leighroy
Team Captain
- Joined
- May 14, 2009
- Posts
- 399
- Reaction score
- 12
- Location
- pakenham
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- melbourne tigers
Following on from Bifrost, if this is about where we are now - then it's bottom three.
If its about where we can be going then it's much better. We have the youngest and lightest squad in the league, that means two things 1) we'll get beaten up by more experienced players of equal talent, and 2) we'll get bigger and more experienced. Our squad structure (talls, mids, kicking skills etc) is much better than it has been for a long time. I doubt anyone thinks we won't cull heavily again, I hope so. But the new guys will be coming into a team that is at least competitive and getting better. From here its all about building quality through drafting and development of players and the team side. This year most seem pretty happy with the development of individuals and how the team is shaping.
Trashing the squad as being among the worst is true right now, but for potential we are doing well. Yes, every team has good youngsters, but we have more and some are among our best players already. Teams like Adelaide, Sydney and even North face a problem of age. The Frawley years left us with a huge hole in a certain age bracket, that no other team faced. The Wallace/Miller years did little to fill that hole. It's now being filled by Lids etc coming through. No other team has this structure - which shows something about how poor the squad was built from around 10 years ago. The teams full of experienced bodies will drop, but they all have youngsters to fill that hole. For them it is how they blend the young and old - currently Adeleiade looks like having done it poorly, but I would never write Adelaide off. Brisbane has tried a mature list to win one now, and they look like having gone bust. We are an experiment in building a team from scratch, which no sane list manager would try to do. Even Gold Coast looks like having more mature bodies in their first year than we have had recently. The good bit is that we will have a group coming through together. If we can get some Sydney type attitude and some Geelong type skills then we might be a contender. But we won't know for at least two years how it is really going. When we have a mature squad then we'll know. Currently this debate is about conjectures about opinions about things that are yet to happen.
well said








