Multiple coleman medallists on the same team

[Wallaby]

Around the early 80s Richmond had in the same year;

Seniors Leading Goalkicker: Michael Roach
reserves Leading Goal Kicker: Brian Taylor
U/19s leading Goal Kicker: Mark jacko Jackson.

all on big numbers

Not quite.

Seniors - Roach.
Reserves - Jackson
U/19s - I think some guy called Lane?

But still - all 3 were centurions in the same year.

However, there is another Richmond pair - Dick Harris (Leading Goal-kicker 1937) and Skinny Titus (1940) played together from 1941-1943 while both had previously been league-leading goalkickers.

I'm pretty sure Norm Smith was never leading Goal-kicker.

 

[Jonno_]

Gumbleton and Hurley

Pinning your clubs hopes on a duo that has played about 15 games all up?

 

[Adelaide Hawk]

Dunstall & Matthews, but Dunstall didn't win a Coleman until after Matthews retired.

Also Ablett & Matthews, Ablett not winning a Coleman until he went to Geelong.

 

[JD-Roo]

Carey and Longmire (1990 Coleman) are the closest recently I would say, along with Roughead and Franklin.

The Duck never won a Coleman

 

[Pykie]

The Duck never won a Coleman

I know that, hence the "closest".