Our top 10

[marcmurphy3]

Now that 08 is one and dusted who and in what order do you rate our top 10. For mine:

1. C.Judd
2. B.Fevola
3. B.Gibbs
4. M.Murphy
5. N.Stevens
6. J.Waite
7. H.Scotland
8. A.Walker
9. M.Jamison
10. R.Houlihan

 

[Jeremias]

What is this top 10 based on?

Potential, where they are at right now, or importance to the side?

 

[R1KSTA]

if this is based on 08, its completely wrong!
kruzzz should be in there
aswell as grigg
even eddie aswell!!

 

[marcmurphy3]

Is based on ability right now for those wondering.

Grigg and Kreuzer aren't quite there yet.

 

[stakes12]

judd
fevola
waite
gibbs
stevens
scotland
murphy
carazzo
walker
simpson

 

[Big Red is back]

For me Fev was number 1 this year

 

[Faz 2000]

For me Fev was number 1 this year

Then Judd was 0. Nobody beats Judd. It's like a natural law of the universe or something.

I'll take a stab...

1. C.Judd
2. B.Fevola
3. M.Murphy
4. N.Stevens
5. B.Gibbs*
6. J.Waite
7. H.Scotland
8. A.Carrazzo
9. K.Simpson
10. A.Walker

* RAPIDLY on the rise.

 

[HBF]

1. C.Judd
2. B.Fevola
3. J.Waite
4. B.Gibbs
5. M.Murphy
6. N.Stevens
7. K.Simpson
8. M.Jamison
9. H.Scotland
10. P.Bower

 

[thegreenmachine]

Sorry MM3 but I've based this on performances through 2008 and their level of importance for this year:
1. C.Judd
2. B.Fevola
3. N.Stevens
4. H.Scotland
5. M.Murphy
6. B.Gibbs
7. P.Bower*
8. S.Grigg
9. A.Carrazzo
10. M.Jamison
Now that you think about it, this is what the top 10 in the B&F count could very well look like, of course Bower may not be there as he's missed a fair few weeks, but when he's been in he really does fill 1 of the key defensive posts nicely, so that's why I've included him in there. By B&F night I'd say Kade Simpson would be in the top 10.
Chris Judd has still been our best player this year IMO, despite not being 100% fit for most, if not all of this year. By 2009, I'm predicting Gibbs will be the big improver as Faz has mentioned. And, for god's sake, if Walker finally has an injury-free year, he should be on that list for next year as well.

 

[Kramer1]

1. Richard Pratt
2. Chris Judd
3. Brendan Fevola
4. Rebecca Twigley
5. Marc Murphy
6. Nick Stevens
7. Bryce Gibbs
8. Brett Ratten
9. Jarrod Waite
10. Justin Cordy

 

[BLUES82]

1. Cain Ackland

 

[Jezza U Beauty]

1. Richard Pratt
2. Chris Judd
3. Brendan Fevola
4. Rebecca Twigley
5. Marc Murphy
6. Nick Stevens
7. Bryce Gibbs
8. Brett Ratten
9. Jarrad Waite
10. Justin Cordy

Nice - except I'd have Greg Swann at 6 instead of Stevo.

 

[thylacine60]

Nice - except I'd have Greg Swann at 6 instead of Stevo.

Yep, Stevo out, Bec in twice. You know it makes scents.

 

[Bluebear]

1. Richard Pratt
2. Chris Judd
3. Brendan Fevola
4. Rebecca Twigley
5. Marc Murphy
6. Nick Stevens
7. Bryce Gibbs
8. Brett Ratten
9. Jarrod Waite
10. Justin Cordy

Has to be top 5.

 

[Kramer1]

Yep, Stevo out, Bec in twice. You know it makes scents.

The problem with top ten lists is there so restrictive...you can only list ten people.

You could consider possible loopholes like listing Rebecca Twigley, Megan Gale and Alex Fevola together as some sort of threesome...you know, just to make sure the WAG's are well represented.

It would make the fourth rung on the top ten list a bit crowded, and they would probably get a bit hot and sweaty being so close to each other and all...but maybe they could wear light cotton tee-shirts and spray each other with a gentle misting hose to cool down.







Sorry, I just got so tired of looking at daft trade suggestions that my mind wandered a little.

 

[Gozz]

1. Chris
2. Brendan
3. Bryce
4. Marc
5. Jarrad
6. Andrew W.
7. Heath
8. Andrew C.
9. Michael
10. Nick

 

[thylacine60]

The problem with top ten lists is there so restrictive...you can only list ten people.

You could consider possible loopholes like listing Rebecca Twigley, Megan Gale and Alex Fevola together as some sort of threesome...you know, just to make sure the WAG's are well represented.

It would make the fourth rung on the top ten list a bit crowded, and they would probably get a bit hot and sweaty being so close to each other and all...but maybe they could wear light cotton tee-shirts and spray each other with a gentle misting hose to cool down.








Sorry, I just got so tired of looking at daft trade suggestions that my mind wandered a little.

Clearly you are a pervert of the highest order. Respect.