Richmond's Draft Picks 2007

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Will try and be nice here...

Cotchin I agree with, but is a monty to go at 1.

Could well be the case, but I think given the 3 sides that could have the #1 pick (Richmond, Melbourne, Carlton) would be keen to add a 200 cm, athletic, ruckman/goal kicking forward in Matty Kruezer to their list.

Cotchin is a gun also; I'd say its between him and Chris Masten from East Freo at this stage for #2/#3.

Ur looking rather silly saying Bellchambers at 3. He is a battler and a 3rd round pick at best.

Agreed, there is no way in hell Tom Bellchambers will be taken at #3. Possibly a 2nd rounder.

Bongetti is not a pick 35 either and I can assure u is not on Richmonds radar.

I don't think you can assure anything.

But Bongetti will go BEFORE pick #35.

 

[santa claws]

Do people agree with the following trades for picks.

Schulz : pick 15 -20
Pettifer: pick 25-35
Tuck: pick 40-50
Krakouerick 45-55
Jackson 55-65
Tivendale 45-55
Johnson 35-45

Delist: Hartigan, Moore, P. Bowden, Howat, Graham, Knoble. If clubs want our delisted players anywhere from 55 +

It would give us lots of picks to ensure a great drafting period with the likelihood of a good player in the PSD. Plus the best rookie list players.

Have I missed anyone?

Thoughts?

typical richmond we missed the boat. these blokes should have been gone at the end of last yr in preparation for the deepest draft in history.

all of the above are delistable or would not be missed bar 2. tuck and knobel.

for all their deficiencies we cant replace them. we dont have many big bodied inside onballers like tuck. get rid of him that would leave just foley.
maybe cogs and maybe one of the kids if they step up.

same goes for knobel we have 1 ruckman aside from knobel, simmo.it would be unfair to ask simmo to go around next yr as the sole ruckman look what has happened this yr.if we delist knobel we have to get a recycled ready to go ruckman from somewhere to replace him. as well as take one with one of our first 3 picks. and if graham goes we will need to rookie list another at least.

 

[Dominate11]

Could well be the case, but I think given the 3 sides that could have the #1 pick (Richmond, Melbourne, Carlton) would be keen to add a 200 cm, athletic, ruckman/goal kicking forward in Matty Kruezer to their list.

Cotchin is a gun also; I'd say its between him and Chris Masten from East Freo at this stage for #2/#3.




Agreed, there is no way in hell Tom Bellchambers will be taken at #3. Possibly a 2nd rounder.



I don't think you can assure anything.

But Bongetti will go BEFORE pick #35.

Of course I can assure u this... especially if I work for Richmond.
And im telling u Bongetti is not rated by the tiges!!!

 

[PLSC]

haha so the "richmond brainstrust" dont rate him

thats a sure sign the kid will be a good player!

good luck to him

 

[crashandbashruckmen]

Draft Strategy that Richmond may insert for this years trading and national U18’s championships in late June to Novembers / Decembers drafts.

As most would attest to, Richmond is required to rebuild now. We did not 2 years ago, and unfortunately Hawthorn and Collingwood have. They are not that far ahead of us and if we do things right, we could be ahead of both after the selections are made later in the year.

A couple of points:
• Richmond needs 2 Crash and Bash ruckmen for centre square work.
• Richmond requires more 2 – way runners that hurt when we have the ball, and negate when other sides do. We have too many downhill skiers at present. Tambling, Deledio, Meyer, Howat, Pettifer, Tuck Schulz. All have big areas of concern. Can it be rectified? Not all of them. See below.

This year’s crop. Not as deep this year, but quality will be found through to pick 40-50. We should trade accordingly.

Schulz: Trade with Doggies: For 3rd Round pick Cameron Faulkner, and Minson/Tim Walsh.
Pettifer: Trade with St Kilda for 3rd round Pick.
Tuck: Trade with Collingwood for 3rd round pick.

Delist: These players will never win Richmond a premiership. On ya bikes! Can you do it all at once? Doubtful but I would for our assault in 2011 or was that 3011?

Jackson, Moore, Howat, Knobel, Bowden. P, Hyde, Krakeour, Graham, Tivendale

Players in this years Championships:

I have stayed away from looking at interstate only Ebert, Masten are probably worthy. Some might improve also later. We do not want the go-home factor again. Re. Danny Meyer.

People can work out who the players play for themselves, or watch the carnival.


Midfield / Back flanks / Wings / Pockets. Nearly in order:

1. Trent Cotchin
2. James Polkinghorn
3. Aaron Joseph ( I love this blokes aggression)
4. Luke Potts
5. Kane Smith
6. Nicholas Peters
7. Jackson Hall
8. Kris Nye
9. Scott Selwood
10. Rory Sloane
11. Ashley Arrowsmith
12. Ricky Hurley

Ruckmen / Resting Forward Pockets.

1. Matt Kreuzer
2. Tom Bellchambers
3. Will Sullivan
4. Mark Wescott.


Spine / Utilities:

1. Andrew Otten
2. Matthew Lobbe
3. Tobias Thoolen
4. Hugh Sandilands
5. Jeremy Laidler
6. Shaun Dixon
7. Callan Ward
8. Tim Bongetti (coming off a knee. Is it sound?)


So how should we attack the draft days?

• 3 Ruckmen
• 2 KPP (preferably defenders)
• 3 mids
• 2 utilities

My selections long ways out from home are: Keep in mind I don’t think Carlton will win another 3 games.

2: Matt Kreuzer / Trent Cotchin

18: Bellchambers
19: Otten
3rd round saints: Polkinghorne
3rd round dogs Thoolen
3rd round Pies Lobbe
35 Joseph
51 Hall
67 Peters
83 Nye

PSD: Target Charman / Dowler / Meesan, for mine.

Rookies: Howat / Graham off: 2 of the players off the listed players still available after draft day named above.

I would like: Shaun Dixon and Mark Wescott / Nye. Or Gazzo (Coburg)

So If I were to get my way we would have 8 picks in the top 51 of a draft where afterwards it gets slim pickings. 2011 here we come!

• Note: At This stage Kreuzer is my number one pick. He is going to be an outstanding, outstanding footballer. Mids can be found later in drafts as we all know.

• Let’s prey that Carlton and Melbourne pick up soon.

• We cannot afford to win games if it to the detriment of the priority pick, pick 1 and first pickings at the rookie and PSD’s draft selections.

• I can hear the sleeping giant about to waken!

• If we follow a similar structure to the one above, we will exceed Collingwood, Hawthorn and Carlton by the length of the Flemington straight. In my eyes we would have the much greater player personnel.

• 2011 here we come.

• Keep in mind many things can happen before the lead up to the draft. However the names mentioned are quality players and will further advance our mighty football club.

• Enjoy reading! Most welcome to hear thoughts and comments.

• Thanks in advance.

 

[crashandbashruckmen]

Draft Strategy that Richmond may insert for this years trading and national U18’s championships in late June to Novembers / Decembers drafts.

As most would attest to, Richmond is required to rebuild now. We did not 2 years ago, and unfortunately Hawthorn and Collingwood have. They are not that far ahead of us and if we do things right, we could be ahead of both after the selections are made later in the year.

A couple of points:
• Richmond needs 2 Crash and Bash ruckmen for centre square work.
• Richmond requires more 2 – way runners that hurt when we have the ball, and negate when other sides do. We have too many downhill skiers at present. Tambling, Deledio, Meyer, Howat, Pettifer, Tuck Schulz. All have big areas of concern. Can it be rectified? Not all of them. See below.

This year’s crop. Not as deep this year, but quality will be found through to pick 40-50. We should trade accordingly.

Schulz: Trade with Doggies: For 3rd Round pick Cameron Faulkner, and Minson/Tim Walsh.
Pettifer: Trade with St Kilda for 3rd round Pick.
Tuck: Trade with Collingwood for 3rd round pick.

Delist: These players will never win Richmond a premiership. On ya bikes! Can you do it all at once? Doubtful but I would for our assault in 2011 or was that 3011?

Jackson, Moore, Howat, Knobel, Bowden. P, Hyde, Krakeour, Graham, Tivendale

Players in this years Championships:

I have stayed away from looking at interstate only Ebert, Masten are probably worthy. Some might improve also later. We do not want the go-home factor again. Re. Danny Meyer.

People can work out who the players play for themselves, or watch the carnival.


Midfield / Back flanks / Wings / Pockets. Nearly in order:

1. Trent Cotchin
2. James Polkinghorn
3. Aaron Joseph ( I love this blokes aggression)
4. Luke Potts
5. Kane Smith
6. Nicholas Peters
7. Jackson Hall
8. Kris Nye
9. Scott Selwood
10. Rory Sloane
11. Ashley Arrowsmith
12. Ricky Hurley

Ruckmen / Resting Forward Pockets.

1. Matt Kreuzer
2. Tom Bellchambers
3. Will Sullivan
4. Mark Wescott.


Spine / Utilities:

1. Andrew Otten
2. Matthew Lobbe
3. Tobias Thoolen
4. Hugh Sandilands
5. Jeremy Laidler
6. Shaun Dixon
7. Callan Ward
8. Tim Bongetti (coming off a knee. Is it sound?)


So how should we attack the draft days?

• 3 Ruckmen
• 2 KPP (preferably defenders)
• 3 mids
• 2 utilities

My selections long ways out from home are: Keep in mind I don’t think Carlton will win another 3 games.

2: Matt Kreuzer / Trent Cotchin

18: Bellchambers
19: Otten
3rd round saints: Polkinghorne
3rd round dogs Thoolen
3rd round Pies Lobbe
35 Joseph
51 Hall
67 Peters
83 Nye

PSD: Target Charman / Dowler / Meesan, for mine.

Rookies: Howat / Graham off: 2 of the players off the listed players still available after draft day named above.

I would like: Shaun Dixon and Mark Wescott / Nye. Or Gazzo (Coburg)

So If I were to get my way we would have 8 picks in the top 51 of a draft where afterwards it gets slim pickings. 2011 here we come!

• Note: At This stage Kreuzer is my number one pick. He is going to be an outstanding, outstanding footballer. Mids can be found later in drafts as we all know.

• Let’s prey that Carlton and Melbourne pick up soon.

• We cannot afford to win games if it to the detriment of the priority pick, pick 1 and first pickings at the rookie and PSD’s draft selections.

• I can hear the sleeping giant about to waken!

• If we follow a similar structure to the one above, we will exceed Collingwood, Hawthorn and Carlton by the length of the Flemington straight. In my eyes we would have the much greater player personnel.

• 2011 here we come.

• Keep in mind many things can happen before the lead up to the draft. However the names mentioned are quality players and will further advance our mighty football club.

• Enjoy reading! Most welcome to hear thoughts and comments.

• Thanks in advance.

 

[PLSC]

your first post would of been quality if the layout wasnt so ****ed up!

2nd post though is on the money!

 

[RichosGuns]

crashandbashruckman...

i like you

 

[beaver fever]

Lol i've read this post on 3 different richmond forums.

 

[wart101]

Draft Strategy that Richmond may insert for this years trading and national U18’s championships in late June to Novembers / Decembers drafts.

As most would attest to, Richmond is required to rebuild now. We did not 2 years ago, and unfortunately Hawthorn and Collingwood have. They are not that far ahead of us and if we do things right, we could be ahead of both after the selections are made later in the year.

A couple of points:
• Richmond needs 2 Crash and Bash ruckmen for centre square work.
• Richmond requires more 2 – way runners that hurt when we have the ball, and negate when other sides do. We have too many downhill skiers at present. Tambling, Deledio, Meyer, Howat, Pettifer, Tuck Schulz. All have big areas of concern. Can it be rectified? Not all of them. See below.

This year’s crop. Not as deep this year, but quality will be found through to pick 40-50. We should trade accordingly.

Schulz: Trade with Doggies: For 3rd Round pick Cameron Faulkner, and Minson/Tim Walsh.
Pettifer: Trade with St Kilda for 3rd round Pick.
Tuck: Trade with Collingwood for 3rd round pick.

Delist: These players will never win Richmond a premiership. On ya bikes! Can you do it all at once? Doubtful but I would for our assault in 2011 or was that 3011?

Jackson, Moore, Howat, Knobel, Bowden. P, Hyde, Krakeour, Graham, Tivendale

Players in this years Championships:

I have stayed away from looking at interstate only Ebert, Masten are probably worthy. Some might improve also later. We do not want the go-home factor again. Re. Danny Meyer.

People can work out who the players play for themselves, or watch the carnival.


Midfield / Back flanks / Wings / Pockets. Nearly in order:

1. Trent Cotchin
2. James Polkinghorn
3. Aaron Joseph ( I love this blokes aggression)
4. Luke Potts
5. Kane Smith
6. Nicholas Peters
7. Jackson Hall
8. Kris Nye
9. Scott Selwood
10. Rory Sloane
11. Ashley Arrowsmith
12. Ricky Hurley

Ruckmen / Resting Forward Pockets.

1. Matt Kreuzer
2. Tom Bellchambers
3. Will Sullivan
4. Mark Wescott.


Spine / Utilities:

1. Andrew Otten
2. Matthew Lobbe
3. Tobias Thoolen
4. Hugh Sandilands
5. Jeremy Laidler
6. Shaun Dixon
7. Callan Ward
8. Tim Bongetti (coming off a knee. Is it sound?)


So how should we attack the draft days?

• 3 Ruckmen
• 2 KPP (preferably defenders)
• 3 mids
• 2 utilities

My selections long ways out from home are: Keep in mind I don’t think Carlton will win another 3 games.

2: Matt Kreuzer / Trent Cotchin

18: Bellchambers
19: Otten
3rd round saints: Polkinghorne
3rd round dogs Thoolen
3rd round Pies Lobbe
35 Joseph
51 Hall
67 Peters
83 Nye

PSD: Target Charman / Dowler / Meesan, for mine.

Rookies: Howat / Graham off: 2 of the players off the listed players still available after draft day named above.

I would like: Shaun Dixon and Mark Wescott / Nye. Or Gazzo (Coburg)

So If I were to get my way we would have 8 picks in the top 51 of a draft where afterwards it gets slim pickings. 2011 here we come!

• Note: At This stage Kreuzer is my number one pick. He is going to be an outstanding, outstanding footballer. Mids can be found later in drafts as we all know.

• Let’s prey that Carlton and Melbourne pick up soon.

• We cannot afford to win games if it to the detriment of the priority pick, pick 1 and first pickings at the rookie and PSD’s draft selections.

• I can hear the sleeping giant about to waken!

• If we follow a similar structure to the one above, we will exceed Collingwood, Hawthorn and Carlton by the length of the Flemington straight. In my eyes we would have the much greater player personnel.

• 2011 here we come.

• Keep in mind many things can happen before the lead up to the draft. However the names mentioned are quality players and will further advance our mighty football club.

• Enjoy reading! Most welcome to hear thoughts and comments.

• Thanks in advance.

shutup

 

[PHX]

lol same, I've already replied to you.

 

[C4[2]Yo`DooR]

Of course I can assure u this... especially if I work for Richmond.
And im telling u Bongetti is not rated by the tiges!!!

....

 

[SolidTiger]

Draft Strategy that Richmond may insert for this years trading and national U18’s championships in late June to Novembers / Decembers drafts.

As most would attest to, Richmond is required to rebuild now. We did not 2 years ago, and unfortunately Hawthorn and Collingwood have. They are not that far ahead of us and if we do things right, we could be ahead of both after the selections are made later in the year.

A couple of points:
• Richmond needs 2 Crash and Bash ruckmen for centre square work.
• Richmond requires more 2 – way runners that hurt when we have the ball, and negate when other sides do. We have too many downhill skiers at present. Tambling, Deledio, Meyer, Howat, Pettifer, Tuck Schulz. All have big areas of concern. Can it be rectified? Not all of them. See below.

This year’s crop. Not as deep this year, but quality will be found through to pick 40-50. We should trade accordingly.

Schulz: Trade with Doggies: For 3rd Round pick Cameron Faulkner, and Minson/Tim Walsh.
Pettifer: Trade with St Kilda for 3rd round Pick.
Tuck: Trade with Collingwood for 3rd round pick.

Delist: These players will never win Richmond a premiership. On ya bikes! Can you do it all at once? Doubtful but I would for our assault in 2011 or was that 3011?

Jackson, Moore, Howat, Knobel, Bowden. P, Hyde, Krakeour, Graham, Tivendale

Players in this years Championships:

I have stayed away from looking at interstate only Ebert, Masten are probably worthy. Some might improve also later. We do not want the go-home factor again. Re. Danny Meyer.

People can work out who the players play for themselves, or watch the carnival.


Midfield / Back flanks / Wings / Pockets. Nearly in order:

1. Trent Cotchin
2. James Polkinghorn
3. Aaron Joseph ( I love this blokes aggression)
4. Luke Potts
5. Kane Smith
6. Nicholas Peters
7. Jackson Hall
8. Kris Nye
9. Scott Selwood
10. Rory Sloane
11. Ashley Arrowsmith
12. Ricky Hurley

Ruckmen / Resting Forward Pockets.

1. Matt Kreuzer
2. Tom Bellchambers
3. Will Sullivan
4. Mark Wescott.


Spine / Utilities:

1. Andrew Otten
2. Matthew Lobbe
3. Tobias Thoolen
4. Hugh Sandilands
5. Jeremy Laidler
6. Shaun Dixon
7. Callan Ward
8. Tim Bongetti (coming off a knee. Is it sound?)


So how should we attack the draft days?

• 3 Ruckmen
• 2 KPP (preferably defenders)
• 3 mids
• 2 utilities

My selections long ways out from home are: Keep in mind I don’t think Carlton will win another 3 games.

2: Matt Kreuzer / Trent Cotchin

18: Bellchambers
19: Otten
3rd round saints: Polkinghorne
3rd round dogs Thoolen
3rd round Pies Lobbe
35 Joseph
51 Hall
67 Peters
83 Nye

PSD: Target Charman / Dowler / Meesan, for mine.

Rookies: Howat / Graham off: 2 of the players off the listed players still available after draft day named above.

I would like: Shaun Dixon and Mark Wescott / Nye. Or Gazzo (Coburg)

So If I were to get my way we would have 8 picks in the top 51 of a draft where afterwards it gets slim pickings. 2011 here we come!

• Note: At This stage Kreuzer is my number one pick. He is going to be an outstanding, outstanding footballer. Mids can be found later in drafts as we all know.

• Let’s prey that Carlton and Melbourne pick up soon.

• We cannot afford to win games if it to the detriment of the priority pick, pick 1 and first pickings at the rookie and PSD’s draft selections.

• I can hear the sleeping giant about to waken!

• If we follow a similar structure to the one above, we will exceed Collingwood, Hawthorn and Carlton by the length of the Flemington straight. In my eyes we would have the much greater player personnel.

• 2011 here we come.

• Keep in mind many things can happen before the lead up to the draft. However the names mentioned are quality players and will further advance our mighty football club.

• Enjoy reading! Most welcome to hear thoughts and comments.

• Thanks in advance.

Extremely good analysis. I am impressed with the amount of research you must have done. It would be great if you were in Richmonds recruitment department. Though I disagree with the Shultz trade.