Pavlich vs Judd

[Bentleigh]

Which would you rather on your list?

Pavlich for me.

One of the very best center half forward and leathal at pinch hitting in the guts.

 

[SBI]

Last year I would have said Judd by a street.

But with Pav up forward, Pavlich for me.

 

[Pav for AA]

how do you compare a midfielder and a chf. not worth casting

 

[Kapow!!!]

I thought Pav for AA started this thread when I saw the link to be honest

 

[Bentleigh]

how do you compare a midfielder and a chf. not worth casting

Which would you prefer on your list.

 

[Pav for AA]

Which would you prefer on your list.

Judd coz we already already have pav

 

[Bentleigh]

Judd coz we already already have pav

Which of the two would you prefer on your list

 

[The_Eagles]

Judd'll be better by 26, equally as good right now

 

[rgauci]

Judd'll be better by 26, equally as good right now

Huh? It's not like Pavlich is old. Pavlich is 23 years old and Judd 21. Its pretty well known that KPPs take longer to develop than midfielders. So given that difference they are pretty much par in terms of age.

It's impossible to tell which player has more development left in them. It basically comes down to the question is a quality midfielder better than a quality Key position player or visa versa. A stupid argument that is definately subjective.

A positive for Pavlich is he can play anywhere on the field. Judd doesn't have that versatility. Thats the only real difference without disputing midfielder vs. KP player.

This year you'd take Pavlich, last year Judd. Its a matter of form and a clubs weakness. I'm pretty sure the Bulldogs would choose Pavlich where Brisbane would choose Judd.

 

[The Magenius]

Huh? It's not like Pavlich is old. Pavlich is 23 years old and Judd 21. Its pretty well known that KPPs take longer to develop than midfielders. So given that difference they are pretty much par in terms of age.

It's impossible to tell which player has more development left in them. It basically comes down to the question is a quality midfielder better than a quality Key position player or visa versa. A stupid argument that is definately subjective.

A positive for Pavlich is he can play anywhere on the field. Judd doesn't have that versatility. Thats the only real difference without disputing midfielder vs. KP player.

This year you'd take Pavlich, last year Judd. Its a matter of form and a clubs weakness. I'm pretty sure the Bulldogs would choose Pavlich where Brisbane would choose Judd.

Both absolute stars, If you were picking a team to play fro your life, I would pick these players number 1 and 2, but one of them has magic powers that the other does not, you know, one is a footy genius, but the other is the magenius !!

 

[jod23]

Comparing a CHF with a midfielder is pretty tough? Pavlich is on fire at the moment but Judd will be talked about in 50 years. He will be a true great of the game. Cant say the same for Pavlich.

 

[Bentleigh]

Comparing a CHF with a midfielder is pretty tough?

Again -

Which would you rather on your list?

 

[jod23]

Again -

Which would you rather on your list?

Chris Judd. Simply a better player than Pavlich.

 

[Bentleigh]

Chris Judd. Simply a better player than Pavlich.

Simple wasn't it?

For mine, it'd be Pavlich. Can dominate anywhere in the spine then go into the midfeild for patches and change the game.

Im more than happy with our midfeilders aged 23 and under comming though but crave a gun CHF.

 

[jod23]

Simple wasn't it?

For mine, it'd be Pavlich. Can dominate anywhere in the spine then go into the midfeild for patches and change the game.

Im more than happy with our midfeilders aged 23 and under comming though but crave a gun CHF.

Im happy with our young talls and Judd add's so much to our midfield. Pav is good but he isnt "special" as Bruce would say.

 

[Reveler]

hmmm.. judd delivering the ball to pavlich. mouth watering stuff.

 

[SBI]

Im happy with our young talls and Judd add's so much to our midfield. Pav is good but he isnt "special" as Bruce would say.

Nine goals say different.

 

[pav_is_god]

Nine goals say different.

Nine straight goals.

 

[sabre_ac]

Bah
How can you compare a Midfielder and a CHF.
Hows this sound, would freo with Judd be as big as improvement as Eagles with Pavlich???
I think not.

 

[MickZu]

Hard to compare, but on "current" form I chose Pav. That said, if I could pick one for Brissy it would be Judd.........................

Hope that clears things up

 

[davey_magik]

Pavlich because when he retires he will be remembered at that time as Freo's best ever player.

 

[The_Eagles]

judd is and will be for a long time, the eagles best ever player ( a far more prestigious honour)

 

[The Magenius]

Award for knee-jerk reaction poll of the year to influence people goes to .........this one. If we asked the same the day after judd won the brownlow I wonder how it would have gone ???

 

[94_Eagles]

Im happy with our young talls and Judd add's so much to our midfield. Pav is good but he isnt "special" as Bruce would say.

Credit where credit's due.

Pavlich can take a park mark as good as anyone. Can play midfield. Kick the miraculous goal from the boundary.

Judd is special. Pavlich is special too without any shadow of a doubt.

 

[Kenny_01]

Both are great players. Pav is in better form but Judd has a brownlow... can't split them.