Round 15 votes

[MarksGirl-kbcrowgirl]

Best On Ground

5 Matthew Clarke
4 Matthew Bode
3 Tyson Edwards
2 James Gallagher
1 Nigel Smart

Best Team Man

3 Matthew Clarke
2 Matthew Shir
1 Mark Stevens

Rookie of the year

3 Graham Johncock
2 Marty Mattner
1 Brent Reilly


k
xx

 

[sapaul]

BOG

5- Tyson Edwards
4- Matthew Bode
3- Chris Ladhams
2- Mark Bickley
1- Matthew Clarke

TTM

3- Matthew Clarke
2- Mark Bickley
1- Andrew Crowell

Rookie

3- Chris Ladhams
2- James Gallagher(if eligible?)
1- Matthew Shir

 

[noddy]

BoG

5 votes = M Bode
4 votes = C Ladhams
3 votes = T Edwards
2 votes = M Clarke
1 vote = M Shir

BTM

3 votes = M Bickley
2 votes = S Goodwin
1 vote = A Crowell

Rookie

3 votes = C Ladhams
2 votes = M Shir
1 vote = M Mattner

 

[dogs105]

BOG

5 - T Edwards
4 - C Ladhams
3 - J Gallagher
4 - M Shir
5 - M Clarke

TEAM

3 - A Crowell
2 - M Clarke
1 - N Smart

ROOKIE

I couldn't be bothered going back to check the elegibility requirements, so I'll just list the top players that I think might be elegible, and you can take the top three that are.

C Ladhams
J Gallagher
M Shir
G Johncock
M Mattner
M Doughty

If my top 3 are elegible, it makes 3 of my 5 best players rookies. Good sign.

 

[ozgeek]

BOG

5 - T. Edwards
4 - C. Ladhams
3 - J. Gallagher
4 - M. Shir
5 - M. Clarke

TM

3 - M. Bickley
2 - S. Goodwin
1 - A. Crowell

Rookie

3 - G. Johncock
2 - M. Mattner
1 - B. Reilly

A scrappy old match and we didn't finish out the last quarter. We threw away some percentage here.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Eligible Rookies

Heaps to choose from this week ...

Doughty
Finnin
J. Gallagher
Handby
Hentschel
Johncock
Ladhams
Mattner
Reilly
Schell
Schuback
Shir
Shirley
Skipworth
M. Smith

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

BOG
5. Edwards
4. Gallagher
3. Bode
2. Ladhams
1. Clarke

BTM
3. Crowell
2. Goodwin
1. Shir

BR
3. Gallagher
2. Ladhams
1. Shir
(apolgies to Johncock & Mattner her were deserving of a vote this week compared to previous weeks!)

PS If anyone wants to change their rookie votes now they know the eligible list, please let me know.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Cumulative votes so far

6 voters so far, but could everyone please re-look at their rookie votes - particularly how they relate to your BOG votes.

eg. kb you had the top rookies as Johncock, Mattner, Reilly, but with your BOG Gallagher best of the rookies. Similar problem with Noddy & ozgeek. Thanks.

Best on Ground
26 Edwards (5)
17 Ladhams (4)
16 Bode (3)
12 Gallagher (2)
11 Clarke (1)
5 Shir
2 Bickley
1 Smart
90 Total

Best Team Man
9 Crowell (3)
8 Bickley (2)
8 Clarke (2)
6 Goodwin
3 Shir
1 Smart
1 Stevens
36 Total

 

[Crow54]

I'm interested to know how many people here go to the game, and how many watch it on TV?

And if you go to the game, do you listen to the commentary on the radio?

I go to Footy Park every fortnight (lately every week!) and get too caught up in the cheering/supporting to listen to the radio. That's why I don't vote here now, I'm watching both ends of the ground, getting caught up in the chanting, etc., and can never pick more than one or two BOG's.

My point is this: are you influenced by TV or radio commentary when choosing your best players?

 

[MarksGirl-kbcrowgirl]

you are confusing me!

here are my amended rookie votes


3 James Gallagher
2 Graham Johncock
1 Marty Mattner


what is the criteria for a rookie?

Heaps to choose from this week ...

Doughty
Finnin (hot stuff girls! wait till he gets a game )
J. Gallagher
Handby
Hentschel
Johncock
Ladhams
Mattner
Reilly
Schell
Schuback
Shir
Shirley
Skipworth
M. Smith

6 of this list have played in previous years. Why are they still rookies - is it under 50 games?

cheers

k
xx

 

[sapaul]

Originally posted by Crow54
I'm interested to know how many people here go to the game, and how many watch it on TV?

And if you go to the game, do you listen to the commentary on the radio?

My point is this: are you influenced by TV or radio commentary when choosing your best players?

I can't get to games being in the Country and health reasons so watch it on tele and usually listen to 5AA for commentary.

Couldn't care less what the commentators votes are, I just do mine on what I seen.

Originally posted by MarksGirl-kbcrowgirl

what is the criteria for a rookie?
6 of this list have played in previous years. Why are they still rookies - is it under 50 games?

Pretty sure it is under 23 years of age and less than 30 games?

 

[Damp Squarie]

BOG
5 Edwards
4 Clarke
3 Bode
2 Smart
1 Johncock

BTM
3 Edwards
2 Goodwin
1 Ricciuto

ROTY
3 Johncock
2 Mattner
1 Doughty


Gruelling Affair. I went to the game which was no spectacle but Im happy for the points.

Matty Clarke copped one early and done a great job througout.
Bassett was good in the goalsquare.
Our zone defence on the kickouts never worked at the southern end...not sure about the north end

Bullys will be pumped up so whoevr has the "focus" theme this week had better be spot on.

Where is Bienke ?

 

[Spogs]

Finally got to see a game on TV so can have a go at the votes this week. Had to go down to Adelaide though.

BEST:

5. Edwards
4. Bode
3. Clarke
2. Ladhams
1. Bickley

TEAM:

3. Bickley
2. Smart
1. Clarke

YOUNG'UN:

3. Ladhams
2. Gallagher
1. Mattner

How good is it to actually have to think about who to leave out of the rookies? Johncock would have had a mortgage on 3 votes for that performance in the first 10 rounds.

 

[ozgeek]

Re: Cumulative votes so far

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
6 voters so far, but could everyone please re-look at their rookie votes - particularly how they relate to your BOG votes.

eg. kb you had the top rookies as Johncock, Mattner, Reilly, but with your BOG Gallagher best of the rookies. Similar problem with Noddy & ozgeek. Thanks.

Sorry, Kane, I didn't think Gallagher was eligible. Please amend to :-

3 - J. Gallagher
2 - G. Johncock
1 - M. Mattner

Thanks, Ozgeek

 

[ozgeek]

OOOPS !

Last Rookie vote should read 1 - Shir/M. Mattner.

I couldn't leave Mattner out !

The youngsters did us proud !

 

[noddy]

Have redone my rookie votes Kane, have given Chris Ladhams 3 votes,

 

[Blues_Girl]

BOG

5. Edwards
4. Gallagher
3. Bode
2. Clarke
1. Bassett

BTM

3. Goodwin
2. Crowell
1. Shir

BR

3. Gallagher
2. Shir
1. Mattner

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Cumulative votes update

Thanks to everyone who redid their rookie votes. I must admit I forgot who was eligible & had to go back to Ant's orginal post. To think most weeks we have only had up to 3 eligible rookies & this week we had 7 (including Reilly)! It may explain why we dropped off a little at the end. Keep the votes coming in as BTM is particularly close.

Best on Ground
41 Edwards (5)
26 Bode (4)
20 Clarke (3)
19 Ladhams (2)
16 Gallagher (1)
5 Shir
3 Bickley
3 Smart
1 Bassett
1 Johncock
135 Total

Best Team Man
11 Crowell (3)
11 Bickley (3)
11 Goodwin (3)
9 Clarke
4 Shir
3 Edwards
3 Smart
1 Riccuito
1 Stevens
54 Total

Best Rookie
18 Gallagher (3)
14 Ladhams (2)
8 Shir (1)
7 Mattner
7 Johncock
1 Doughty
55 Total

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Well it looks like the final votes then. Just 1 minor change, I have made an executive decision to give Crowell, Bickley & Goodwin 2 BTM votes each (ie. 1/3rd of 3+2+1) rather than 3 votes each.