Murphy V Gibbs

[bigpapagman]

Merc
Hawkins by a country mile
Bingle for sure, only downside it's fev's 2nds..
Gibbs easilly

chin fail.

 

[sausageroll]

The only Gibbs v [insert name] thread worth answering apart from the Selwood thread.

Gibbs wins them all pretty comfortably although the Selwood/Gibbs comparison is the closest imo.

He's already playing like a star. Next step = Superstar

 

[Antoine]

A bottom of the market bmw (a la 3 series, preferably the M, or even the new 135i) or a top of the market Mercedes (S, CL, SL)
Both girls, at the same time
Gilchrist

Murphy and Gibbs have different roles. I would trust Murphy with (most of) my life giving an inside 50 kick to Fevola. Gibbs I would trust in most other places.

Thank goodness we have them both. Last year the pick for this is Murphy, however looking back on what's happened this year, the pick is Gibbs, by a country mile.

Gibbs.