Player X or Player Y (Part 3)

[foley4brownlow]

dangerfield or ballantyne or even mayne?

 

[foley4brownlow]

Matt Maguire or Alex Silvagni?

Harbrow or Waite?

Banner or Trengove?

maguire- just think he will do well at the lions and could average 50-60

waite- if he stays injury free should average 80+ and be a good keeper

trengove- should play 20 odd games and average 70+, although if your on a tight budget banner could be good value at around 55k cheaper and should average 60+

 

[demondude]

mitch clark or sandilands?
(ziebell + 30k) or (tippett) or (josh.kennedy) or (hall + 30K)
gibbs or bartel? (already have selwood)
k.cornes or anyone around 420K options include sylvia/judd/lids/cross/l.anthony.
brent.harvey or anyone around 380k options include higgins/gian/c.knights/m.bate.

 

[DrTomSwift]

relton roberts vs mitch duncan vs carl peterson vs banfield

 

[CrozaN]

mitch clark or sandilands?
(ziebell + 30k) or (tippett) or (josh.kennedy) or (hall + 30K)
gibbs or bartel? (already have selwood)
k.cornes or anyone around 420K options include sylvia/judd/lids/cross/l.anthony.
brent.harvey or anyone around 380k options include higgins/gian/c.knights/m.bate.

want us to make you your team? .

 

[FrankenLynch]

I've picked Pendlebury as my 2nd expensive mid but I'm starting to reconsider. My logic is that with Jolly giving a better contest in the ruck, his scores (as well as Didak and Davis that I've also picked) should increase.

Is this crappy logic? Are there players around the same price that I should pick instead of Pendles, Didak or Davis?

Anyone?

 

[Jizza9]

Jetta or Bastinac or Shuey?

 

[Seriously]

Well I've ended up going with Stanton, but Boyd is in my supercoach, so in conclusion they are both good. Neither will let you down but if there were to be the tiniest advantage it may be with Stanton who is a proven ball magnet, as is Boyd, but Boyd may lose points to Cooney & Griff

Cheers

 

[tuckbauer]

Jetta or Bastinac?

Both reasonable picks, but I would probably go Bastinac as I think he'll be a bit more consistent. Both should be good cash cows however.

LeCras vs Gray?

 

[styley]

Both reasonable picks, but I would probably go Bastinac as I think he'll be a bit more consistent. Both should be good cash cows however.

LeCras vs Gray?

gray more of a natural DTer but 50/50 to play, so risky

cannot decide for my life 2 out of ziebell/danger/balla (ziebell means downgrading from clark to Hmac in the ruck)

 

[demondude]

brent harvey or giansiracusa?

 

[styley]

brent harvey or giansiracusa?

gia based on his massive PS

 

[Galacticos]

do ppl hav to giv the "right" answers here?

 

[swans4eva]

gray more of a natural DTer but 50/50 to play, so risky

cannot decide for my life 2 out of ziebell/danger/balla (ziebell means downgrading from clark to Hmac in the ruck)

Danger and Balla for me or even consider Mayne. Ziebell is priced considerably higher and I don't see the benefit in that as it is not worth the 5-10ppg you will lose from downgrading Clark to Macca.

Bastinac + Hitchcock
OR
Banner + Gumbleton?
(Yes I'm tight on cash)

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

Silvagni or Nason? Running out of time

 

[swans4eva]

Silvagni or Nason? Running out of time

I don't think someone has asked that before

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

dont have time to go through the thread, was kinda after a quick answer, but thanks anyway mate, pretty helpful.

 

[swans4eva]

Silvagni or Nason? Running out of time

dont have time to go through the thread, was kinda after a quick answer, but thanks anyway mate, pretty helpful.

Best advice I can give is to flip a coin... I'm going Silvagni because I need the extra cash, however it is luck in my opinion to who is the better option!

 

[desTROY]

Yeah i've gone with Silvagni. Only cause i have a couple of other tiger rookies.

 

[Little Jerry]

Danga vs Balla

and

Harry O vs Joel Macdoanld

 

[Affidavit]

Hey everyone just quickly what do you think is better?

Mastern and $92k or
Ball and $19,900?

 

[ForceOfNature]

So far, pretty happy with my choice to take Waite over Harbrow, now I just hope that he stays fit...

 

[Moogs]

rockliff named as emg..!!!
do i trade him out for gumbleton?

 

[stuart27]

Hargrave and Suckling

or

Gram and Hunt?

 

[Little Jerry]

Hargrave and Suckling

or

Gram and Hunt?

Hunt more likely too play more games.