murphy v ellis

[wookie]

what are ure thoughts guys im starting to think ellis may come off for us a little taller and faster...

 

[MarkT]

It's not a choice we are likely to have to make.

 

[magpies42]

trade the picks to get murphy, nota fan of ellis

 

[wookie]

yeah thats a thought ive been pondering what would we trade for no 1 (murphy)

 

[Eddie19]

yeah thats a thought ive been pondering what would we trade for no 1 (murphy)

You have appsalutely nothing to offer and no way would we do it

 

[deluxeman]

yeah thats a thought ive been pondering what would we trade for no 1 (murphy)

Can't trade priority picks...so youve got no hope of getting Murphy

 

[wookie]

didnt they last year or were they not priority

 

[deluxeman]

didnt they last year or were they not priority

What trade are you talking about?

 

[wookie]

sorry mate not last year,

 

[wookie]

sorry mate not last year, i made a mistake

 

[Murray]

Can't trade priority picks...so youve got no hope of getting Murphy

I think you can trade priority picks

 

[Sloth]

You have appsalutely nothing to offer and no way would we do it

We could offer a spelling coach...

 

[Stanton]

No way will trade our no 1. Murphy is the only player who is almost guarenteed to be very good player in the draft. Weve already got on no 2 pick whos a dud in andrew walker so good luck with that

 

[goalpie]

Nothink rong withe Ellic, whill bee a grate palyer.

 

[deluxeman]

No way will trade our no 1. Murphy is the only player who is almost guarenteed to be very good player in the draft. Weve already got on no 2 pick whos a dud in andrew walker so good luck with that

For ******** sakes, just because he hasn't had immediate impact like Judd he ain't a dud. He is only 19!

As for the Murphy vs Ellis debate, it is not 100% certain whether Ellis enters and if he doesn't pick 2 could be an interesting battle but would prob go to Hurn.

 

[Silvagnis]

No way will trade our no 1. Murphy is the only player who is almost guarenteed to be very good player in the draft. Weve already got on no 2 pick whos a dud in andrew walker so good luck with that

Luckily we didn't pick Stanton or Monfries instead of Walker and Russell, I know who I'd rather have.

 

[wookie]

guys dont think that carlton havnt talked to ellis aswell or ryder, 6 weeks ago they said that they would love to recruit a tall

 

[wookie]

the draft works in funny ways.....

 

[deluxeman]

guys dont think that carlton havnt talked to ellis aswell or ryder, 6 weeks ago they said that they would love to recruit a tall

And they will...thats what Pick 4 is there for

 

[wookie]

And they will...thats what Pick 4 is there for

so who do u think will go 3??

 

[Silvagnis]

Hopefully Ryder or Clark because my boy Kennedy is off limits.

 

[wookie]

im hoping clark stays till 5, a talented big man is hard to come across

 

[deluxeman]

so who do u think will go 3??

I think Hurn should be Pick 3 but Hawks might take Ryder as they tend to go for the KPP. But either way at Pick 4 Carlton either get a quality midfielder a good tall.

 

[wookie]

yep people are saying its a shallow draft but the top ten seem to have the goods, im hoping hurn goes 3, i wish we could trade for another top 10 pick

 

[TheHeatleyStand]

Murphy inside Cousins type with great skills on both sides... bit like a Ben Cousins

Ellis is a player with no real position.. outside and very left sided.
He reminds me abit of Robert Murphy... flanker wingman... very slight