Reciprocate the love....

[Riders of Rohan]

It's time for the love Sydney gave you in 1996 to be reciprocated next year. In nearly identical circumstances, the love needs to be returned. Please return the love.

Love.

 

[Zahki]

You think it's a good idea to ask for Reid after you put the curse of Jolly on us!?

I kid.

 

[Riders of Rohan]

Good old Jolly. The curse that wins you a premiership one year, then loses it the next. (Though he did his best to lose the first one as well)

 

[entourage]

Very harsh to say Jolly lost us a flag, thought he played quite well in the GF this year, certainly not the reason we lost. Anywho, no idea what this 1996 business is i would've only been 7..

 

[Zahki]

We got Anthony Rocca from Sydney in 1996 cause he wanted to play with his brother.

 

[Riders of Rohan]

Sorry, him losing the second GF mostly applies to Sydney.

 

[Riders of Rohan]

We got Anthony Rocca from Sydney in 1996 cause he wanted to play with his brother.

In return we got two fringe players and your first two picks. One of those fringe players went back to you after 2 years

I merely suggest the same deal

 

[Zahki]

Straight swap for Jesse White or gtfo

 

[entourage]

Lol gotchya then, i knew that happened at some stage but didn't know the year...fair call on Jolly in sydney..also, seeing as it was the younger brother to follow the older brother, i think sammy should come to us!

 

[Riders of Rohan]

You'd have to add your first rounder. White's got far too much potential to be let go that easily.

 

[Riders of Rohan]

Lol gotchya then, i knew that happened at some stage but didn't know the year...fair call on Jolly in sydney..also, seeing as it was the younger brother to follow the older brother, i think sammy should come to us!

Yeah but... but ... that wouldn't be fair.

Sydney coming off losing the 1996 GF, you guys this year. Incredibly eerie how identical these circumstance are, except reversed.

 

[entourage]

No way would i trade reid for white, even without a draft pick

 

[entourage]

Yeah but... but ... that wouldn't be fair.

Sydney coming off losing the 1996 GF, you guys this year. Incredibly eerie how identical these circumstance are, except reversed.

Lol didn't know about the losing GF either!

 

[Zahki]

No way would i trade reid for white, even without a draft pick

Spangher? Pushing it maybe, but Reid is pretty good and we'd need a good return.

 

[Number 10]

Good thread, would read again.

I would throw up all over my mums face if we got White for Reid. White is just the laziest bloke I have seen on the field.

 

[Riders of Rohan]

Spangher would be a good get for you guys. He's won 6 out of the 7 games he has played in for the club, Sydney never lost playing against him at WC and he never lost a reserves game. So he's kind of our lucky charm.

So thinking about it, with a straight swap you'd be able to get a new lucky charm to replace Blair when he is delisted this year.

He also beat Geelong this year, and he only played them once!

 

[entourage]

Spangher? Pushing it maybe, but Reid is pretty good and we'd need a good return.

Sorry, not quite sure what you mean by that. Maybe i should clarify...If we were offered White for Reid i would definitely say not. Mix that in with the suggestion we'd have to give up a draft pick as well for White, even more hell-to-tha no.
You've confused me lol

 

[Ant85]

Sydney's one of the few AFL teams we have a good trade history with.

But Reid's not going anywhere mate.

Who besides Carlton is stupid enough to trade a gun KPP?

 

[Riders of Rohan]

Depends if you want something for them or willing to let them walk for nothing into the PSD.

 

[coopernewf]

Is Reid seriously wanting to head to Sydney? Where's the link at?

 

[entourage]

Don't think so, cooper, don't stress!

 

[scruffydog]

If he wants to leave to play with his brother, I guess there would be no point trying to stop him. And with Sydney not being one of our mortal enemies (especially since they haven't beaten us in a million years) I wouldn't feel too bad about sending Reid there - but I certainly would prefer to keep him. He's still quite young and has potential to be simply amazing.

Also, Riders, this way we get to see Brother v Brother matchups, which are fairly rare, and add a little bit more interest to our games. Think of it that way

 

[Riders of Rohan]

But scruffy, you can see that when west coast vs Geelong

Don't worry guys, this is only wishful thinking on my part.

Though you do owe us one.

 

[mattys123]

Straight swap for Jesse White or gtfo

Yeah, seems like a fair trade.

An All Australian CHB for a dud forward who has no consistency what so ever.

Jesse White is A DUD, he has never delivered in big games, and had a pretty poor year for the Swans, and he is actually older then Reid.

Don't want, let alone for Reid.

 

[Jedi01]

Straight swap for Folau