No Pav in Sheahan's Top 50

[DamianBis]

Pav didn't have his best year this year. He is probably THE most underrated key position player in the game (over here in melbourne atleast). Such a great player. I would swap him for fev in a second(especially considering Fevs problems

 

[Stronzo]

Stronzo I thought that your AV photo with you in the GIMP outfit posing as a wrestler was far better than having to look at masten!

I agree. I lost a bet mate, this is the price I must now pay.

 

[samseenee]

Who really gives a toss who is in Sheaahan's top 50?
Does anyone think the players, clubs or significant others really give two hoots wot this has been thinks?

 

[Florimo]

He is an idiot, Pav is a champion - Any team would take him in a second

 

[Kickett Punches Read]

every year sheehan neglects great interstate players to find room for ordinary victorian players..... jones/rioli/maxwell ahead of pavlich..... gees louise..... but it literally means ZERO to us as a club and im sure even less to pav himself.... would be interesting to see what his thoughts on rioli would be if he was at freo.... not much i would think

 

[The Night Shift]

Sheahan has always been an arse clown of the highest vic centric order... It dosen't matter who, if they are an "interstate" based player he just dosen't seem to have much awareness...
It's not like his silly list actually means anything in the greater scheme of things. Opinions are like arseholes...

 

[Upgrayedd]

So what?

Yeah, Sure Pavlich Carries a Young and inexperianced team (i say this because if i say crap i get banned) and is Fremantles best Midfielder and Best forward Target at the same time, gets about 4 times as much focus on him from opposition players, stops fremantle from finishing last, and is that versitile he could slot down back and probably make the AA team,

Clint Jones is a really good tackler, and nearly got delisted last year! Isnt that enough to qualify you as a top 50 player in the game? its not like its a list of actually the top 50 players in the league and all, You got to calculuate Manlove from Sheahan, Media Hype, and pick 3-4 players and ajust the position to try to grab a headline so people will read it

 

[Angus McFuttock]

So what?

Yeah, Sure Pavlich Carries a Young and inexperianced team (i say this because if i say crap i get banned) and is Fremantles best Midfielder and Best forward Target at the same time, gets about 4 times as much focus on him from opposition players, stops fremantle from finishing last, and is that versitile he could slot down back and probably make the AA team,

Clint Jones is a really good tackler, and nearly got delisted last year! Isnt that enough to qualify you as a top 50 player in the game? its not like its a list of actually the top 50 players in the league and all, You got to calculuate Manlove from Sheahan, Media Hype, and pick 3-4 players and ajust the position to try to grab a headline so people will read it

Spot on. Sheahan judges some of the elite players too harshly because of their high standards. The market value of players like Pav and Buddy is high because of sustained performance and their abilities. Even after C Jones season how many clubs would even offer a second round pick for a one-sided tagger??? Boyd and Ling would be the only taggers I'd have in a Top 50.

 

[SS_Fury]

Pav didnt make the 50 because by 'pav standards' his year wasnt as god as previous years. Lets say Brett Peake did what Pav did this year, Peake would be named something like no. 30. Pav has set lofty standards for himself.
BTW, Harvey needs to plonk him foward and leave him there. Looking forward to seeing Palmer again.

 

[the walloper]

Mike Sheahan is an idiot. Pav is top 15 and Sandilands top 20. I'm sure he does this to create controversy. He goes out of his way to insult supporters of certain clubs. Selwood at 6 ahead of Pav? Ahead of Franklin?
He makes a mockery of this sort of list.

 

[estibador]

Mike defends his top 50

I like the way he uses Bartel's 30 goals as reasoning for having him so much higher than Watson but then says that Pav's 28 goals is 'nothing to write home about'.

 

[Ogrebait]

... by 'pav standards' his year wasnt as god as previous years.

Freudian typo?