Remove this Banner Ad

Rules Phantom Drafts - Board Rules

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Oct 30, 2007
12,262
15,556
Adelaide
AFL Club
Fremantle
Other Teams
West End Redbacks, Cleveland Browns
Welcome to the Drafts and Trading board.

Please ensure you adhere to the following guidelines as well as the Big Footy rules.


General Posting

- Don't quote large posts.

There are many large posts on this board, quoting these in full only makes threads bigger and messier. In the end, it just results in people not being able to find what they want. So, if you want to reply to a specific section of a large post, simply edit out what isn’t relevant. Similarly, try to avoid quoting large posts and editing your answers into the quote. Again, it just makes things messier than they need to be.

This goes double for phantom drafts. Don’t quote the entire draft.


- Search first.

Chances are there is already a thread for what you want to discuss. Just because it isn’t on the first page, doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist. So use the search function.


- Don't insult posters, don't insult teams.

This isn’t Bay 13 or your team’s own board. Opposition posters can comment on your players, but just because they don’t share the same high view of them as you doesn’t mean you can abuse them. By all means defend your team and attempt to persuade them otherwise, but don’t attack the poster, their club or representatives of the club, e.g. using Bay 13 nicknames like Norf, Carltank, Bears, Essendrugs, plastics, Tuggers, etc, or posts that boil down to "haha your team's crap".

A number of threads have been derailed by this type of talk. Trolling will result in cards and board bans.


- Show some patience and respect.

Not everyone who visits this board is a draft or trading expert. Simply show some patience. If someone proposes an unlikely trade, perhaps try helping them rather than abusing them?

We’re also lucky enough to have a number of posters who spend considerable time watching and evaluating draft prospects. While nobody’s word is gospel, we want to keep these posters around as they add a lot of valuable information.


- Off topic comments about other teams.

Trolling teams based on prior trades, drafting or list management will not be tolerated. Any posts along the lines of “you can’t talk, your team traded pick X for player Y”, or “at least we didn’t give player Y a new contract” or “can’t believe you drafted player X over player Y” will be deleted and repeat offenders could find themselves with a card or board ban.

The same goes for trying to drag comments from a team's board on the D&T board. They are separate boards - if you want to reply or criticize something on a team's board post there, not on here.


- Draft and trading games.

All draft and trading games (with the exception of the yearly BigFooty Phantom Draft) are to be conducted on the Footy Games board found here.


Phantom Drafts

- All phantom drafts must be posted in the Phantom Draft sub-board.

- All phantom drafts must have the correct draft order, as of the time of posting.

- All phantom drafts must be a full first round at a minimum.

Don’t do any of those, and the thread will be deleted. If you can’t get the little things right, then the phantom draft can’t be of much value.

Also, we would like to keep phantom draft threads on topic and preferably about the specific phantom draft itself rather than the draft and players in general. If you have questions about players, then why not head over to the Draft Watch sub-board and create that player their own thread? A number of posters read these threads, so there will always be someone around to provide an answer.


Trade Week

- Confirmed trades.

Don’t post anything as being a confirmed trade, unless it has been officially announced. Rumours posted as fact will result in red cards being handed out.


Reproduction of articles

I think most people know the deal by now. Nobody is permitted to post entire articles, regardless of where they have come from. Pick out the important part, up to a paragraph in length, and post that along with links to the original article.

This is a directive from Fairfax, and nobody wants to get BigFooty in trouble, right?


Finally, did I mention to have fun?
 
As we get closer to the end of the season, there will no doubt be an influx of new phantom drafts. So just a couple of things to remember...

- any draft must be a full first round at the very least, including compensation picks
- it must be the correct order as of posting
- player descriptions or reasoning for the selection are not mandatory, but are much appreciated

Don't do either of the first two things and it will be deleted on sight.

Also, if you update your draft and do so in a new thread as opposed to simply editing your previous thread, then those previous threads will be deleted - unless you can think of a good reason for it to survive. No need to have half the page being drafts from the same person.

And finally, be kind to new posters. Not everyone has the same level of knowledge at this stage, but everyone has to start somewhere. While it might not look like anything now, any one of these new phantom drafters could be the next 'expert'.

If you have any suggestions, then feel free to post them for us here.
 
- Don't insult posters, don't insult teams.

This isn’t Bay 13 or your team’s own board. Opposition posters can comment on your players, but just because they don’t share the same high view of them as you doesn’t mean you can abuse them. By all means defend your team and attempt to persuade them otherwise, but don’t attack the poster, their club or representatives of the club, e.g. using Bay 13 nicknames like Norf, Carltank, Bears, Essendrugs, plastics, Tuggers, etc, or posts that boil down to "haha your team's crap".

A number of threads have been derailed by this type of talk. Trolling will result in cards and board bans.


- Show some patience and respect.

Not everyone who visits this board is a draft or trading expert. Simply show some patience. If someone proposes an unlikely trade, perhaps try helping them rather than abusing them?

We’re also lucky enough to have a number of posters who spend considerable time watching and evaluating draft prospects. While nobody’s word is gospel, we want to keep these posters around as they add a lot of valuable information.
Quoting for emphasis.

Posters, please keep these in mind when posting in the Phantom Drafts board, they apply here as well, not just on the main Drafts, Trading and Free Agency board.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top