Remove this Banner Ad

MVP PAFC B&F 2025 - Congratz Butters (AFL) & Watkins (SANFL)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

What ****ing planet is this guy on? Bond with fans and members continues to grow? It’s in the gutter and the club’s connection with its supporters is at an all-time low.

 
Last edited:
Incredible the incoming (well actually current) coach does not get to give a speech at the B&F to outline the plans for the season ahead and sell some hope to the fans.
Give it a rest why would he? He was an assistant up until today. Gain nothing by making promises on Kens, Cornes and Davies farewell.
 
So I watched Houseboat Hinkley's chit chat.

Have we changed our name from "White Noise" to "The Bullshit"?

Just confirming.
I love it how they give us pet names, so cute.

Could not believe he said he was leaving the BnF in 30 minutes during his speech at the start?
Seriously?
Did he expect to charge them by the hour to attend?
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

So I watched Houseboat Hinkley's chit chat.

Have we changed our name from "White Noise" to "The Bullshit"?

Just confirming.
I love it how they give us pet names, so cute.

Could not believe he said he was leaving the BnF in 30 minutes during his speech at the start?
Seriously?
Did he expect to charge them by the hour to attend?
Hes a sook. Always has been.
 
So just to confirm, members were allowed to purchase tickets but it wasn't made known until very late due to an "error"?

And Josh Carr doesn't get to speak?

This club just constantly outdoes itself, most insular, unaccountable club in the league by a country mile.
Yeh the same error as last year. Ha ha. Why does this club continue to BS members. We know what you're up to.
 
Give it a rest why would he? He was an assistant up until today. Gain nothing by making promises on Kens, Cornes and Davies farewell.
Because there is literally no better time for the incumbent to outline his view of the future and sell hope to a fanbase that has lost all trust in those at the top.
 
Cant Speak Nathan Fillion GIF
Dittmar is another w***er who should never be allowed near our club ever again.
 
Top 3 Port Magpie players in the magarey that was tonight.
View attachment 2413993
Full magarey votes:

R2
Jackson 2

R3
Watkins 3
Moore 1

R5
Atkins 1

R6
Boak 3
Atkins 2 (3)

R7
Watkins 3 (6)
Lorenz 1

R9
Sweet 3
Liddy 2 (13)
Lorenz 1 (2)

R10
Williams 2

R12
Soldo 3
Lord 1

R14
Watkins 3 (9)
Whitlock 2

R15
Lorenz 2 (4)
Liddy 1 (14)

R16
Mackinlay 3
McLennan 1

R17
Finlayson 3
Watkins 1 (10)

R18
Watkins 3 (13)

R19
Watkins 2 (15)

Leaderboard:
15 - Watkins
14 - Liddy
4 - Lorenz
3 - Atkins, Boak, Sweet, Soldo, Mackinlay, Finlayson
2 - Jackson, D.Williams, Whitlock
1 - Moore, Lord, McLennan
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Has there ever been an event with so much repetitious lauding of "amazing" and "incredible" "humans"?
The third lot of quotations seems a bit unfair, I am very confident that they're all humans.
 
This is beyond baffling. 2-3 good games and 4th. Seriously concerning.
He's an average player who had a few really good games. Granted he plays a difficult role particularly given his lack of height & physical strength. Sounds all to familiar. Him finishing 4th shows what a shit year we had.
 
You look at the results, and really Farrell and Drew dont make the TOP 10. If regular whipping boys DBJ and Lachie Jones are 7th and 8th maybe it's time some heat were put on these two. I thought it might have been games played but other than Jones they all played much the same.
I've been criticising Farrell most of the year. He has received way too many undeserved credits. So indecisive, uncompetitive at ground level & in the air, rarely tackles & his much lauded kicking has been very inconsistent. Drew was pedestrian this year & we need to find a defensive midfielder to replace him. Try him in the backlines.
 
Because there is literally no better time for the incumbent to outline his view of the future and sell hope to a fanbase that has lost all trust in those at the top.
Rubbish. His time is from now on. There was nobody there anyway apart from players and officials and probably only a dribble of members watching on the internet. I mean stacks of people here said they weren't watching. As I said get a grip.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Rubbish. His time is from now on. There was nobody there anyway apart from players and officials and probably only a dribble of members watching on the internet. I mean stacks of people here said they weren't watching. As I said get a grip.
So you've told me so far to "give it a rest" and "get a grip". I think you are the one that seems to be slightly unhinged about this topic. I just think the B&F is the perfect opportunity for the new coach to give an uninterrupted 5 minute speech about where he sees deficiencies, improvement, and as I said sell hope to a fanbase that is crying out for change.

Whether it was Carr or the club's call for him not to speak (my guess the club) it's just another in a long list of poor decisions that show just how unserious we've become.
 
So you've told me so far to "give it a rest" and "get a grip". I think you are the one that seems to be slightly unhinged about this topic. I just think the B&F is the perfect opportunity for the new coach to give an uninterrupted 5 minute speech about where he sees deficiencies, improvement, and as I said sell hope to a fanbase that is crying out for change.

Whether it was Carr or the club's call for him not to speak (my guess the club) it's just another in a long list of poor decisions that show just how unserious we've become.
Give it a rest and get a grip.
 
So you've told me so far to "give it a rest" and "get a grip". I think you are the one that seems to be slightly unhinged about this topic. I just think the B&F is the perfect opportunity for the new coach to give an uninterrupted 5 minute speech about where he sees deficiencies, improvement, and as I said sell hope to a fanbase that is crying out for change.

Whether it was Carr or the club's call for him not to speak (my guess the club) it's just another in a long list of poor decisions that show just how unserious we've become.
I told you other things too you decided to skip over in your reply.
 
So you've told me so far to "give it a rest" and "get a grip". I think you are the one that seems to be slightly unhinged about this topic. I just think the B&F is the perfect opportunity for the new coach to give an uninterrupted 5 minute speech about where he sees deficiencies, improvement, and as I said sell hope to a fanbase that is crying out for change.

Whether it was Carr or the club's call for him not to speak (my guess the club) it's just another in a long list of poor decisions that show just how unserious we've become.
Just seems to me you're making a big deal of nothing. Let Carrs actions from now do the talking not some token speech at Hinkley love in. There's probably nothing he could say at this point to a jaded supporter base that already know what the problems were. He's not going to stand up there and divulge his game plan on a white board at the B@F.
 
So you've told me so far to "give it a rest" and "get a grip". I think you are the one that seems to be slightly unhinged about this topic. I just think the B&F is the perfect opportunity for the new coach to give an uninterrupted 5 minute speech about where he sees deficiencies, improvement, and as I said sell hope to a fanbase that is crying out for change.

Whether it was Carr or the club's call for him not to speak (my guess the club) it's just another in a long list of poor decisions that show just how unserious we've become.
I'm with you, Frank.

It was a great opportunity to gave Carr a timeslot later in the evening to say what he wanted to. He's the head coach and with Hinkley leaving, we would've seen what he is about, what he wants to do. It didn't even have to be specific. Just a basic, here's the new head coach.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

MVP PAFC B&F 2025 - Congratz Butters (AFL) & Watkins (SANFL)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top