List Mgmt. Rookies Eardley and Bathie delisted

[crocsta]

If they are making space for sully on thr rookie list i can understand it,but i think he willneed to be taken in the nd anyway.

Obviously he's had a decent year in VFL but Sully look slow to me. Is he slow?

 

[Vdubs]

It may mean they view his chances of playing in the seniors as minimal.

Minimal if we have Shaw.

 

[CharacterFirst]

If they are making space for sully on thr rookie list i can understand it,but i think he willneed to be taken in the nd anyway.

Hey PO,

Do you have Sully particulars - i.e. age, height etc

 

[THE CAT WRANGLER]

I've got to say I was surprised @ Eardley I think he is better than shearing ham
As for Bathie he has improved every year however there isn't a place for him short term

 

[Vdubs]

Hey PO,

Do you have Sully particulars - i.e. age, height etc

Sully dob 15/10/92, 196 cm, 95 kg
Bathie dob 15/4/87, 198 cm, 102 kg

 

[Stig_90]

I would have preferred they cut Sheringham or Bews before Eardley.

 

[CatTricks]

Why the **** would we want to bring a cancer like Heath Shaw into our club?

 

[Vdubs]

Why the **** would we want to bring a cancer like Heath Shaw into our club?

We are great at chemotherapy
Without his brat mates around him, and with our way of dealing with issues, he would be a revelation for us.
At his best, an excellent player.

 

[CharacterFirst]

Sully dob 15/10/92, 196 cm, 95 kg
Bathie dob 15/4/87, 198 cm, 102 kg

Ta VD.

Is he slow, as some are suggesting?

 

[Vdubs]

Ta VD.

Is he slow, as some are suggesting?

If we are judging on Sunday's game, I can hardly recall Sully, while Bathie looked imposing.
Sully hasn't looked that slow during the year, iirc.

 

[Stig_90]

Why the **** would we want to bring a cancer like Heath Shaw into our club?

I really don't think he's a cancer, he's more like a class clown.

 

[CatTricks]

We are great at chemotherapy
Without his brat mates around him, and with our way of dealing with issues, he would be a revelation for us.
At his best, an excellent player.

He is a dickhead... Why anyone would want him around our young blokes is beyond me...

 

[FredLeDeux]

We are great at chemotherapy
Without his brat mates around him, and with our way of dealing with issues, he would be a revelation for us.
At his best, an excellent player.

I knew him from football/cricket as a 12-year old.
He was the same deadset boofhead then as he is now.
He doesn't need chemotherapy, he needs a lobotomy.

 

[JUBJUB]

We are great at chemotherapy

We cured Justin Murphy.He met fist #1,fist #2,fist #3 and fist #4.
A quick cure and he was on his way back home

 

[CatTricks]

I knew him from football/cricket as a 12-year old.
He was the same deadset boofhead then as he is now.
He doesn't need chemotherapy, he needs a lobotomy.

Sounds like he really is Collingwood through and through. He can ****ing stay there as far as I'm concerned.

 

[Turbocat]

Shaw say's Geelong or North , well I say after the great things North has done to us recently like picking Thompson before us then trading Hmac to us ,the least we can do is be benevolent and let him go to Kanga's

 

[crocsta]

If we are judging on Sunday's game, I can hardly recall Sully, while Bathie looked imposing.
Sully hasn't looked that slow during the year, iirc.

I thought he looked slow in a few contests but I didn't realise he was 196cm. Perhaps he moves ok for his size.

 

[darren forssman]

efa:

I really don't think he's a cancer, he's more like a ass clown.

 

[darren forssman]

I knew him from football/cricket as a 12-year old.
He was the same deadset boofhead then as he is now.
He doesn't need chemotherapy, he needs a lobotomy.

is he an elthamite or burrahead?

 

[FredLeDeux]

is he an elthamite or burrahead?

Worse, Diamo.

 

[darren forssman]

Worse, Diamo.

ahhh yes, the shaw family was a bit further out now that you mentioned diamo.

too much diamo boyz influence?

 

[FredLeDeux]

ahhh yes, the shaw family was a bit further out now that you mentioned diamo.

too much diamo boyz influence?

Yeah, any diamo boyz influence is too much.

 

[Vdubs]

Shaw say's Geelong or North , well I say after the great things North has done to us recently like picking Thompson before us then trading Hmac to us ,the least we can do is be benevolent and let him go to Kanga's

Betts sounds NM bound; they don't have space for 2 FA's?

 

[Pivo]

I still hope we reselect Bathie- he showed some real poise v Hawks on Sunday, and can play in defence.
What are we lacking?- a big bodied fit mobile unit who can mark and play at both ends. That is Bathie, and he is mature.

I wasn't sold on Bathie earlier in the year but he sounded a bit towards the end.

I wasn't surprised to see him let go but I'd think another side would give him a crack next year.

Personally I thought he looked a bit at sea down back but seemed more at home up forward.

And while I have you, I need to pick your brain (but in a different thread).

EDIT: "...but he sounded..." WTF am I talking about?? This Eardley delisting is hitting me hard.

 

[Vdubs]

I wasn't sold on Bathie earlier in the year but he sounded a bit towards the end.

I wasn't surprised to see him let go but I'd think another side would give him a crack next year.

Personally I thought he looked a bit at sea down back but seemed more at home up forward.

And while I have you, I need to pick your brain (but in a different thread).

Go ahead!! but I have been the victim of a few magpie attacks this past week , again. Running in September is dangerous.
Puns intended