Player X or Player Y (Part 3)

[galindez]

shuey or jetta?

 

[Biggy_Boy]

Which two of Banner, Bastinac and Shuey?

 

[anf06]

Which two of Banner, Bastinac and Shuey?

Both Bs.

Wright or Campbell?

 

[Houli2Gumbleton]

Both Bs.

Wright or Campbell?

Wright. A little cheaper and will play further up the ground more so than Campbell.

Which two out of Shuey, Banner and Bastinac?

 

[anf06]

Wright. A little cheaper and will play further up the ground more so than Campbell.

Which two out of Shuey, Banner and Bastinac?

My same answer applys in Banner and Bastianac. That being said I have actually chosen Sheuy and Bastianac, but only because i don't have the balls to take Banner, even though i know he will rip it.

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Banner and Shuey imo.

Dennis-Lane, Pod or Tarrant.

 

[Jay-Z]

Wright. A little cheaper and will play further up the ground more so than Campbell.

Which two out of Shuey, Banner and Bastinac?

???

Wright will play mostly off the HBF while Campbell has been a regular part of our midfield rotations this pre-season. Personally i think Campbell will average a bit more than Wright but Wright's a little cheaper so if you need the cash go Wright. Personally, i have both

Banner/Shuey for your q H2G

 

[anf06]

???

Wright will play mostly off the HBF while Campbell has been a regular part of our midfield rotations this pre-season. Personally i think Campbell will average a bit more than Wright but Wright's a little cheaper so if you need the cash go Wright. Personally, i have both

Banner/Shuey for your q H2G

I want to pick Campbell but am scared off by his 'injury'

Have you heard anything?

 

[Maestro15]

Banner/Shuey for your q H2G

Don't you think Bastinac will play many games?

 

[anf06]

Don't you think Bastinac will play many games?

Relax. He'll play plenty.

 

[Jay-Z]

I want to pick Campbell but am scared off by his 'injury'

Have you heard anything?

Haven't heard much but I think it's just a rumour/minor thing that won't keep him out Rd1. He is named in 22 and is still in my side.

 

[anf06]

Haven't heard much but I think it's just a rumour/minor thing that won't keep him out Rd1. He is named in 22 and is still in my side.

Argh. This is the one spot in my team that i have been tinkering with all day. Doing my head in.

 

[Jay-Z]

Don't you think Bastinac will play many games?

He may, he may not. There is a lot of competition for spots in the midfield so if he guns it then he will stay in the team but a couple of bad ones will see him dropped.

Also have Cunnington coming back from injury who could steal his spot as he has a more AFL ready body

 

[Damon_3388]

Ben Warren, Hayden Ballantyne or Sam Wright?

And (dictated by the first choice) Kurt Tippett or Lance Franklin?

 

[Jimmza Oner]

Who would u choose out of these two options
Pavlich, Drummond, Malceski
or
Brown, Hodge, Kennelly
Thankyoup

 

[Jay-Z]

Argh. This is the one spot in my team that i have been tinkering with all day. Doing my head in.

I know. Me too. What it came down to in the end for me was that there was still an injury risk in anyone I was looking at swapping him to. And his change of role this year means he will definately go up

 

[Jimmza Oner]

Ben Warren, Hayden Ballantyne or Sam Wright?

Hayden Ballantyne seems to be much more fitter than last season and his preseason form before he got injured was pretty good, nearly BOG against NM

 

[anf06]

Who would u choose out of these two options
Pavlich, Drummond, Malceski
or
Brown, Hodge, Kennelly
Thankyoup

Top one. Don't like Kennelly.

Although i don't like Mal either

 

[Jay-Z]

Who would u choose out of these two options
Pavlich, Drummond, Malceski
or
Brown, Hodge, Kennelly
Thankyoup

Brown/Hodge/Kennelly

only because you would be ASKING for 0's if you had Drummond and Malceski in the same side

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

Anyone with an idea on;

Dennis-Lane, Pod or Tarrant?

Im about to head out to the pub, and this is my last spot .

Currently have Dennis-Lane with $49,200 remaining.

 

[srv23]

Warren plus Duffield/Hargrave or Gram

OR

Medhurst plus H Shaw

 

[anf06]

I know. Me too. What it came down to in the end for me was that there was still an injury risk in anyone I was looking at swapping him to. And his change of role this year means he will definately go up

Well for me it's between Campbell, Ballantyne and Wright.

Ballantyne was shunned because of his injury.

Campbell, from what he said on SEN didn't seem to have an injury concern. And Wright doesn't really have concerns.

I might have to flip a coin between the 2.

Who would you lean towards?

 

[anf06]

Anyone with an idea on;

Dennis-Lane, Pod or Tarrant?

Im about to head out to the pub, and this is my last spot .

Currently have Dennis-Lane with $49,200 remaining.

None of the above. But out of those, Pod.

 

[foley4brownlow]

dangerfield, warren or mayne?

thinking mayne at this stage. i see him having a good year and averaging around the 70 mark but still not entirely sure who to go for. thoughts?

 

[The Smaller Warrior]

None of the above. But out of those, Pod.

Who would you recommend then?

Besides Moore I cant see much else that speaks out to me.