Opinion Posts That Don't Deserve a Thread (Random Opinion or Questions)

[kneecapper]

Question

Do fans have the right to be critical of players?

Of course they do, within certain broad limits. Why are you asking?

 

[The King!]

Of course they do, within certain broad limits. Why are you asking?

You know me, im deep

Nah just interesting especially on facebook for instance, use a hypothetical wont pick on a player

But someone will say this stupid dumb idiot who has always been rubbish wearing number 22 for a hypothetical side buggers up a pass with a minute to go and a 5 point lead when he could of gone sideways

People bah him out

Others go ohh you are not there, you are not a player, dont bag them out

I think its not personal its just sports analysis , thats the price players pay, they doht have to go read the comments

But others would say ohh people dont come to your work and comment the same

 

[Kapanis]

You know me, im deep

Nah just interesting especially on facebook for instance, use a hypothetical wont pick on a player

But someone will say this stupid dumb idiot who has always been rubbish wearing number 22 for a hypothetical side buggers up a pass with a minute to go and a 5 point lead when he could of gone sideways

People bah him out

Others go ohh you are not there, you are not a player, dont bag them out

I think its not personal its just sports analysis , thats the price players pay, they doht have to go read the comments

But others would say ohh people dont come to your work and comment the same

FB is a mind f&$k, just don't go there and expect any normal debate. The " I love my Swannies" brigade will condemn you too hell.

 

[PVF]

Question

Do fans have the right to be critical of players?

Absolutely, sports is entertainment. We pay in some form to watch them perform so we have the right to be critical within the limit if we think it's warranted.

 

[PVF]

But others would say ohh people dont come to your work and comment the same

Well clearly they have never worked in customer service or the hospitality industry haha.

 

[TheTrademark]

Question

Do fans have the right to be critical of players?

Fans do... supporters don't.

 

[The King!]

FB is a mind f&$k, just don't go there and expect any normal debate. The " I love my Swannies" brigade will condemn you too hell.

Ever seen ryan j brown on facebook?

 

[Kapanis]

Ever seen ryan j brown on facebook?

I have not, what's his bug bare? I now read the article and bypass the comments section after the Goodes saga.

 

[Maddo11]

Was interested to see what everyones Best 22 is in a perfect world with no injuries? Find myself really stuck with the Key Back spots, purely because I don't know what combination is best. Richards and Grundy with massive runs on the board but I find myself worrying about 2-3 years down the track.

Rampe - Richards - Smith
McVeigh - Grundy - Johnson
Cunningham - Hanners - Rohan
K.Jack - Franklin - Parker
Reid - Tippett/Sinclair - Heeney

Fol. Tippett/Sinclair - Kennedy - Mitchell.

Bench from Reid, McGlynn, Mills, Papley.

Lloyd stiff but AJ > Lloyd.

Tried to get the best mix of Height and Pace.

 

[Tuco]

Question

Do fans have the right to be critical of players?

Yes. One caveat: Don't make it personal or be a dick about it, I guess?

Similarly, if a poster is critical those who disagree shouldn't take that opinion personally and be a dick about that either.

Probably too much to ask.

 

[SwannyAz]

Rampe - Richards - Smith
McVeigh - Grundy - Johnson
Cunningham - Hanners - Rohan
K.Jack - Franklin - Parker
Reid - Tippett/Sinclair - Heeney

Fol. Tippett/Sinclair - Kennedy - Mitchell.

Bench from Reid, McGlynn, Mills, Papley.

Lloyd stiff but AJ > Lloyd.

Tried to get the best mix of Height and Pace.

Pretty similar to mine. I think you've got Reid in there twice.

Johnson Richards Smith
McVeigh Talia Rampe
KJack Hannebery Mitchell
Cunningham Franklin McGlynn
Papley Sinclair Heeney
Tippett Kennedy Parker

Reid Lloyd Mills Rohan

Went for a mix of experience and youth at the key back spots. Not sure if we can win the flag this year but I think we can in next two if we fresh up those key back spots. Reid could move in and replace Richards as well.

 

[Tuco]

Jon Ralph and Daniel Harford are floating an opinion that the Tigers have offered Hurley a 5 year x $900k contract.

Just speculation, of course.

This now puts him at Richmond according to some at SEN

Melbourne according to Andy Maher at SEN

Oh and he had a coffee with with McVeigh according to BF.

So I take from all of that that he is a certain starter for the Bombers then?

 

[TheTrademark]

Rampe - Richards - Smith
McVeigh - Grundy - Johnson
Cunningham - Hanners - Rohan
K.Jack - Franklin - Parker
Reid - Tippett/Sinclair - Heeney

Fol. Tippett/Sinclair - Kennedy - Mitchell.

Bench from Reid, McGlynn, Mills, Papley.

Lloyd stiff but AJ > Lloyd.

Tried to get the best mix of Height and Pace.

I reckon Laidler is the stiff one
There was something in that last q from Hewitt where he ran through a lot of traffic then hand ball it and it looked sooo good. (On the Hewitt Bandwagon)

I reckon best 22 is
Johnson Grundy Smith
McVeigh Talia Rampe
KJack Hannebery Mitchell
Cunningham Franklin Hewitt
Papley Sinclair Heeney
Tippett Kennedy Parker

Reid Laidler Mills Rohan

I reckon best 22 this season is:
Laidler Grundy Smith
McVeigh Talia Rampe
KJack Hannebery Mitchell
Cunningham Franklin Hewitt
Papley Sinclair Heeney
Tippett Kennedy Parker

Reid Lloyd Mills Rohan

 

[The King!]

Best 22

B Smith, Talia, Grundy
Hb Laidler, Reid, Rampe
C Hannebery Mitchell Parker
Hf Jack, Franklin, Papley
F Hewett, Rohan Heeney
Foll Tippett Kennedy mcveigh
Int Mcglynn or cunningham cant decide Mills Lloyd Nankervis

 

[miggs]

Talia has some shoes to fill the way hes being pumped up on here

 

[J_Moore]

Yeah what's with this assumption that Talia will be better than mediocre, which is where he sits on exposed form?

 

[miggs]

Its like going to the pub and you see 5 girls with 4 of them being beasts and 1 of them average. All of a sudden that average girl looks like a solid 7/10 but take away the herd of 2/10s and she reverts back to a 5

 

[SwannyAz]

Talia is the only realistic younger option. Don't think anyone here is suggesting he's his brother, but has to be pushed forward because others are getting too old.

 

[bedford]

Of course we have a right to bag a player, same as a jockey who has a shit ride

 

[The King!]

Yeah what's with this assumption that Talia will be better than mediocre, which is where he sits on exposed form?

Only has to be better than XR or AA

 

[connolly]

Of course we have a right to bag a player, same as a jockey who has a shit ride

Many of whom if they were an inch taller would be unemployable

 

[miggs]

Of course we have a right to bag a player, same as a jockey who has a shit ride

Especially when the pygmy has just cost me my trifecta

 

[miggs]

Many of whom if they were an inch taller would be unemployable

Theres always chimney sweeps

 

[CD__]

Especially when the pygmy has just cost me my trifecta

One of my good mates had the best part of $2k riding on the Swans sat night as the last leg of his multi...fair to say he was livid with Towers haha. No idea why he didn't take my advice and lay off with a few hundred on the Tigers head to head.

 

[miggs]

One of my good mates had the best part of $2k riding on the Swans sat night as the last leg of his multi...fair to say he was livid with Towers haha. No idea why he didn't take my advice and lay off with a few hundred on the Tigers head to head.

Oh yeah, I stupidly should have done that last cricket world cup. Had a ridiculous 10 legger worth around 10k that 9/10 came in. Last leg was Windies to beat Ireland which was paying $1.01..... The rest is history