Mike Sheehans Top 50.

[ablettjnr]

No Ling or Corey.

Scarlett and Milburn in bottom half.

I mean Tadhg Kennelly, great story, good player, but he's no Corey or Ling.

Thoughs?

 

[Kegs44]

Havent seen it yet but a mate filled me in, sounds like utter crap to me, he aint no expert, hes an idiot.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Rutten
Barry
Fletcher
Hudghton
Scarlett

= no credibility

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Oh and Craig Bolton too, wtf is going on there.

 

[Shell]

Who gives a fats rats clacker about Mike Sheehans "Top 50".. It's just one(little) mans opinion. I dont know why people get so worked up about it!!!

 

[thehoff]

Fletcher ahead of Scarlett.

Does this ugly little man even watch football?

 

[iameviljez]

No Ling or Corey.

No Ling, no Corey is ridiculous. Scarlett's a little lucky to be there but his performance against Adelaide warrants it.
From other teams, Mark Williams (Hawks), Ian Perrie (Crows) and Cameron Bruce (Dees) can feel unlucky but then again it IS only Mike Sheehan.

 

[Copernicus]

Don't really know why people give a rats' clacker about this bloke's top 50. It could just as easily be some bogan from Collingwood giving his top 50 and has just as much impact or importance.

 

[Turbocat]

Just a joke. He is suppose to work it after finals performance , so why wasnt Scarlo better off.Cleaned Halls clock. If you asked 16 coaches in the AFL, he would be in the best group of defenders , if not the best.How can taggers be judged better than him . Joke

 

[ciaobella]

Whilst I respect everyone's opinion in this thread, I don't know why you're bothering with a 'WTF' attitude as it's only Mike Sheehan! The guy is a complete idiot!

I stopped watching the Fox Footy show On The Couch as Sheehan was ********ing me of so much with his views on the game. Always saying something then immediately turning to Robert Walls for his statement to be approved.

Even though I've given up on Aussie Rules, I'll always maintain that Scarlo is by far the best full back and if not on level pegging with SOS. He yet again proved this by blanketing Hall in this year's Semi.

Don't waste too much of your time with discussing Sheehan's unfounded views. Just not worth it!

 

[Shell]

I stopped respecting the mans opinion a loooonggg time ago. I started going to the game in 93' and I believe (please correct me if im wrong) Gary Ablett NEVA once made number one on that stupid list. The best player to have played the game.. no no.1.. i rest my case at this list being a waste of space...

 

[Goldust]

IF it's consolation - Michelangelo Rucci's top 50 in The Advertiser had Lingy in at 15 or 16.

But seeing as though he's a bigger f***wit than Mikey, who gives a crap.

The whole exercise is futile.

Any one of 300 players could have a cas emade for them being included.

 

[JUBJUB]

IF it's consolation - Michelangelo Rucci's top 50 in The Advertiser had Lingy in at 15 or 16.

Is that based on this years performance ?
If so,he's a bigger knob than Noddy.

 

[Goldust]

Is that based on this years performance ?
If so,he's a bigger knob than Noddy.

Sorry. On looks!!!!!!!!!!!