NAB Challenge Discussion

[TheOz]

Geez how on earth are Adelaide going to cover the loss of Kerridge?

 

[Jcpdragonx]

just got rid of Liberatore
went Pendles - Shiel
Libba - Rockliff

Have to be careful making knee jerk reactions. We've done plenty of research, don't lose faith because of one game. Having said that I've done the same haha, Pendles>Ward and downgraded libba to upgrade d4 from a rookie. I think libba will be fine but he will be an m8 keeper if we are lucky, he just looked off today. On Pendles, his role is very concerning. Gona have to do some more research, he did a Q and A on Facebook and I'm gona go through that. He won't average 120 from defence. I'm sure he will go through the mids plenty but with Treloar and Degoey looking really good, they can afford to use him elsewhere.

 

[Didstar]

Maybe more an X vs Y thread thing, but: Mitch Duncan or Cripps?

Cripps. Was fantastic yesterday. Far far more upside imo

 

[MacStradbroke]

I can't bloody wait to see Selwood and Danger starting in the square together. Joel hasn't had the luxury of a Zac Smith type and size ruckman for an extended period before. Felt like Ottens played more finals than home&away games.

 

[Chism]

Libba out for me to and Cripps in.

Did a few rookie moves/swaps to make the extra 30k i needed as i had cash already left over.

Libba is watch and see now coming off that knee injury and i am not starting with him, knees are pricks of things not to mention time out of the game.

 

[MacStradbroke]

Geez how on earth are Adelaide going to cover the loss of Kerridge?

They'd expect Danger to star but I'm thinking they may be a little pissed if Kerridge continues as he's started for the blue baggers.

 

[catstragic]

A bit premature but given that Scott is already using Guthrie as a tagger it may write off Scooter as a supercoach option if and when he makes the team.

 

[TheOz]

They'd expect Danger to star but I'm thinking they may be a little pissed if Kerridge continues as he's started for the blue baggers.

They should be, they gave him and pick #28 for Menzel.

 

[Sir Skid]

Macca IN

 

[TheOz]

McCarthy cemented himself into Geelong's round 1 side and thousands of SC forward lines.

 

[TheOz]

Bartel gone for the game.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Bartel's done for the day.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Lincoln boots boots in the fwd pocket spot.
Soft 50 imho.

Jimmy off for the rest of the game concussion.

 

[SterlingArcher]

I guess the only thing I'd say with Libba is that it isn't his performance necessarily making people react, it is equally how promising Matt Crouch looks as a SC pick. I struggle to see how I can have both when I consider Ablett, Rockliff and Pendlebury locked into my team, and think I need at least one of Fyfe/Danger. Mills is also a lock for most. So that's a pretty expensive midfield if you take Fyfe, Pendlebury, Ablett, Rockliff, Crouch, Libba, Mills, rookie...depends on how forward and defense rookies go come round 1 but I think a flip of the coin decision will have to be made between Crouch and Libba (Libba the prior history, Crouch the form).

Of course, if we get solid rookies (5-6) forward and back then both become a viable option. And just to clarify I still have Libba, I just also understand the decision to move him out.

 

[Double the Fist]

McCarthy cemented himself into Geelong's round 1 side and thousands of SC forward lines.

McCarthy certainly making the most of his opportunties.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Libba is currently owned by 55.44%

Wait for the lols with people panic trading after a nothing game

 

[Double the Fist]

Going back a game, did Pendles look ok? Does Nat fyfe look 'ok' in this game?

 

[MacStradbroke]

They should be, they gave him and pick #28 for Menzel.

Menzel sighted yet? Plenty of talent but always looked like he was limping. Not the most durable family.

 

[Souup]

2nd Blicavs comment in about 30 minutes, but I've been watching him closely. Hasn't played that well at all and has just reached the half ton in DT. Tackles like a man possessed

Has turned it over a bit in close though so I'm assuming his SC may be a bit down unfortunately

 

[Didstar]

Libba is currently owned by 55.44%

Wait for the lols with people panic trading after a nothing game

Not starting Libba may be less of a Pod now

 

[Jiska]

I guess the only thing I'd say with Libba is that it isn't his performance necessarily making people react, it is equally how promising Matt Crouch looks as a SC pick. I struggle to see how I can have both when I consider Ablett, Rockliff and Pendlebury locked into my team, and think I need at least one of Fyfe/Danger. Mills is also a lock for most. So that's a pretty expensive midfield if you take Fyfe, Pendlebury, Ablett, Rockliff, Crouch, Libba, Mills, rookie...depends on how forward and defense rookies go come round 1 but I think a flip of the coin decision will have to be made between Crouch and Libba (Libba the prior history, Crouch the form).

Of course, if we get solid rookies (5-6) forward and back then both become a viable option. And just to clarify I still have Libba, I just also understand the decision to move him out.

Would rather Brad over Matt

 

[TheOz]

Going back a game, did Pendles look ok? Does Nat fyfe look 'ok' in this game?

They both look like they don't give a shit coz it's preseason.

 

[Jiska]

Libba is currently owned by 55.44%

Wait for the lols with people panic trading after a nothing game

Never really excited me personally.

 

[MacStradbroke]

2nd Blicavs comment in about 30 minutes, but I've been watching him closely. Hasn't played that well at all and has just reached the half ton in DT. Tackles like a man possessed

Has turned it over a bit in close though so I'm assuming his SC may be a bit down unfortunately

Kept Fyfe relatively quiet.

 

[catstragic]

That's a lie, and we all know it

Im for real.
If anyone understands its a cats supporter. We lost Gazza for chrissakes!