reid and brown for picks 2 and 19?

[heartbroken]

Hi there fellow supporters. Would you be (i) rapt, (ii) mildly happy, (iii) indifferent, (iv) annoyed or (v) thoroughly pi$$ed off if the above deal happened between us and Collingwood?

I am not the most knowledgable junior talent expert but I was thinking that if the above deal happened and we could secure a young ruckman in the draft with pick 18 and we were able to secure Haselby in the PSD, our stocks would rise substantially.

Thoughts?

 

[parrot]

From a Carlton point of view I'd be delighted if you did, because we'd get Cotchin with pick #3. But I would have thought trading away pick #2 is just crazy. Reid is ordinary and over-hyped. Brown has shown zip.

 

[hougie]

Rapt.

But it won't happen.

And now we shall play the waiting game... How long will it take fot the Colliwobble supporters come on and abuse all Richmond supporters for thinking we'll get this deal?

 

[Croat tiger]

Richmond won't budge with pick 2 so suck it up pies.

 

[Heckles]

Richmond won't budge with pick 2 so suck it up pies.

hmmm reid hasnt shown any potential this year yet, and bronw has been playing in the williamstown seconds. i dont think richmond are gonna throw away picks 2 and 19 for that.

 

[serpico66]

Will do the deal if the Dogs agree to give Richmond Pick 5 for Reid.

Downgrade from Pick 2 ---> 5 plus pick 19 for Brown

We'll still get one of Cotchin, Palmer, Masten or Morton with pick 5

 

[Ah Cheung]

Annoyed. If the pies want pick 2, they need to pay more than what its worth. We have no obligation to help them out. They can give us Reid and Brown for just pick 2, but that won't happen.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

iv for me.

 

[Deledio2Conca]

If we didnt have to give up #19 I'd do it.

 

[blaisee]

pick 2 is going no-where

 

[David3030]

I'll take Reid and Brown for pick 19.

If Collingwood are Judd's preferred option we should squueze the gonads out of them. Reid abd Brown don't fit that bracket for mine.

 

[tony_montana]

the only way pick 2 goes is to land judd direct otherwise forget abt trading it

 

[SolidTiger]

For picks 2 and 19 I'd be annoyed. If it was just for pick 2 I'd be indifferent.

 

[Dr Sanchez]

You blokes are ^@$% stupid %@#$%'s if you pass that up. Both were top 10 picks in the super draft of 2006 and both are key position players. You are all probably the same @#%@#'s who wanted Fiora before Pavlich and Tembling before Franklin.

WAKE TIGER SUPPORTERS - GET SOME ^$@%% KEY POSITION PLAYERS

 

[blaisee]

You blokes are ^@$% stupid %@#$%'s if you pass that up. Both were top 10 picks in the super draft of 2006 and both are key position players. You are all probably the same @#%@#'s who wanted Fiora before Pavlich and Tembling before Franklin.

WAKE TIGER SUPPORTERS - GET SOME ^$@%% KEY POSITION PLAYERS

settle down dr

judd is your problem, not ours

 

[tigers71]

pick 2 is going no-where

It going somewhere, being used on Trent Cotchin or Cale Morton!!!

 

[Ah Cheung]

You blokes are ^@$% stupid %@#$%'s if you pass that up. Both were top 10 picks in the super draft of 2006 and both are key position players. You are all probably the same @#%@#'s who wanted Fiora before Pavlich and Tembling before Franklin.

WAKE TIGER SUPPORTERS - GET SOME ^$@%% KEY POSITION PLAYERS

Need to relax on the prozacs sanchez, didnt realise u loved the tiges so passionately.

 

[Tyger]

You blokes are ^@$% stupid %@#$%'s if you pass that up. Both were top 10 picks in the super draft of 2006 and both are key position players. You are all probably the same @#%@#'s who wanted Fiora before Pavlich and Tembling before Franklin.

WAKE TIGER SUPPORTERS - GET SOME ^$@%% KEY POSITION PLAYERS

Will they be enough for Judd?

 

[Dr Sanchez]

Will they be enough for Judd?

Forget Judd, just trying to give you blokes a leg up.

How good are prozacs?

 

[Bazzar]

the only way pick 2 goes is to land judd direct otherwise forget abt trading it

Why cant the others see this as well.

Stuffed if i would want reid and brown and give up pick 2 when we could use it to get one of the best players in our generation

 

[Weaver]

Stuffed if i would want reid and brown and give up pick 2 when we could use it to get one of the best players in our generation

Who is this guarenteed one of the best players in our generation?

People so HUGELY overvalue draft picks. It has become a near religious obsession with accumulating and spending them.

 

[Don Logan]

Who is this guarenteed one of the best players in our generation?

People so HUGELY overvalue draft picks. It has become a near religious obsession with accumulating and spending them.

If you were list manager Damian would you entertain that swap??

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Pick 2 for Brown and Reid id do in a heartbeat.Why should we give up pick 19?
In fact id push West Coast to chuck in pick 13 our way.I,ve said it 100 times We have to let it be known to West Coast its in their best interests to jump in bed with us.Thats the key.

 

[Harvey Leadpipe]

Who is this guarenteed one of the best players in our generation?

People so HUGELY overvalue draft picks. It has become a near religious obsession with accumulating and spending them.

Including clubs themselves?

I'd do it, but it is because of the fact above that Miller may be able to squeeze quite a bit out of the No.2 pick, especially this year when Judd is somewhere in the equation.

As long as it is used for kids (ie, under 22-23) where the bulk of our other development lies, bring it on.

 

[Terry 2001]

How about a 4 way deal to secure us two KPP and a Ruckman

Say Pick 2 >>>>>> Collingwood >>>>>>>> on traded to Westcoast with Pick 14 for Judd

Reid and Brown >>>>>>>> Richmond for pick 2

Pick 19 (ours) and a Collingwood fringe player eg Rhyce Shaw >>>>>>>>> Brisbane

Cameron Wood >>>>>>> Richmond

Therefore
Richmond loose pick 2, 19 and gain Reid, Brown and Wood.
Collingwood loose Reid, Brown and Shaw and get Judd.
West coast loose Judd and get pick 2 and 14.
Brisbane gets pick 19 and Shaw for Wood.

Collingwood miss out a little but they want Judd so tough luck.