Pick 5

[bren_gc]

Well now that it seems power and bartel are re-signed, it seems that we will definately be using pick 5 in the draft. What do you all think we should do with it. Everyone was split between trading it or using it and now we will use it, so who to pick up?

My view is we get ellis with 2 and get the best available KPP with 5. There is a slight chance of us picking up another 1st round pick from dogs or dons so we could use that for a mid. But my opinion is if we use 5 for the next best available mid, then by the time 21 comes around there will be no decent KPP around and we will get ANOTHER mid... too many mids i think.

Thoughts....?

PS. i know there has been threads on this before, but now with the re-signings its a chance to put it all in one thread.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Well now that it seems power and bartel are re-signed, it seems that we will definately be using pick 5 in the draft. What do you all think we should do with it. Everyone was split between trading it or using it and now we will use it, so who to pick up?

My view is we get ellis with 2 and get the best available KPP with 5. There is a slight chance of us picking up another 1st round pick from dogs or dons so we could use that for a mid. But my opinion is if we use 5 for the next best available mid, then by the time 21 comes around there will be no decent KPP around and we will get ANOTHER mid... too many mids i think.

Thoughts....?

PS. i know there has been threads on this before, but now with the re-signings its a chance to put it all in one thread.

My preferences in order:

#1: Josh Kennedy
#2: Nathan Jones
#3: Shannon Hurn

 

[Hard Yakka]

The best midfielder available.

KPP with pick 21. Hopefully Austin Lucy is still available at 21.

 

[Murray]

My preferences in order:

#1: Josh Kennedy
#2: Nathan Jones
#3: Shannon Hurn

Nah, can't see that.
MM has stated we need quick mids, can't see him changing his view now.

For what it is worth my opinion is
Ellis at 2
Hurn/Thomas at 5 one of them will probably still be there
Jones at 21 (can't see him going sooner)

KPP at 23 if we trade Cole to Essendon.

But only Swann/Hine/MM really know

 

[bren_gc]

Nah, can't see that.
MM has stated we need quick mids, can't see him changing his view now.

For what it is worth my opinion is
Ellis at 2
Hurn/Thomas at 5 one of them will probably still be there
Jones at 21 (can't see him going sooner)

KPP at 23 if we trade Cole to Essendon.

But only Swann/Hine/MM really know

I think Jones may go before Thomas. Surely someone in the first round will be wanting to pick up a ready-built midfielder like him.

 

[jimmy35]

Nah, can't see that.
MM has stated we need quick mids, can't see him changing his view now.

For what it is worth my opinion is
Ellis at 2
Hurn/Thomas at 5 one of them will probably still be there
Jones at 21 (can't see him going sooner)

KPP at 23 if we trade Cole to Essendon.

But only Swann/Hine/MM really know

Is Jones that young bloke in the TAC GF that picked up 35 possies ?

 

[bren_gc]

Is Jones that young bloke in the TAC GF that picked up 35 possies ?

Thats him.

PS: there all young blokes

 

[jimmy35]

Thats him.

PS: they're all young blokes

Cheers.

True , especially to me.

edit:small edit required