POTY Voting Thread v Collingwood

[is2SWaNz]

Votes in here.

I need to lie down. Head is buzzing, and can't think who to give it to. (except for Jolly).

 

[Bloods_33]

Votes in here.

I need to lie down. Head is buzzing, and can't think who to give it to. (except for Jolly).

honestly apart from jolly, kirk, craig bolton I can't think of any other players worthy, this is a shattering loss back to square one no improvement from last year

 

[MF]

____ me this is going to be tough but here goes......

5. Kirk (If I could give him all the votes I probably would)
4. Richards
3. Jolly
2. Mattner
1. C. Bird (Showed a lot of composure in possesion tonight and was one of our few good players in the first half)

 

[MF]

honestly apart from jolly, kirk, craig bolton I can't think of any other players worthy, this is a shattering loss back to square one no improvement from last year

What was good about Boltons game? I don't think he really did a lot defensively or in possession?

 

[CAS79]

Damn this is so hard as weeks like this were giving votes to performances we would have been uninspired by previously.

5: B.Kirk
4: C.Bolton
3: D.Jolly
2: M.Mattner (for his run not his defensive efforts)
1: M.O'Loughlan - for working so hard to bring us back into the game in the last.

To answer a question. Bolton was as good/bad as anyone in the first half but was given the brief on Thomas in the second and stop him. He did so.

 

[grimlock]

I can only give 4 players votes. Is that allowed?

5 - B.Kirk (Only midfielder to give his all. Shame to the rest of you.)
4 - C.Bolton (Started well on Didak, then shut down the piping hot Thomas. If only we had 2 B2s...)
3 - C.Bird (Hope he isn't dropped next week)
2 - D.Jolly (I think he did okay, against the 2nd string ruckmen. Normally wouldn't get votes)
1 - ???

 

[Mick Oxlong]

5. Kirk (still should be solo captain...it was leo tonight and we all know how that panned out!)
4. Jolly (worth every bit of that 4yr contract)
3. Jude Bolton (only player to put head over ball)
2. Kennelly (unfortunately possessions weren't effective)
1. Ablett (best of a bad bunch)

Apologies to LRT, Marty the monster and who gives a Jack!

 

[OperationGetCats]

5. Kirk (Machine)
4. Jolly (Worked hard took good grabs)
3. Mattner (Did the right things... very solid performer)
2. Richards (Tried hard, is composed these days when in prev yrs he would look hesitant)
1. Playfair (also worked hard... if only he could kick properly)

Found it very hard to give a 5th vote.

Everitt looked terrible out there. So slow, couldn't kick. He looks to skinny... wtf is with that.

 

[OperationGetCats]

Finding it hard to believe ppl are leaving Mattner out of the votes.

 

[Jaymeee]

voting really should be cancelled this week. Seriously besides Kirk, I cannot think of anyone that deserves praise.

5. Kirk - self explanatory
4. Mattner- don't really know why, he just seemed to have a lot of the ball
3. LRT - he clashed heads with lockyer so for his act of bravery he gets the points
2. Bird - lovely goal from the boundary
1. Ted Richards - got a poke in the eye from medhurst and battled on

 

[is2SWaNz]

5. Jolly
4. Kirk
3. Mattner
2. Bird
1. Richards?

I don't know. I've done these halfheartedly and I doubt I'll fix the votes up. I'm sick and tired of this shit.

 

[RUNVS]

5. Kirk
4. Jolly
3. Mattner
2. Richards
1. Playfair

I considered Jude Bolton as his tackling pressure was good but not alot else.

 

[No1SwansFan]

I thought tonight it may have been easy to give votes for worst on ground and remove them from the POTY voting tallies. Man that would be so easy. I honestly at this stage have no idea who to give votes to.
Mattner was good early but then went quiet Kennelly although having 21 possies was ordinary. Kirk was a stand out Playfair was good. Bevan finally kept Didak quietish in the last quarter and Ryano had a few good moment but nothing that really deserved votes right now. Maybe after a replay!!

 

[snappy]

5. Kirk
4. Jolly
3. Mattner
2. Richards
1. C.Bolton

C.Bird coming on nicely, pity he isnt lightning quick.

 

[grimlock]

Don't like criticising other people's votes but Teddy was towelled up tonight first by Cloke then by Anthony. He did cop a smack in the eye by Medhurst early and perhaps was disorientated by it.

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Don't like criticising other people's votes but Teddy was towelled up tonight first by Cloke then by Anthony. He did cop a smack in the eye by Medhurst early and perhaps was disorientated by it.

From a TV point of view, Teddy did well when kicking to the left of screen

 

[OperationGetCats]

Don't like criticising other people's votes but Teddy was towelled up tonight first by Cloke then by Anthony. He did cop a smack in the eye by Medhurst early and perhaps was disorientated by it.

Cmon grimlock you left out Mattner he was good everytime he got it and our most efficient player.

Richards battled hard... Most of Cloke's shots at goals were on LRT... Richards not in top 3 but worthy of a vote

 

[grimlock]

Just from watching it on the ground, I wasn't too impressed by Mattner. He was far too lose on Thomas early on and that got him into my bad books. Looked better up forward. And for Cloke, the reason why LRT was on him was that Teddy had already lost the battle to Travis.

 

[SOPH_CROSS]

NOT VOTING so mad right now but will vote when i watch the replay

BUT i am giving

5 POINTS 2 JARRED MOORE...FOR BEING SO SWEET AND GIVING ME THE BEST HUG EVER AND I GOT 2 KISS HIM *SQUEALS!*

 

[ssfc0203]

5 Kirk
4 Mattner
3 Jolly
2 Bird
1 Bolts (shut down daisy completely.)

 

[SouthSwans]

I refuse to vote this week.

-22. Sydney Swans

 

[Jeffers]

No votes from me either. Only Kirk deserves all my votes and i won't give the other players the decency of getting my minor votes.

 

[natlovestheswans]

5. Kieren - He is amazing and smells so good.
4. Moore - For being so amazing with Soph.
3. Richards - Aw, he is so adorable.
2. Mattner - Few helicopter moments and had fun just watching him for like 5 mins.
1. Beanie - At least he wasn't out there.

 

[SOPH_CROSS]

5. Kieren - He is amazing and smells so good.
4. Moore - For being so amazing with Soph.
3. Richards - Aw, he is so adorable.
2. Mattner - Few helicopter moments and had fun just watching him for like 5 mins.
1. Beanie - At least he wasn't out there.

LOL Yup i agree 100% with Nat

 

[Corpuscles]

1. Beanie - At least he wasn't out there.

Haha

Times like these , thank goodness I left the voting to you others

Apart from Kirk, I reckon it would be easier to pick the top 20 worst!