OK only one move this week so...

[babydoll]

Should I do:

In - Mcphee Out - Carazzo

OR

In - Robert Murphy Out - Monfries

mindful that the dons only have a 4 day break so although Mcphee has been gunning this year dont know how well he'll score.

Advise much appreciated - thanks!

 

[big_slick]

to be honest i wouldn't bother with either trade, i think carazzo is good to have in the backline, maybe you could look someone else to trade for mcphee

and as for robert murphy maybe wait a few more weeks with him, but i had him at the start of the year and got rid of him, when aker is back from injury will find it difficult to maintain 100's in the forward line IMO

 

[eugene_tomas]

why the *** wld u wana get rid of mcphee???

and robert murphy is just coming good.. dont do anythink save ya 2 trades

 

[Turmoil]

eugene I think you need to read the trades again, you have them back to front, he wants to get McPhee or Murphy.

As for the trades, I agree with big slick on both accounts.

 

[moose25289]

Should I do:

In - Mcphee Out - Carazzo

OR

In - Robert Murphy Out - Monfries

mindful that the dons only have a 4 day break so although Mcphee has been gunning this year dont know how well he'll score.

Advise much appreciated - thanks!

big slick is totally right, but if you are seriously considering mcphee get him soon before his price sky rockets