Mike Sheehan doesn't rate BEN HUDSON

[NSWCROW]

Sour perhaps MIKE ?.........

 

[RoosterLad]

what

 

[Adam BK]

Sour perhaps MIKE ?.........

What did he say?

 

[NikkiNoo]

They talked very little about our game on the Couch except to pump up Waite and the Carlton forward line and Walls stating that Fev moved out to half forward and Rutten was out of his depth, but Adelaide may wake up to that eventually and send him back to the goal square. Considering that Rutten didn't move out on him and was on Waite for a period of the game, maybe watching a game instead of presuming Robert may help you?

They then showed some clips of some of Huddos supurb taps in relation to asking Walls about an Academic apparently stating last week that Ruckmen aren't needed anymore. Robert of course disagree but then Sheehan piped up over the videos that Carlton don't have a ruck division implying that Huddo didn't really have any decent opposition for the game.

 

[Big Sticks]

Sour perhaps MIKE ?.........

Mike Sheehan is clueless. He is only in a job because all the Age can manage is Carolyn Wilson. PPPFFFFTTTT. Hudson is getting better every game and does more at ground level than most ruckmen

 

[Punchy Bassett]

Please explain?

 

[Alex99]

I guess the question has to be asked; does Ben Hudson rate Mike Sheehan writing?


Mike Sheehan, you are a hack and nothing but a B grade gutter journalist

 

[Stiffy_18]

They talked very little about our game on the Couch except to pump up Waite and the Carlton forward line and Walls stating that Fev moved out to half forward and Rutten was out of his depth, but Adelaide may wake up to that eventually and send him back to the goal square. Considering that Rutten didn't move out on him and was on Waite for a period of the game, maybe watching a game instead of presuming Robert may help you?

They then showed some clips of some of Huddos supurb taps in relation to asking Walls about an Academic apparently stating last week that Ruckmen aren't needed anymore. Robert of course disagree but then Sheehan piped up over the videos that Carlton don't have a ruck division implying that Huddo didn't really have any decent opposition for the game.

Haha Mike is a tool. Did he not realise that going into that game, Carlton were #1 team in hitouts and clearences un the comp?!

Mike "What do you think" Sheehan is a laughing stock!

 

[jo172]

To be fair to Mike Huddo has been nowhere near as effective as before the knee injury. Look at the votes for BTM this year compared to 2005 for proof.

 

[NikkiNoo]

To be fair to Mike Huddo has been nowhere near as effective as before the knee injury. Look at the votes for BTM this year compared to 2005 for proof.

Don't think you can use that with any relevance Jo - as 2005 he was such a surprise to us all. He now has a standard that we expect due to that year and I think people are under rating him this year because of that.

 

[SA_Stazza]

They talked very little about our game on the Couch except to pump up Waite and the Carlton forward line and Walls stating that Fev moved out to half forward and Rutten was out of his depth, but Adelaide may wake up to that eventually and send him back to the goal square. Considering that Rutten didn't move out on him and was on Waite for a period of the game, maybe watching a game instead of presuming Robert may help you?

They then showed some clips of some of Huddos supurb taps in relation to asking Walls about an Academic apparently stating last week that Ruckmen aren't needed anymore. Robert of course disagree but then Sheehan piped up over the videos that Carlton don't have a ruck division implying that Huddo didn't really have any decent opposition for the game.

LMAO - pretty ridiculous statement given Carlton were ranked #1 in the AFL for Hitouts To Advantage prior to the match!!!!

I've always disliked Sheehan, even from the days of Talking Footy with Bruuuuuuuuuce!!

 

[jo172]

Don't think you can use that with any relevance Jo - as 2005 he was such a surprise to us all. He now has a standard that we expect due to that year and I think people are under rating him this year because of that.

Yeah maybe, he doesn't seem to be at the bottom of packs as often as he used to and also seems more reluctant to kick it. I think he might be playing through injury or worse, being afraid of re-injuring his knee.

Also he might be overlooked with all the hoopla about Griffin.

 

[ThePeckers]

Hudson was rated very highly up until he did his knee. He will have to regain that respect and reputation. When people put him down it will only work in his favour to prove them wrong

I think he is good, still not in his best form though.

Sheehan is like the Rucci of Melbourne, Biased and talks cr@p

 

[showdownhero]

That's crap Huddo has been a dead set super star this year. His constant willingness to put his body on the line has been outstanding really adds another dimension to our ability at the stoppages!!!!

 

[TooFar]

^^ I agree, I think he has been great this year so far. One of our most consistent performers.

 

[swanfan]

Obviously babbling, buffoon Sheehan wasn't watching the Carlton game when Hudson was so desperate to stop a Carlton goal, he almost split himself in half around the goal post.

I think the man should watch more games, analyze them with more accuracy and see a doctor about that verbal diarrhea that plagues him every winter.

 

[crow87]

Did he actually say anything directly bagging out Huddo or just insinuation/our imaginatoin or being a bit touchy (I havnt seen it)? As far as comparing Sheehan to Rucci I think thats a bit harsh, the guy often has some very thoughtful insights into the game and doesnt just dribble rubbish, actually writes some meaningful stuff sometimes. Sure he doesnt like the Crows that much and I dont agree with everything he says but on the whole I think he's pretty good. A question here: Who do you guys think is a good football journalist? I think I can scratch Rucci , Caro, Sheehan and Robert Walls from the list of possibles, Seriously though... who?
PS Hudson is a very good Ruckman and if he doesnt think so I disagree 100%

 

[Allefgib]

Did he actually say anything directly bagging out Huddo or just insinuation/our imaginatoin or being a bit touchy (I havnt seen it)? As far as comparing Sheehan to Rucci I think thats a bit harsh, the guy often has some very thoughtful insights into the game and doesnt just dribble rubbish, actually writes some meaningful stuff sometimes. Sure he doesnt like the Crows that much and I dont agree with everything he says but on the whole I think he's pretty good. A question here: Who do you guys think is a good football journalist? I think I can scratch Rucci , Caro, Sheehan and Robert Walls from the list of possibles, Seriously though... who?
PS Hudson is a very good Ruckman and if he doesnt think so I disagree 100%

Does Clinton Grybas write for any papers? (been living overseas for 3 years now and if looking up footy on internet come here first ) I always rated his NBL commentary though and his football commentary is top quality as well.

 

[jmorg1]

How would people rate Hudson this year compared to 2005?

Statistically this year, he's having a career season but in 2005 he really did burst on to the scene to impress with his work around the stoppages.

 

[- PC -]

Im sure Ben rates Mike as well

 

[-VC-]

I didn't see it (yes, that is a Robert Walls reference) but from what you guys have said it doesn't sound like he was putting Huddo down - he was putting down Carlton's ruck stocks. Unless there's something else he said that wasn't put in here then I don't know how you can come to the conclusion that he doesn't rate Huddo.

 

[Captain Sensible]

Mike has no idea. Hudson played for the bulldogs feeder club and theres not one bulldog supporter wondering how he played footy right under our nose for a year and we didnt draft him.

 

[Macca19]

So all he said was he doesn’t rate Carltons ruck division (which is probably the worst in the league) and that somehow ends up with Mike doesn’t rate Hudson?

Drawing a long bow there aren’t you?

 

[Walsh Bay]

Ben was recruited from Mike's old club. He's always hard on the Werribee blokes!

Go Huddo.

 

[bus24]

Why wasn't he picked up by the Doggies? Right under their noses too.

Did they believe he wasn't good enough?