Player X or Player Y (Part II)

[Lajon]

Selwood and Podsaidly

OR

Gibbs and Hitchcock?


Heard if Mitch Brown recovers, Pods has to go back on rookie list.

Leaning towards second one

Yep I'd agree with that...2'nd option due to the rookie


Selwood or Dal Santo??

 

[MattyC]

I would go Nicky Dal personally, but Selwood is cheaper so if that extra money allows you to slightly upgrade another player then go with Selwood.

Mine is Gibbs vs Deledio vs Boyd vs Cross

Only players in that price range I'm interested in.
Gibbs is all class (but will probably cop the tag early w/o Judd).
Deledio can be a weapon if he continues his end of season form plus no one at the Tigs will steal points off him (but he will cop the tag).
Boyd and Cross are very consistent but never really bring in the huge scores.

Opinions?

 

[The Sultan]

Gibbs, though am somewhat biased, as mentioned Gibbs is all class and dont think getting tag will effect him toomuch, as SC scoring is not based purely on number of possesion rather the quality of Gibbs should be ok

mine...

Originally had my premium rucks a Clark and Jolly, with Pav in the fwd line but was able to free up some cash with Greenwood going down. So pondering the following:

1.Rucks: Sandilands and Clark/Jolly,
Fwd : Pav

2. Rucks: Clark and Jolly
Fwd: R.O.K

 

[staedtler]

first, clark is definately a better option than jolly, so this means its either sandi and pav or jolly and rok

i would probably go sandi + pav, coz sandi will average at least 15 more than jolly and pav will probably improve on his 100 ave, having said that i reckon okeefe is good enough to make up the deficit and jolly may suprise

 

[takeiteasy]

2 spots 3 maybe even 4 players.. Gia, Gray, B.Harvey, Franklin...

atm i've got Gia and Gray but just free'd up enough $ to get harvey for one of them plus i can't seem to let go of buddy lol.
i'd say Gia is my fav but can't decide on the other 3...

thoughts?

 

[jd2006]

Not so much an X vs Y but a thoughts on a ruck combo.

Hille and NicNat. Both under 400k and it frees up cash to load up everywhere else.

Too risky?

 

[Hands Open]

Having dilemmas with my 7th defender and forward...

ATM i have greendwood (DEF) and Rockliff (FWD), but am thinking greenwood is a bit expensive to be having as a 7th defender, and then Rockliff might not get enough games early

On my bench i have (DEF) Maguire, Webberely and FWD Gumby, Podsiadly

Should I drop greenwood to say Sheppherd/Waters and bump Rockliff up to someone that will play more??

 

[thomas_m18]

2 spots 3 maybe even 4 players.. Gia, Gray, B.Harvey, Franklin...

atm i've got Gia and Gray but just free'd up enough $ to get harvey for one of them plus i can't seem to let go of buddy lol.
i'd say Gia is my fav but can't decide on the other 3...

thoughts?

Franklin first.

He's a gun, and should improve average, but inconsistant.

Last 3 are all 33.3/33.3/33.3.

Boomer Harvey WAS a premium, but I don't know what effect he will have now. Young midfield, will get more experience and such. Harvey will be very important for the Kangas, but he'll get tagged outta some games as well. Plus, he's 32 now. Maybe steer clear, don't know how he'll fare this year.

Gray has upside, and Port will give him every opportunity to step up. Young, maybe a couple of injury niggles? (Probably just made that up)

Gia, if he's your favourite, go for him. Should have a little upside this year.

Gia/Gray comes down to who you like more, really.

 

[thomas_m18]

Having dilemmas with my 7th defender and forward...

ATM i have greendwood (DEF) and Rockliff (FWD), but am thinking greenwood is a bit expensive to be having as a 7th defender, and then Rockliff might not get enough games early

On my bench i have (DEF) Maguire, Webberely and FWD Gumby, Podsiadly

Should I drop greenwood to say Sheppherd/Waters and bump Rockliff up to someone that will play more??

Greenwood's Injured. That's all I need to say.

 

[BleasePlease]

massive dillemma..

who do i go with, ive changed about 100 times..

A) Goddard, Gram and Trengove

B) Drummond, Hunt and Kerr

option b makes my midfield look very imposing with ablett, mitchell, vince, cooney, kerr and martin..

however option a makes my backline look very tight nit with goddard, hurn, hodge, gilbee, gram, ladson and waters..

what are serious supercoach heavies thinking bout my option, should i go with option a or option b......

please help, its doin my head in...

 

[Ed D]

massive dillemma..

who do i go with, ive changed about 100 times..

A) Goddard, Gram and Trengove

B) Drummond, Hunt and Kerr

option b makes my midfield look very imposing with ablett, mitchell, vince, cooney, kerr and martin..

however option a makes my backline look very tight nit with goddard, hurn, hodge, gilbee, gram, ladson and waters..

what are serious supercoach heavies thinking bout my option, should i go with option a or option b......

please help, its doin my head in...

Goddard, Hunt, Trengove and upgrade someone else. Drummond is a gun but injury prone so I wouldn't pick him, and I wouldn't pick Gram or Kerr.

 

[Absolute Gun]

Trengove or Banner??

 

[remedi]

Trengove

I think he could win the rising star tbh.

 

[jinny1]

Jay Nash or Ricky Ladson?

 

[staedtler]

Trengove or Banner??

Ive got trengrove on field, banner on bench...

but wondering who i should get out of banner, bastinac and shuey? or is there anyone else at ~100k or less?

 

[Hands Open]

Urquhart and Waters v Malceski and Ladson/Nash/Raines etc (or any pair to fit under 525k)

Also is Paul Bower worth a look???

 

[Hot Tiges]

Trengove

I think he could win the rising star tbh.

Any other team then Melbourne, then yeah.. he definately would. Seems to be very professional and warming to the senior level nicely. Tom Scully? See him on the Footy Show with Jono Brown and Bazza?? very nervous! Mind you.. who wouldn't!!

 

[Blueforce]

midfield premium dilemma -

dal santo & ball
vs
mitchell & cooney

 

[Grimmjow]

midfield premium dilemma -

dal santo & ball
vs
mitchell & cooney

that is a dilemma...

i believe NDS > Mitchell , Ball = Cooney

so NDS & Ball

 

[marshie_blues]

higgins vs harvey vs buddy

and 2 of Jetta, banner, bastinac and shuey

 

[velour_fog]

Thoughts on Kerr? AT 410K worth picking up?

 

[jinny1]

Mitch Clark or Darren Jolly?

J.Trengove OR M.Lobbe Or D.Currie OR R.Stanley ?(pick 2 out of 4)

C.Enright OR J.Drummond?

 

[thomas_m18]

Mitch Clark or Darren Jolly?

J.Trengove OR M.Lobbe Or D.Currie OR R.Stanley ?(pick 2 out of 4)

C.Enright OR J.Drummond?

Hmmm.

I'm thinking Clark for the first one, but both are a little unknown this year. Dunno what either will pull out.

If you have Tippett, you want Lobbe.

I'd pick Stanley after Lobbe, then Currie, then Trengove.

And Enright over Drummond. I'd rather consistency.

 

[marshie_blues]

higgins vs harvey vs buddy

 

[Yoda_]

OK, straightforward:

Ben Warren or Taylor Walker?