Preview Rnd 6 - Carlton v Hawthorn Sunday April 28th 3.20PM @ UTAS - Team Post #1331

[spry]

LOB is named on the HFF is this anything to go by or are they playing silly buggers? I like the idea of him doing a run with role on a damaging half back and his disposal inside 50 could be damaging.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Juddernaut08]

5?

McKay Casboult maybe Charlie. Would never call McGovern a KPF and who’s the other?

Who do you think I might be referring to Soapy? Perhaps being a bit loose with the term to make a point, but if they're above 190cm and play predominantly as a marking forward, then ...

 

[Laphroaig]

5?

McKay Casboult maybe Charlie. Would never call McGovern a KPF and who’s the other?

Mcgovern and Silvagni are both mediums. Neither could be accused of being a small forward. So unless Curnow or Silvagni plays outside the forward line we have 3 tall and two medium forwards.

Gibbons is going to be a busy boy.

 

[Soapy V]

Who do you think I might be referring to Soapy? Perhaps being a bit loose with the term to make a point, but if they're above 190cm and play predominantly as a marking forward, then ...

No idea. Don’t see any in the side

 

[Arr0w]

Thank you. It was irrelevant to the subject at hand the first time, too.

But accurate

 

[Soapy V]

Mcgovern and Silvagni are both mediums. Neither could be accused of being a small forward. So unless Curnow or Silvagni plays outside the forward line we have 3 tall and two medium forwards.

Gibbons is going to be a busy boy.

Mediums aren’t KPF. Murphy Fisher O’Brien Curnow Dow Gibbons SPS will all have stints up forward. Looks good to me

 

[Blue and Blue]

If the blues play with this much agro I will be very pleased

 

[blue healer]

LOB is named on the HFF is this anything to go by or are they playing silly buggers? I like the idea of him doing a run with role on a damaging half back and his disposal inside 50 could be damaging.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Won't believe it until he puts that HFF apron on.

 

[Laphroaig]

But accurate

I exercise my right to disagree.

Move on.

 

[Aphrodite]

I exercise my right to disagree.

Move on.

How about you both give it a rest and move on!

 

[marcmurphy#3]

In a perfect world (where we had decent small forwards), going with one less tall forward would of course be a better option. But where the change is Polson for Charlie, I'm perfectly happy to go in with this line-up. Polson's 61% game-time and 2-tackles are hardly difficult to replace, and I'd assume this will force Levi to spend slightly more time on the bench (which is perfectly fine).

 

[Soapy V]

If the blues play with this much agro I will be very pleased

Agro? Been pretty good IMO

 

[blue healer]

Agro? Been pretty good IMO

Think he means the agro in the thread.

 

[Laphroaig]

Mediums aren’t KPF. Murphy Fisher O’Brien Curnow Dow Gibbons SPS will all have stints up forward. Looks good to me

Murphy Fisher O’Brien Curnow Dow Gibbons SPS are also vastly different types to McGovern and Silvagni.

That's why we have the popular term medium forward between KPF and smalls.

I will be interested to see how we actually set up. If the way we set up turns out to be McGovern, Silvagni, Curnow C, McKay and Casboult plus one unfortunate other, I would be very worried.

 

[HBF]

A small player goes out who a lot said nothing and Charlie comes in. ONE change and all of a sudden we are too tall?

We were borderline too tall last week. As others have said, if Charlie plays up the ground then I can live with that. But Gov, Harry, Cas, Charlie and Jack in the one forward line is TOO TALL

 

[Soapy V]

Think he means the agro in the thread.

So did I.

 

[Soapy V]

We were borderline too tall last week. As others have said, if Charlie plays up the ground then I can live with that. But Gov, Harry, Cas, Charlie and Jack in the one forward line is TOO TALL

Agree IF we line up that way

 

[HBF]

The pissing contest in this thread and others is becoming very tiresome.

 

[Eiffel 65]

It is windy as crap right now here in Launceston ..expect it to be just as bad Sunday...so the club needs to take this into consideration re game plan

5 tall forwards.................

 

[murphster]

Curnow for Polson is a good change

Finally we can move on

I wish Arrow but the too tall crowd will start now.

 

[Laphroaig]

In a perfect world (where we had decent small forwards), going with one less tall forward would of course be a better option. But where the change is Polson for Charlie, I'm perfectly happy to go in with this line-up. Polson's 61% game-time and 2-tackles are hardly difficult to replace, and I'd assume this will force Levi to spend slightly more time on the bench (which is perfectly fine).

That's the rub. Midfield was very very good last week. Team as selected potentially disrupts that.

With a very young midfield we can not afford to change rucks off the bench. The young mids need the bench inches to stay in the game. THere are multiple other flow ons. Gibbons' performance when allowed mid minutes was a major plus. Can we afford to move him out of a valley of the giants front 6?

Like many, I like the thought of Curnow C as a roaming giant. Eventually. But I doubt if he has the footy nous to jump into that new Kouta role just yet. So if we try that one, the midfield is again disrupted.

All will become clear on the day, no doubt, for good or for bad.

 

[ForYouBlue]

The ol' 4 tall trick again.

I think after a functioning forward system last week, if we fail to do the same this week we can put the 4 tall thing to bed with a nightcap of bleach...

Obviously there are lots of variables that would make it harder to tell if that is the defining factor, but I would say past evidence suggests the onus is on the 4 tall trick to prove its worth.

 

[CFC18]

How about you both give it a rest and move on!

Holds little weight to say 'both' when you overlook several of Arrow's posts saying move on and quote one poster as soon as they retort.

 

[TooBlue14]

I’ll repeat 4 tall forwards is better than 3 and Polson. Curnow is just as quick and tackles more.

 

[Mr_Plow]

The pissing contest in this thread and others is becoming very tiresome.

It's good for the board's post count, though. Still some way to catching Adelaide for #1 spot.