superstar to help out with your team. MOL, he has been tackling and running more this year. Its good to see he still has plenty left in the tank, and as for Benny, he has improved. A good tagger too, and tries to do everything right for the club.

No predictions from me.

Hmm.. okay, I should stop right here. This is not a report actually, its more like my opinion on how the boys are playing right now. And congratulations to the people who were actually bothered to read my amateur 'report'.
 
wel writen is2swanz.:thumbsu:
i think most would agree with what youve said, interseting about the SMH article, i cant help laugh about halls remark, maybe he shouldnt go to boxing, if thats how he feels, imagine all the people wanting him to perform there, and with the fact theres no team to help u with.. really please.,.
anyway it is frustrating that the consistancy is down its almost like my tipping each week.. though as long as we can get 1 of the next 2 were definately on our way.
imo if u can give a score then the article was spot on, to be where we are and be a long way off top form is a credit to our club.. heres to baz not feeling the hopes of all his supporters..
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom